Kakashi's Kamui or Obito's Kamui - which would you choose?

[Takos]

Which of them would you choose if they consumed no chakra and couldn't make you go blind?

You can choose Kakashi's Kamui at his current level or Obito's Kamui at his current level.

Kakashi's Kamui:
-instant, as opposed to Obito's
-long-ranged

Obito's Kamui:
-can be used on himself to be intangible
-short-ranged

 

[Germanicus]

The eyes and their abilities are the same; it's Obito's experience and practice with his eye that make them seem different. Kakashi just hasn't had the same amount of time at using Kamui as Obito.

 

[Lil B]

I would choose Lil B's life

 

[Takos]

The eyes and their abilities are the same; it's Obito's experience and practice with his eye that make them seem different. Kakashi just hasn't had the same amount of time at using Kamui as Obito.

No, they're different.
-Obito himself stated Kakashi's was faster.
-Kakashi cannot use it on himself.
-Obito cannot use it long-range.

Kakashi is no where near obito level dude.

same techniques

I guess I will have to explain the differences... -.-

Kakashi's Kamui:
-instant, as opposed to Obito's
-long-ranged

Obito's Kamui:
-can be used on himself to be intangible
-short-ranged

 

[XMrLiNdOrX]

They r the same eyes

 

[Bogard]

Both have their advantage and disadvantage. For the defense, Obitos kamui is better. Kakashis is better for offense

 

[KidGamer65]

Obito's is better...he can actually enter the dimension unlike Kakashi and he can be intangible so I pick Obito's.

 

[Champ]

Since there both Obito's eyes I'll go with his Kamui

 

[Germanicus]

No, they're different.
-Obito himself stated Kakashi's was faster.
-Kakashi cannot use it on himself.
-Obito cannot use it long-range.

It would have to come from different experiences, otherwise this is a sizeable plot hole (typical Kishi). The eyes came from the same person and have the same genetic build up. There's no real reason that would allow two eyes to develop so differently without being a difference in experience. Genetically, it wouldn't be possible for eyes from the same person to differentiate that much.

 

[Takos]

It would have to come from different experiences, otherwise this is a sizeable plot hole (typical Kishi). The eyes came from the same person and have the same genetic build up. There's no real reason that would allow two eyes to develop so differently without being a difference in experience. Genetically, it wouldn't be possible for eyes from the same person to differentiate that much.

Don't involve genetics here. It's the same with other MS - one eye has Amaterasu, the other has Tsukyomi. This is a very similar case, only the two techniques are both s/t ninjutsu (as opposed to one being a ninjutsu and one a genjutsu) so they are considered one technique, that's how I see it.

 

[Shunsin no Shisui]

I would go with Obito's. I'd rather stay defensive and avoid attack than get killed by a small kunai etc.(it's disgraceful) And I'm also pretty sure that Obito's can also suck in objects to his pocket dimension even though the method may be slightly different compared to Kakashi's Kamui.

EDIT: Poll would be a good idea

 

[UrFace234]

this is pretty obvious.......obito 's kamui would be better because he's an authentic user....meaning he's better at sharingan techniques because he's an uchiha. there is a genetic barrier here for kakashi because he's not uchiha. however, both eyes belong to obito anyways, so u cant really say that kakashi has a kamui of his own... lol

 

[Prime Rib]

you kiddin me obitos

 

[blackstar9]

Kakashi kumai is not instant ! it takes time for him to use it.The best example of instant is minato FTG