Kamui > Yata

[OnPoint]

Neither or us are going to concede the point, so this is futile. All I will say is;

• Kamui or the chakra which powers the Jutsu is sourced in Kakashi's eye - the actual hole in space isn't made of anything nor does it consist of any parts. It's just as Tsukuyomi's power is stored or 'sourced' in Itachi's eye.
• If you admit that the Mirror cannot negate Obito's phasing (in which he doesn't consist of anything in the normal reality), then you also allow for it being unable to negate another Jutsu which is made of nothing in that very same plane of existence (Kakashi's variant).
• Minato's Hiraishin moves the shield in its entirety from A to B. Kamui also does this.
• Obito did have a Mangekyou Sharingan so I win =p

 

[Strict]

Alright. We need to agree to disagree. I get your point, it makes sense, and can be the possibility.

 

[rubiclt]

does it matter, itachi shits on kakashi anyways

 

[BenjerminGaye]

Just compare both hype and you'll realise it U_U

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

1) Yata = Shield(Defense)
Kamui Hype1 = No defense possible

2) Yata hype = Change properties to stop an attack
Kamui Hype2 = No matter what, it drags the target it

Conclusion:

Kamui > Yata

Deal with it. Kamui solos

You must be registered for see images

If you wanna be real technical about it kamui was(and still isn't to the best of my knowledge) never referred to as an attack. Even in the databook. So yata honestly shouldn't even put up a defence.

 

[Varrah]

I disagree with the notion Kamui > Yata.

Kamui is a technic arose within the Mangekyō Sharingan, a stronger form of the Sharingan produced by the brain of an Uchiha releasing a specialized chakra or Inton throughout the cranial nerves which affects the optic nerves once a sufficiently strong emotional stimulus is invoked—likely because the Uchiha are a battle-hardened clan—and allows the user of the eyes insightfulness, hypnotism, and the reflection of one’s soul. [

You must be registered for see links

] The specialized chakra that begets the Sharingan is Inton as Hagoromo Ōtsutsuki divided his immense powers among his sons, and this power is originally that of the Shinji’s fruit before Princess Kaguya Ōtsutsuki consumed it and her son inherited it, illuminating why the Sharingan has its properties: it is the summit of Yin Release, the spiritual side or imagination projected; and Yin Release, along with Yang Release create the sixth Seishitsu Henka, and the Yata no Kagami is said to alter its characteristics to that of the attack, reflecting the force used.

Kamui is an Inton (‘Yin’) ability, a Seishitsu Henka; therefore, the Yata no Kagami can negate it. ​

 

[KingHashirama]

only if Kamui was an attack. =D

 

[-ahhimane-]

Lol, When someone uses Kamui, the opponent won't pull out Yata Mirror for the defense. He'll pull out Totsuka sword because the Kamui user gets materialized while using Kamui.

So both Yata and Kamui are incomparable to each other. Both are hype but have no connection with each other during a battle.

 

[FlemSmack]

Kamui requires chakra. Yata would counter the chakra with the opposite chakra and cancel the jutsu.

 

[Misconception]

Well Kamui hype has been debunked... Omyoudon>Ninjutsu therefor it>Kamui...