Agreed at this stage pein would win. If we see more jutsu's from the bro's then maybe. Pein would repel the to fast and inbetween the 3 second delay he would hust use the other path of peins to block and defend him with the absorbtion powers. I still think if pein had been at full power when he fought naruto we'd be seeing the 10 tails a lot faster.but if he gets caught by the rope he is done cause all they have to do is say pein and boom gone...but yeah pein would win since he can replace and take souls.