[Discussion] Kiado + 3 Calmaities vs Luffy + 3 straw hats

[Mikeuhsomething36]

I am not asking if there would be a big four. I am asking who are the straw hats most capable four fighters and I don't know why you cannot grasp this.

Your thread is extremely vauge then. It's set up like a vs thread. Basically your thread us asking for the fourth best straw hat combat wise or something of the like? Of that is the case why did you compare them to Kaido's crew. Literally "who is the fourth strongest straw hat combat wise" literally you aren't betting straight answers and almost everyone here thinks this is a vs thread or an extremely vauge thread. Without the whole kaido thing (that you needed to edit your own op to specify as not a vs thread) this would be going more smoothly. A straight answer is based on what? What defines a caoable fighter depends do you mean strength or skill wise? Because if overall then It's robin. If strength franky. If skill...Usopp.....insane luck. Admittablt even from your response "the purpose of a good story.." woukd be fluff if you're not assuming changing anything. I get what you mean now though

 

[Dęvîa Puęrî]

Kaido solos

 

[Angelic.]

Law jinbie or the samurai idk

 

[Tomato God]

Usopp would get negged by a calamity. I can't believe you actually suggested that Usopp could fight one.

So would robin and franky

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

So would robin and franky

I never said they wouldn't.

 

[Your Creepy Stalker]

Doesn't always have to be Luffy/Zoro/Sanji, there's plenty of other people who could fight them.
Most likely in my opinion is Inuarashi and Nekomamushi taking out Jack.

"But Your Creepy Stalker, Didn't they admit they couldn't beat Jack"

Ah, yes, but all it would take is one panel of them saying "That was 1v1, now behold our true power when we work together" or something like that, then another panel of Jack, absent one head.

Other possibilities, Law, Jimbe, Marco, and Usopp seem most likely to take out a calamity, although Usopp really only does overspecialised DF user who would otherwise solo everyone like Sugar and Perona, and i don't see Kaido having one.