~kishi vs other manga writers~

[SAHAN1993]

what do u think about kishi's manga style and other writers manga styles?why naruto so popular among other mangas?how did kishi do this?

 

[Joon]

When the killing and blood was good..... Now..... :|

 

[hixa kuogame]

Naruto is the only manga I read :T_T:
But comparing it too other stories I think its better because its different and its just one big story but its extremely stretched out

 

[take it easy]

Just better than other manga from big three... Great style and character development.

 

[Lightbringer]

Well compared to One Piece and Bleach, it's not as repetitive.

Having jutsu gives variety in the world rather than just getting better at Getsuga Tensho or Gomo Gomo since jutsu can be learned by anyone

The world is also well thought out and isn't as random as Bleach or One Piece. In Bleach Ichigo being a quincy, along with shinigami and hollow just seems like an ass-pull.

The enemies are also all tied in. They mentioned Madara in part 1, now he's one of the final villains. Whereas in Bleach and One-Piece it's always someone new who doesn't have much of a connection to the main character or wasn't hinted at from before.

In Bleach they said there were no more quincies left aside for one, now they're the main villains.

 

[accept pain]

because kishi is troller.

 

[Punk Hazard]

Oda's better all's I know.

 

[Rock on]

ONE WORD
NINJA!!!
:x3: :hooray:
now :stfu:

 

[MartinRico]

Well compared to One Piece and Bleach, it's not as repetitive.

Having jutsu gives variety in the world rather than just getting better at Getsuga Tensho or Gomo Gomo since jutsu can be learned by anyone

The world is also well thought out and isn't as random as Bleach or One Piece. In Bleach Ichigo being a quincy, along with shinigami and hollow just seems like an ass-pull.

The enemies are also all tied in. They mentioned Madara in part 1, now he's one of the final villains. Whereas in Bleach and One-Piece it's always someone new who doesn'thave much of a connection to the main character or wasn't hinted at from before.

In Bleach they said there were no more quincies left aside for one, now they're the main villains.

Oda is the king of foreshadowing. I just started rereading op and I'm amazed at how many little things that hint to future chapters.

 

[KingHashirama]

All have different styles. If you don't like someone's style don't read it. Instead of stressing about it or bashing them.

Oda is the king of foreshadowing. I just started rereading op and I'm amazed at how many little things that hint to future chapters.

He does have the most predictable story.. o-o.

 

[DJKS]

Overall, I think Kishi's story has had the best plot and character developments. Neither Bleach nor OP have as in depth characters as Naruto does.

 

[Lightbringer]

Oda is the king of foreshadowing. I just started rereading op and I'm amazed at how many little things that hint to future chapters.

Thing with that is it's kinda hard to catch on and follow in comparison to Naruto.

I'm honestly not even sure of any foreshadowing in OP, can you clarify?

When I'm reading Naruto it's pretty clear, but with OP I need to read a few times to get what's going on.

Not to mention that there is a huge amount of speech bubbles and text in OP panels which can be disorienting sometimes and most of them have nothing to do with the actual plot at hand.

 

[Cosman]

Kishi's probably one of the more talented writers I've seen in shonen. The proof is in how great he make pure asspulls look.

Kishimoto can do whatever he wants sometimes and actually make it work. He doesn't even need to try to stay competitive which is quite sad. Back when Kishi gave a shit (pain saga) nobody could argue he was top dog.

 

[SIR HERDERP PRESIDERP SDO]

Tezuka is the greatest Mangaka of all time *_*

 

[BenjerminGaye]

what do u think about kishi's manga style and other writers manga styles?why naruto so popular among other mangas?how did kishi do this?

naruto is only popular because of when it came out. Any other action manga that came out around that time and got shipped to the us would have been just as popular.(same goes for bleach)
Kishi: Cover plot holes with flashbacks(tobi=obito).Create character development with flashbacks(garra,sasuke,naruto). Create flashbacks within flashbacks(hashi vs madara).
Kubo: Ichigo gets beat up Enters hyperbrolic time chamber, then beats up who beat him up.Rinse, repeat.(notable examples: Byakuya, Grimmjow,Ulquiorra,)

 

[BenjerminGaye]

Kishi's probably one of the more talented writers I've seen in shonen. The proof is in how great he make pure asspulls look.

Kishimoto can do whatever he wants sometimes and actually make it work. He doesn't even need to try to stay competitive which is quite sad. Back when Kishi gave a shit (pain saga) nobody could argue he was top dog.

pain saga wasn't the best. In fact all of shippuden was half ass.The big and bad Akatsuki getting killed off every arc(by gennin and chunin no less) but oro and co the original baddies from before the timeskip are still alive and kickin.

 

[MartinRico]

Thing with that is it's kinda hard to catch on and follow in comparison to Naruto.

I'm honestly not even sure of any foreshadowing in OP, can you clarify?

When I'm reading Naruto it's pretty clear, but with OP I need to read a few times to get what's going on.

Not to mention that there is a huge amount of speech bubbles and text in OP panels which can be disorienting sometimes and most of them have nothing to do with the actual plot at hand.

Yosuke tells Sanji and luffy about Jinbei about 500-400 chapters before he is introduced. Zoro uses fire swords on an explosive df user, and comments how useful a style it is. Now we have kinemon. I don't know if these would be considered foreshadowing. If not, then he just takes his work seriously and doesn't like gaps in his story.
Sorry for the really late post. I'm taking a small break from rereading op.

 

[Lightbringer]

Yosuke tells Sanji and luffy about Jinbei about 500-400 chapters before he is introduced. Zoro uses fire swords on an explosive df user, and comments how useful a style it is. Now we have kinemon. I don't know if these would be considered foreshadowing. If not, then he just takes his work seriously and doesn't like gaps in his story.
Sorry for the really late post. I'm taking a small break from rereading op.

I'm pretty sure Oda literally said that he makes things up as he goes and the only thing he knows for certain is how OP is going to end.

 

[MartinRico]

I'm pretty sure Oda literally said that he makes things up as he goes and the only thing he knows for certain is how OP is going to end.

actually that's true, but the rate at which he creates new chapters is astonishing. He is known for his lack of sleep and determination for his beloved series. He had stated that this is his last work and works hard to to make it a great series.

 

[Lightbringer]

actually that's true, but the rate at which he creates new chapters is astonishing. He is known for his lack of sleep and determination for his beloved series. He had stated that this is his last work and works hard to to make it a great series.

i don't doubt that, but that really goes for the majority of manga artists as well

sleep is not part of their luxury