- Joined
- Feb 8, 2011
- Messages
- 32,590
- Reaction score
- 2,096
Itachi has never been seen needing to gather a significant amount of time to prep Tsukiyomi. It happened easily with a closing and opening of eyes against Kakashi. He used it almost instantly against Bee (mid-fight).
Being bisected wouldn't change anything. Getting damaged as an Edo has never indicated a loss of chakra gathering. We also have no indication that Izanami is a huge chakra cost. And as an Edo Tensei, he can constantly use his maximum potential of chakra meaning even if it did take a lot, he could use it and Tsukiyomi immediately.
Still, if he can activate it at anytime, then why would he stand there in front of Kabuto and fight as opposed to simply falling back, and returning to activate it? There's no need for Itachi to play close with Kabuto which is EXTREMELY risky when he can sit in Susanoo and if Sound Genjutsu is used, just cooperate with Sasuke to keep safe.
I agree that both options are applicable; however, from what we saw, and based on everything said, I would say physical contact was needed for A'. That's what my point was about. In my opinion, until Kishi notes that Itachi can create it just by Ocular Dojutsu, I would say Physical contact exists as the more general answer of the two.
But as you noted... Pretty much at this point it stands as a difference of opinion.
Well not anytime, however much time is necessary. That's not really a good strategy at all. Itachi has no idea of Kabuto's abilities. While confident of his own, he still has Sasuke to protect; the latter displaying multiple times he'd act without waiting for permission from the former. With Sasuke there, it's infeasible that he's just 'sit there' and do nothing while the Kabuto is going after both of them. And you may argue that Kabuto has nothing to get through Susano'o, however he may or may not have shown his full arsenal (I doubt he did).
I see you understood the implications this has in battle strategy though.
Yeah I wholeheartedly disagree that physical contact a second time seems more plausible based on what was said. I believe that A' requires only the power of the eyes, because well, that's what the manga said.
I do agree that the whole incident surrounding Izanami may be a bit unclear; and that either explanations can easily be debunked when Kishi explains it.