kamui flawed

[sage22]

So last chapter it was hinted that kamui n tobi ninjutsu use the same dimension. If that is true then anyone kakashi hit kamui with could survive if their body is intact. So let's say he were in another battle with zabuza for example n he teleports him with kamui. If his while body is teleported then he will survive. Now that's only if he use the same dimensions as tobi cuz tobi has shown us an individual can survive a week in there at least. Any thoughts.

 

[Nikes]

Kisame>>>Kamui

 

[The Necromancer]

Well yes... but there's no way to get out so they will die of starvation and thirst.

 

[Kazekage35]

Possilby. Unless Kamui destroys them at a cellular level while teleporting them away? So essentially it would destroy them into nothing but empty matter, but then that most likely would have done the same to rasengan so I'm drawing a blank here

 

[-Logic-]

D00d. It warps you to another dimension. Technically, you don't exist in the normal one, and you're dead.

 

[OnPoint]

If you're put in that dimension you're as good as dead.

 

[saaaaaadpanda]

Well yes... but there's no way to get out so they will die of starvation and thirst.

^This. They do use the same dimension. For a more thorough explanation, see the thread in my sig.

 

[bigmoose21]

Didnt Tobi take sasuke there.... and pull the dudes out from the sasuke danzo fight a while after he teleported them?

 

[Narutoverse]

Didnt Tobi take sasuke there.... and pull the dudes out from the sasuke danzo fight a while after he teleported them?

He did, you don't die from being in the dimension. You'd die from not having any food or water, since there is nothing there. So when he took those 2 two out they were barely alive

 

[sage22]

Didnt Tobi take sasuke there.... and pull the dudes out from the sasuke danzo fight a while after he teleported them?

This

 

[SilverSlick]

Lol, yes because anyone Kakashi sends there is still a threat to him, right?

 

[bigmoose21]

so why doesnt Kakashi secretly send gai there...... and when naruto goes to TBB Tobi and he teleports gai is waiting with a swift kick to the mask... it breaks we see who he is BAM make it happen

 

[ThtOneGuy]

he sends there neck to another dimesnsion when he uses it offensively. he never has tried sending there whole body there. yes he possibly could but chopping off there head gets the job done faster and with less chakra, so there is no point in him sending there whole body to the other dimension.

 

[gordo1]

You don't die if you're not there a terribly long time, but most people don't get brought back.

 

[Vegeto30294]

Thats why every time he used it, he aims for the head/neck. He got Deidara's arm, which is the equivalent of ripping his arm off. If you send someone's head or neck there, you'd be dead instantly for obvious reasons.