kishi is a bad writer

[GrayParadise]

The story is actually pretty good. It's just this week that I'm especially pissed.

 

[blackstar9]

You tricked me! I thought the title of this thread was your statement! xD
Anyway, I totally agree with you!

yeah that was deceptive your right

 

[Renpatsu Dei]

Actually, yes, he's not that good of a writer, but who the **** cares. I still read Naruto every single week.

Something that you don't like or think is bad doesn't mean we have the right to make a judgement on his quality as a writer. When we say something like that it doesn't mean shit because we don't have the qualifications or background to back up that judgement. I like the fact that Tobi is Obito, but the flashback was awful, and this arc has had loads of things I haven't liked, I've nearly lost interest altogether, but I still couldn't call Kishi a bad writer because I don't have the credential to back up my judgement.

 

[Mr.Beastie]

you have done completely the wrong conclusions... you dont understand naruto and madara personality

Kishi made their personalitys this way cover the bs. When the whole world is at stake why does all of a sudden Madara has become this predictable villain thats sits there waiting to get his @ss kicked. Why couldnt Naruto have known sasuke for longer. No matter their personality you have to admit edo tensei is complete bullsh!t. The most powerful technique has no consequences and gives people immortality, infinite chakra but every other justu has consequences like losing chakra or life ending.

 

[Voltron]

I happen to think that kishi's mind is often scattered and he likes making things interesting... but not logical

 

[Klad]

I agree .

These damn haters criticise Naruto every week . That's why I'm not often online on NB

 

[GreyWizard93]

Amen man!

the fans ruin the anime/manga with their high expectations and nit picking over every detail.

 

[blackstar9]

I agree .

These damn haters criticise Naruto every week . That's why I'm not often online on NB

critisise every week but read the manga faithfully and on naruto sites all the time !

 

[Altaneen]

Story = plot. The plot differs from the writing, the way Kishi has been leading Naruto to is shitty and it's all over the place.
There are a bunch of incoherent things, like for example with Orochimaru suddenly turning goog and Tsunade accepting it like it's nothing. The way Sasuke just suddenly came back and claimed that he wanted to become Hokage because he wants to rebuild everything from scratch. And I can go on endlessly.

It's not as if Sasuke was just magically Hokage, he simply claimed that he wanted to be the next one. What is so out of place about that? If he had shown up with the hat on, and everyone was just cool with it, than you'd have a reason to gripe.

As for Tsunade, she has to worry about Madara ending the world, there's no time to get in a fist fight with Orochimaru. It's quite possible she doesn't trust him, but is going along for what needs done most.

As for Orochimaru going good, he said himself he just wants to see what Sasuke's doing, maybe Sasuke changed him, maybe he has not. That is yet to be seen.

 

[Versatile jutsu]

Kishi made their personalitys this way cover the bs. When the whole world is at stake why does all of a sudden Madara has become this predictable villain thats sits there waiting to get his @ss kicked. Why couldnt Naruto have known sasuke for longer. No matter their personality you have to admit edo tensei is complete bullsh!t. The most powerful technique has no consequences and gives people immortality, infinite chakra but every other justu has consequences like losing chakra or life ending.

1. wait few chapter... madara just play with us
2. in memory show how naruto know sasuke since their childhood
3. all jutsu have disadvantages

 

[blackstar9]

I happen to think that kishi's mind is often scattered and he likes making things interesting... but not logical

scattered mind huh ? i disagree most things are revealed at a later time .or ties in somehow

 

[Vandenre1ch]

Tite Kubo is a prime example. Everyone keep saying he was a bad writer but he shut them all up a year ago.

 

[Prince Charles]

Allow me to put in simple terms.

If you like the manga and story then read it.

If you dont like how the story is going and you rather complain and call kishi a bad writer dont read it.

I cant comprehend how some can call kishi a bad writer but still read every chapter on every release date.

 

[CrimsonFire]

You act like no one can have opinion on what they read. I heard these types of arguments all the time and honestly it's POINTLESS. No matter what people are always going have a different opinions you see everyday in different types of media. Of course people have the right to discuss on how they feel about a series that read good or bad. I always hear all the time oh if you don't like it don't read it, oh just a hater, or you think the manga is so bad write one yourself. Your "rant" is perfect example of your typical fan who can not take someone else criticism. The bottom lines is fans have the right to criticize on what they read and it depends on how you take it.


No I do not think Naruto is the best manga in the world, nor do I think it's the worst. Naruto is at least average to me with problamtics that come in the 2nd half of the story. I disagree, Kishi is not that good of a writer.

 

[MonCheRena]

Is NOT

Opinions are opinions, though.

One thing I will admit, IMO his storyline has seemed kind of rushed but I heard he's on a deadline so can you blame the guy? And his character development skills has been sucky for some of the characters in the manga.

 

[Renpatsu Dei]

You act like no one can have opinion on what they read. I heard these types of arguments all the time and honestly it's POINTLESS. No matter what people are always going have a different opinions you see everyday in different types of media. Of course people have the right to discuss on how they feel about a series that read good or bad. I always hear all the time oh if you don't like it don't read it, oh just a hater, or you think the manga is so bad write one yourself. Your "rant" is perfect example of your typical fan who can not take someone else criticism. The bottom lines is fans have the right to criticize on what they read and it depends on how you take it.


No do not think Naruto is the best manga in the world, nor do I think it's the worst. Naruto is at least average to me with problamtics that come in the 2nd half of the story. I disagree, Kishi is not that good of a writer.

No one is banning you from your opinion, its just people throw around the whole Kishi is a bad writer thing as if it is a fact. Criticising something that anooys you is fine, I do it plenty, but judging someone's ability in something that they are clearly more experienced than you in is just doesn't make sense, you don't hold enough weight to make statements like that.

 

[The Work]

Damn, Oro ain't good

He's just waiting for Sasuke to do his evil intentions

 

[Mr.Beastie]

1. wait few chapter... madara just play with us
2. in memory show how naruto know sasuke since their childhood
3. all jutsu have disadvantages

He only knew his name. -_- that dont count. Not to me anyways. They didnt have a real relationship till they got on the same team. Edo tensei has no weakness kabuto stated it himself.

 

[CrimsonFire]

Damn, Oro ain't good

He's just waiting for Sasuke to do his evil intentions

Let's hope man, if Orochimaru is truly good then I do not know what to say lol

 

[Nous]

He's not a bad writer. I haven't see anyone say he was. He's a good one, heck he's excellent. However recently he seems to be messing up. The war is unbalanced, characters are acting weird and most people don't care about them anymore. The Pain Arc was excellent - we felt "into" the story and felt scared for the characters and a legitimate sense of fear - Naruto might actually lose. Jiraiya, Kakashi, Hinata etc. gone and the Village blown up. This was excellent writing but ever since then, the story has been lagging.