[Gimp] Just got into GFXing.

[Trendykill]

Yeah. I created a forum set for myself.
I felt it was pretty good for a first.

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

That one comes without the text. Feel free to use it, as long as you credit me in your sig somewhere ^.^

Please, criticism appreciated. No, seriously. Go harsh.

 

[Darth Vader]

It's not a bad start! ^_^

 

[Positive Human]

It's very good for the start but the text is bad.
Use a short text, smaller text and place it near Ahri

 

[-S-]

''Go harsh''

Yeah, it's really bad. The signature is way too large, and the render is far to small in it. The text is pretty unsightly too.

 

[Trendykill]

It's not a bad start! ^_^

Thanks!

It's very good for the start but the text is bad.
Use a short text, smaller text and place it near Ahri

Ah okay. I still have the xcf files. I can edit it

''Go harsh''

Yeah, it's really bad. The signature is way too large, and the render is far to small in it. The text is pretty unsightly too

I posted this on quite a few forums and they said the same things: not bad for a start, text too large, etc. Also, it was too bright apparently, which I agree with.
With a lot of NB sigs, they have the character outside the sig bg. I wanna try and replicate that.

 

[Troi]

Yep, this is terrible.

 

[Trollo Lucilfer]

Yep, this is terrible.

Are you sure terrible is the correct word to describe this so called artwork, i'm not saying it's wrong, i just don't think that the usage of the word itself to describe the very first signature of a beginner is right. lol.

 

[Drāgy]

Are you sure terrible is the correct word to describe this so called artwork, i'm not saying it's wrong, i just don't think that the usage of the word itself to describe the very first signature of a beginner is right. lol.

Totally agree with my mate megaamine here. It's not cool to use such words, especially when someone has put effort to make something. I'm not saying that it is wrong, but the word is not really nice to use, especially when the person who made this is a beginner and with such critics we will unmotivate him to continue ... Indeed he said: "Go harsh."; still that doesn't mean that we have to throw out words like that.​

 

[Uchiha Minato]

Totally agree with my mate megaamine here. It's not cool to use such words, especially when someone has put effort to make something. I'm not saying that it is wrong, but the word is not really nice to use, especially when the person who made this is a beginner and with such critics we will unmotivate him to continue ... Indeed he said: "Go harsh."; still that doesn't mean that we have to throw out words like that.​

Also it's not very helpful to use these words. If someone is starting to learn how to GFX then you are supposed to give constructive criticism, or good feedback. If you give them feedback they can learn from their mistakes and add in what they missed the previous try!