[Discussion] I've Been Wondering . . .

[iKiddMars]

Well in the last chapter we've seen tobi Critically claim that he was going to revive the Juubi with the Incomplete amounts of chakra he's received from the Kyuubi and Hachibi. But I don't know if anyone has said this yet, But since Edo tensei has been released, Aren't Kinkaku and Ginkaku Released from the binding, and are no longer in the Treasured tools. This may mean that All Tobi has in his Possession are the 1-7 tailed beast.

Just something I've been thinking about, Like I said I don't know if anyone has brought this up but, Discuss !

 

[~Dream~]

They are sealed in there so Edo tensei can't release them OR Plot hole.

 

[wridacule]

looks like you found yourself a plot hole there sir

 

[saaaaaadpanda]

There souls were bound to a sacrificial body by edo tensei, but then were subsequently sealed in the sacred tools. I can see how you would be confused.

 

[gordo1]

Their souls were sealed in sacred weapons before the Edo was released so they're bound there now, not the pure world.

 

[Legendary Broly]

No because their souls were sealed therefore cannot be released back to where they were prior to being revived rep+ for good question anyway

 

[6PathsofKami]

You cant escape from them even if edo tensei is released it just means they are free from kabutos control but they are sealed inside the treasures if they are released then they will go back to the pure world but with kinkaku and ginkaku that aint happening theyr screwed.

 

[iKiddMars]

Honestly The revival of the Juubi May be a Very incomplete one without the Kyuubi Chakra. Tobi never sealed the Chakra of the Kyuubi into the Gedo Mazo before the Edo Tensei was released. As you can see in the last chapter he summoned them THEN the Gedo Consumed them which was WAY after the Edo was released. The use of Edo tensei can be used from several different ranges as we can see so I doubt since they were sealed the edo couldn't be released.

Tobi Isn't as sharp as I thought.

 

[MetalDuck]

Did you not read what everyone posted? They were both sealed in the tools. Obviously before Edo was released. Since they were sealed there, they did NOT go back when Edo ended. Then Tobi fed them to the Gedo.

I know it's a difficult concept (no it's not), but at least read what people post.

 

[iKiddMars]

Did you not read what everyone posted? They were both sealed in the tools. Obviously before Edo was released. Since they were sealed there, they did NOT go back when Edo ended. Then Tobi fed them to the Gedo.

I know it's a difficult concept (no it's not), but at least read what people post.

And Did you not read what I wrote ? What I'm saying is even if they were sealed in the Tools that does not mean that the ending of edo tensei had no effect on them. Please for the sake of both of us show me where it say's since they were sealed in the tools edo tensei couldn't be ended on them. Last time i checked it didn't BUT I may be wrong. . . . I'm waiting

 

[Ven]

And Did you not read what I wrote ? What I'm saying is even if they were sealed in the Tools that does not mean that the ending of edo tensei had no effect on them. Please for the sake of both of us show me where it say's since they were sealed in the tools edo tensei couldn't be ended on them. Last time i checked it didn't BUT I may be wrong. . . . I'm waiting

Show us where it says that sealed souls ARE released by Edo Tensei, it goes both ways bro.

Gin Rummy: I always say the absence of evidence is not the evidence of absence.

Riley: What?

:flaw:

 

[iKiddMars]

Show us where it says that sealed souls ARE released by Edo Tensei, it goes both ways bro.

Gin Rummy: I always say the absence of evidence is not the evidence of absence.

Riley: What?

:flaw:

And that you are true about, It can go both ways but we will see.

 

[MNU]

Their souls were sealed in sacred weapons before the Edo was released so they're bound there now, not the pure world.

this^

 

[Floydical]

Its clear that their souls are bound to the pot / gourd despite edo's release. The fact that Gedo Mazo reacted to consuming the pot and activated all nine eyes means that Kin / Gin were still in the pot when it was consumed.

 

[beastmode634]

If kin and gin were sealed in the tools, i dont quite see how the gedo used their chakra, since "whatever goes in can never come out no matter what"

 

[iKiddMars]

Its clear that their souls are bound to the pot / gourd despite edo's release. The fact that Gedo Mazo reacted to consuming the pot and activated all nine eyes means that Kin / Gin were still in the pot when it was consumed.

Everyone here Has a point, But we all know how Kishi can be so lets let the manga talk.

 

[psukkar]

Well in the last chapter we've seen tobi Critically claim that he was going to revive the Juubi with the Incomplete amounts of chakra he's received from the Kyuubi and Hachibi. But I don't know if anyone has said this yet, But since Edo tensei has been released, Aren't Kinkaku and Ginkaku Released from the binding, and are no longer in the Treasured tools. This may mean that All Tobi has in his Possession are the 1-7 tailed beast.

Just something I've been thinking about, Like I said I don't know if anyone has brought this up but, Discuss !

this means two things,

1) He already made the gdeo mazo absorb the chakra long before the edo tensei was released.

or

2) the sealing pot overrides the edo tensei release, the fox did say nothing can remove the soul from the pot.

 

[iKiddMars]

this means two things,

1) He already made the gdeo mazo absorb the chakra long before the edo tensei was released.

or

2) the sealing pot overrides the edo tensei release, the fox did say nothing can remove the soul from the pot.

Everyone here has said something good. But we know how Kishi is so lets just see what the manga reads.

 

[MilwaukeegHost]

Honestly The revival of the Juubi May be a Very incomplete one without the Kyuubi Chakra. Tobi never sealed the Chakra of the Kyuubi into the Gedo Mazo before the Edo Tensei was released. As you can see in the last chapter he summoned them THEN the Gedo Consumed them which was WAY after the Edo was released. The use of Edo tensei can be used from several different ranges as we can see so I doubt since they were sealed the edo couldn't be released.

Tobi Isn't as sharp as I thought.

Edo or not, once a soul is sealed it is not released to pure world. The Brothers soul was sealed along with their chakra, so when Edo was released that honestly should have no effect on their sealed souls. They are still in the pot and the pot is now in Gedo.

 

[iKiddMars]

Edo or not, once a soul is sealed it is not released to pure world. The Brothers soul was sealed along with their chakra, so when Edo was released that honestly should have no effect on their sealed souls. They are still in the pot and the pot is now in Gedo.

What we both elaborated on may be true, BUT there really is no evidence exactly for it in the manga. The reason Why I say this is because the same thing was said about orochimaru when itachi sealed him but we've seen his soul a great number of times. But like I said you may be right, But the manga has alot of talking to do.