[Discussion] Luffy VS Crew

[Tomato God]

Situation luffy is in nightmare mode and its current luffy and he can hold it for 10 minutes.

Situation 1: Current Night mare luffy vs Current crew
Start distance is 50 yards

Situation 2: Current Nightmare Luffy vs Current Crew + there Pre-skip counter parts so Current Zoro + PreTS Zoro + Current Nami + PreTS... Ect All vs luffy in nightmare mode.

 

[ShonenAnimeFreak]

Luffy might be able to win in scenario one if he can use haki + the gears with nightmare mode,

he can't win in the second scenario

 

[LogicnoJutsu]

Ussop and Nami slow him down long enough for Chopper the Go into his Crazy mode. After the 10 mins are up and Luffy is exhausted Zoro could chop off his limbs with ease. Then after Luffy calms down and has a Snickers that Sanji will cook up they'll pay a visit to Law and have him re attach his rubber arms.

 

[jiraiya lives]

10 mins? the crew got this

 

[scorezor]

zoro with the 1080 pound the oh wins.

the second scenario , hmm... water + thunder = ko ? something like that xD

 

[Love Cook]

Nightmare Luffy got this, he did something pre skip the entire crew didn't even come close to doing, so it's obvious that his strength is far bigger.

It's only logical that after the skip this would still apply since Luffy grew just as much during the training and with his nightmare form he would still be the strongest.

As for Scorezor who said Zoro can finish him with his 1080 pound canon, Nightmare Luffy has a sword and the souls of great swordsmen. So even if they might not be as great as Zoro was once they were alive, Luffy knows basic sword techs but has superior power.

Nightmare Luffy stopped Oz Jr.'s punch with one hand and he didn't even had to put effort in it. The difference between that and the rest of the crew is obvious.

 

[Bogard]

Scenario1 and scenario2 is practically the same. Preskip incarnations of strawhats are fodders to top3 fighters of the crew, let alone the strongest one with a huge power boost, so they aren't going to make any difference. I imagine the boost will be significant. Infact even considering post-skip, besides Zoro and Sanji, none of them would make that much a difference either. In direct combat, they will get stomped. Their only way is to outlast the 10min. If they manage, they win

 

[juzumaki]

knight mare would wreck only diff he have is against zoro which would be mid to high diff since knightmare luffy is a sword master as well but he isnt a swordsman

 

[Love Cook]

knight mare would wreck only diff he have is against zoro which would be mid to high diff since knightmare luffy is a sword master as well but he isnt a swordsman

Luffy himself doesn't have to be a swordsman because he has a lot of souls of talented swordsmen inside of him and he uses those abilities, like Ryuuma used brook's fencing style and Oz was able to use the gomu fruit.

So it doesn't matter if Luffy isn't a swordsman, nightmare Luffy is.

 

[A v i]

Nightmare mode is like 20X stronger than normal Luffy. They can't win against him.

 

[24 12 11 to troll]

Situation 1: Current Night mare luffy vs Current crew
Start distance is 50 yards

Luffy wins high diff

Situation 2: Current Nightmare Luffy vs Current Crew + there Pre-skip counter parts so Current Zoro + PreTS Zoro + Current Nami + PreTS... Ect All vs luffy in nightmare mode.

Luffy still wins

 

[sravan]

nightmare luffy will win both scenarios.