[Discussion] Luffy Vs Prime Don Chinjao

[David1996]

Who takes this one ?

 

[Son Ryuto Uzumaki]

Luffy wouldn't have lasted a minute

 

[24 12 11 to troll]

Luffy wouldn't have lasted a minute

Actually we don't know as we haven't seen Luffy all out. I have a feeling that for Chinjao a tie would be his luckiest outcome.

 

[David1996]

Actually we don't know as we haven't seen Luffy all out. I have a feeling that for Chinjao a tie would be his luckiest outcome.

Daaaamn, that's pure underestimation man.

 

[Netferarri]

If Chinjao could take on Garp, then Chinjao could take on Luffy

You must be registered for see images

 

[TheHokage]

Luffy wouldn't have lasted a minute

You're seriously underestimating Luffy here...Don Chinjao was defeated by Garp in one punch and despite how powerful Garp is that wasn't Garp at his strongest either.

Luffy wins - High difficulty.

 

[24 12 11 to troll]

Daaaamn, that's pure underestimation man.

No it isn't. Current Chinjao (with his head back) is probably still inferior to Luffy. You must remember than Luffy hasn't gone all out and the only times he ever does ; the following events happen:
He enters G3 TWICE
He coughs up blood at some point during battle
He relentlessly attacks for a finish.
If Luffy did all that vs Chinjao we missed it.

Current Luffy>>Current Chinjao
Aces bounty was 550m
Ace and Luffy are comparable.
Chinjaos bounty is comprable to Aces and therefore Luffy and Chinjao would be a close match (but I'm leaning towards Luffy winning)

 

[David1996]

No it isn't. Current Chinjao (with his head back) is probably still inferior to Luffy. You must remember than Luffy hasn't gone all out and the only times he ever does ; the following events happen:
He enters G3 TWICE
He coughs up blood at some point during battle
He relentlessly attacks for a finish.
If Luffy did all that vs Chinjao we missed it.

Current Luffy>>Current Chinjao
Aces bounty was 550m
Ace and Luffy are comparable.
Chinjaos bounty is comprable to Aces and therefore Luffy and Chinjao would be a close match (but I'm leaning towards Luffy winning)

Ace eh ? damn, if only Ace didn't die, he'd become the next pirate king...

 

[TheHokage]

Ace eh ? damn, if only Ace didn't die, he'd become the next pirate king...

Ace had no intention of becoming Pirate King...not to mention he relied on his Logia devil fruit to much so he'd have probably ended up dead sooner or later...however I do agree Ace would have been OP as hell if he survived.

 

[SAHAN1993]

Luffy wouldn't have lasted a minute

luffy far too ahead to young roger how don chin take this?and garp take him on a one shot

i think luffy

 

[David1996]

Ace had no intention of becoming Pirate King...not to mention he relied on his Logia devil fruit to much so he'd have probably ended up dead sooner or later...however I do agree Ace would have been OP as hell if he survived.

He did, remember when he met Shanks ?

 

[TheHokage]

He did, remember when he met Shanks ?

But he gave that dream up...hence the reason he said he would make Whitebeard king and when he said the only regret he had was not being able to see Luffy reach his dream which is becoming Pirate King.

Sometime after his meeting with Shanks Ace gave up his dream of becoming Pirate King all he really wanted was to know whether or not he should have been born.

 

[David1996]

But he gave that dream up...hence the reason he said he would make Whitebeard king and when he said the only regret he had was not being able to see Luffy reach his dream which is becoming Pirate King.

Sometime after his meeting with Shanks Ace gave up his dream of becoming Pirate King all he really wanted was to know whether or not he should have been born.

WB himself didn't want to become a PK, even tho Roger gave could have gave him the instruction to go to the final island( forgot the name ), but you're right, Ace would have lost to Luffy if they ever fought for the PK title.

 

[xcoyote]

Prime Chinjao wins.

 

[Hexuze]

Prime Chinjao wins.

Garp looked fairly young back then and he probably above admiral level so it would make sense for him to take Chinjao out in one punch. As for the diff. I would say around mid. Luffy can't win, Chinjao's overall strength has depreciated a lot during those years and that punch from Garp. Plus we've seen Chinjao even at an old age tank some of Luffy's attacks.

Wow people honestly think Luffy can win? Garp even said it himself that he had prepare by destroying mountains for the battle. Don't think Garp had it easy back then.

 

[SAHAN1993]

Prime Chinjao wins.

Garp looked fairly young back then and he probably above admiral level so it would make sense for him to take Chinjao out in one punch. As for the diff. I would say around mid. Luffy can't win, Chinjao's overall strength has depreciated a lot during those years and that punch from Garp. Plus we've seen Chinjao even at an old age tank some of Luffy's attacks.

Wow people honestly think Luffy can win? Garp even said it himself that he had prepare by destroying mountains for the battle. Don't think Garp had it easy back then.

so you only think about a one fact what about dark kings saying 'luffy far too ahead to young roger'.not only that i never think so much strength difference in their prime and present because dark king[present] match up with kizaru[admiral].so if you think so much difference between prime and present i cannot think what the hell dark king was.there is a strength difference.but it is small

 

[Hexuze]

so you only think about a one fact what about dark kings saying 'luffy far too ahead to young roger'.not only that i never think so much strength difference in their prime and present because dark king[present] match up with kizaru[admiral].so if you think so much difference between prime and present i cannot think what the hell dark king was.there is a strength difference.but it is small

I understand what you're trying to say but look at this. When Rayleigh was fighting Kizaru, he was at a disadvantage due to his age but Chinjao on the other hand he was at a disadvantage from old age + flattened head from Garp. It's safe to assume that Chinjao used his head for the most part when it came to fighting (no pun intended xd). I don't think it was fair to even compare those two scenarios. Plus I have a feeling that you think I'm saying Prime Chinjao will take on luffy easily, which is false.

 

[Shinichi Izumi]

Honestly there is not a lot to go by...We Haven't seen Luffy's full potential yet and we don't really know exactly how strong Chinjao was back then. But I'd say based off of hype Chinjao wins mid-high difficulty.

 

[Fireplay]

Considering that Garp had to train in order to match Chinjao. I say he stomps.

 

[SAHAN1993]

I understand what you're trying to say but look at this. When Rayleigh was fighting Kizaru, he was at a disadvantage due to his age but Chinjao on the other hand he was at a disadvantage from old age + flattened head from Garp. It's safe to assume that Chinjao used his head for the most part when it came to fighting (no pun intended xd). I don't think it was fair to even compare those two scenarios. Plus I have a feeling that you think I'm saying Prime Chinjao will take on luffy easily, which is false.

yeah i think it is ok to say like this 'luffy take him on extreme high difficulty.but the thing is when anime came out people think luffy is weak as hell because manga luffy > anime luffy.

When Rayleigh was fighting Kizaru, he was at a disadvantage due to his age but Chinjao on the other hand he was at a disadvantage from old age + flattened head from Garp

yeah it could be a problem but different between prime garp and luffy garp sunk don chins head butt luffy fix it.so what if luffy at garp position i mean luffy also can sunk don chin head butt but garp also can fix it.i believe what you said bro.because don chin has a disadvantage due to his age