Lets not forget Madam Sharley's prediction

[zachaerysean]

hey base, lets not forget about the prediction Sharley had about a man in a straw hat destroying Fishman Island... the manga does state that her predictions are never wrong and that they don't happen immediately happen... it could be years before anything happens...

Now her prediction could be a way to save Fishman Island... like Luffy and the Strawhats claim to have "destroyed" island in order to save from Big Mam... but that's only one of many theories...

Also, remember that she said that it was a "man in a straw hat"... now Luffy cannot be the only person in this world that wears a straw hat... it could be a brand new character all together... just another theory...

i just have a feeling that this whole prediction thing is gonna come full circle somehow...

if you have a theory or whatever then comment here...

 

[Uchiha seeker]

destroy the island and rebuild it so Humans and Fishman can live together?... or some random strong guy with a strawhat destroys it

 

[Akuma]

I didnt read but i know the Mugiwara will end up saving Fishman Island.

 

[Kianto]

or maybe... she predicted wrong for the first time... or random guy comes... or somehow.. luffy meets shanks, luffy gives hes hat back to shanks, shanks destroys the fisherman island... but that theory is just dumb... luffy is not luffy without hes strawhat..

 

[zachaerysean]

didn't somebody recently say in the manga that they should raise Fishman Island to the surface?? or am i imagining things?

 

[aperson]

didn't somebody recently say in the manga that they should raise Fishman Island to the surface?? or am i imagining things?

I'm not sure if anyone said that but i think that luffy will try to bring fishman island to the surface and do it by moving the whole island :shrug: or destroy it so they have to build it at the surface.

 

[Zoro..]

The prediction only showed him with the burning island. It will most likely be where his fight with Big mam takes place and she destroys Fishman Island but that wont be a bad thing cause Luffy will convince humans to let Fishman live with them... Thats my theory

 

[lubricati0n]

Firstly good job on telling us what was said in the manga.

You must be registered for see links

Secondly Madame Shirley clearly said she had felt something from the boy in other words Luffy hence the reason why she looked into the future. Her prediction was of Luffy destroying the island.

You must be registered for see links

 

[iSpeak]

Maybe Magellan captures Bon Kurei, turns him over to the Marines, they train him to become a mindless puppet for them (Kinda like the CP9), Akainu finds out that Shirahoshi is Poseidon and sends Bon Kurei to Fishman island to destroy it (pretends to be Luffy to deceive everyone on the island). Thats all I can think of lol.
For real though she probably just got it wrong.

 

[EternalMangekyouRinnegan]

Joyboy is going to return to fishman island and fulfill his promise. He's going destroy fishman island and take them all to surface on Noah. Joyboy is going to wear a straw hat that he bought at fishman island and it will be revealed that he was the first guy to wear Luffy's straw hat. It was passed down from Void Century to all D's with the same spirit like Luffy and Roger and it's actually both One Piece and ancient weapon Uranus, capable of destroying the whole world.

Yeah. Believe it :naruto:

 

[Dino]

I don't think this is the last we've seen of Fishmen Island. Caribou will probably let "You-know-who" know about Shirahoshi and there'll probably be a battle held at FI. The princes said something about them having the strongest fleet under the sea and I think that they'll participate in the battle as well, along with SH pirates. Luffy destroys Fishmen Island during his last battle and he takes them all to the surface in Noah. Just a theory.

 

[wallie20]

I don't think this is the last we've seen of Fishmen Island. Caribou will probably let "You-know-who" know about Shirahoshi and there'll probably be a battle held at FI. The princes said something about them having the strongest fleet under the sea and I think that they'll participate in the battle as well, along with SH pirates. Luffy destroys Fishmen Island during his last battle and he takes them all to the surface in Noah. Just a theory.

Hmm yea nice theory, I really think that that's the purpose of Noah

 

[NarutoVsGoku]

destroy the island and rebuild it so Humans and Fishman can live together?... or some random strong guy with a strawhat destroys it

basicly this

and like the OP said its somehow gunna come full circle

 

[NarutoVsGoku]

I don't think this is the last we've seen of Fishmen Island. Caribou will probably let "You-know-who" know about Shirahoshi and there'll probably be a battle held at FI. The princes said something about them having the strongest fleet under the sea and I think that they'll participate in the battle as well, along with SH pirates. Luffy destroys Fishmen Island during his last battle and he takes them all to the surface in Noah. Just a theory.

this too.. the whole Princess using the sea kings, noah ark and luffy blah blah blah will all tie up together in the future

 

[AT sama]

I think the fishman island is not going to destroying by Luffy's hands but someone who has straw hat. And Madam Sharley didn't say that Fishman Island will be detroyed by Luffy, she said that this Island will be detroyed by someone who has straw hat, right!

 

[Totsuka No Tsurugi]

Maybe Magellan captures Bon Kurei, turns him over to the Marines, they train him to become a mindless puppet for them (Kinda like the CP9), Akainu finds out that Shirahoshi is Poseidon and sends Bon Kurei to Fishman island to destroy it (pretends to be Luffy to deceive everyone on the island). Thats all I can think of lol.
For real though she probably just got it wrong.

no man bon-chan will never do that, but then again it will be a great plot twist