Itachi was DEAD WRONG

Status
Not open for further replies.

AlphaScythian

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Mar 19, 2013
Messages
14,389
Reaction score
1,023
True but his determination a will was what kept him alive and strive through according to anime/manga logic XD
We call it plot armour :cool:

If by konohas enemies you mean oro he came back right afterwords to see him. ofc there are risks to being a ninja and besides sasuke doesnt need his hand held

Yeah itachi should have said so to his parents inb4 doing poor job protecting him.
One would think that it would be his main goal since he planned to die by sasuke's hand and give him his eyes, but then again this plan was worthless if sasuke wouldnt live up to the fight and he's done little to no protection.
 

WalksInShadows

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Feb 8, 2012
Messages
5,365
Reaction score
233
if you look at his hero Shisui, you would find where he inherited that stupidity.
 

SSStylish

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Oct 28, 2014
Messages
3,467
Reaction score
597
The Uchiha had to die one way or another. His actions prevented more deaths, saved Sasukes life and gave him a reason to live.
 

TenthHokagexRamen

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Jan 27, 2013
Messages
2,627
Reaction score
197
I'm going to murder all my family, friends and clan to prevent a war. Instead of just killing obito.

Aidachi logic
 

SSStylish

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Oct 28, 2014
Messages
3,467
Reaction score
597
How would killing Obito at that time have solved anything?

It wouldn't have and the person that wrote it probably knows it himself.

The Uchiha had to die. All that Itachi did was preventing deaths, saving Sasuke and giving him a reason to live.
 

LordRevan

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Jul 31, 2012
Messages
549
Reaction score
34
Thats what I have been saying to these Itachi and Danzo fappers. lol.

Itachi was a mere kid. Danzo was a power-hungry anti-uchiha dictator.
 

Chie

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 10, 2014
Messages
8,333
Reaction score
1,599
He killed the Uchiha clan to prevent the outbreak of an invasion on Konoha, supposidly. His logic is that once Konoha is weakened, other nations would immediately take the oppourtunity to attack.



Well, was there an invasion from other nations after this?

You must be registered for see images

Or this?

You must be registered for see images

Or this?

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images


Well, Itachi was wrong in his stupid assumption. That is because he is an idiot.

-Invasions at this point are unheard of. Simply because Akatsuki were hired by the nations to eliminate select shinobi from others. Ironically, the framework of Akatsuki prevented invasions and thus war started by the nations.

-The Kyuubi attack happened one year after the 3rd shinobi war concluded. No nation was ready to invade at that point.

-Suna was ruined at that point and Konoha was quickly rebuilt. The Sound shinobi took a worse beating than anyone from Konoha did. No one could invade at that point. Also, once again Akatsuki members are used at this point instead of invasions.

The Uchiha clan was not killed off only due to the possibility of invasion. Itachi killed them off to protect their honour and prevent a definitive conflict in Konohagakure itself. He didn't have a choice over the fate of their lives, only how they died.

You're saying one is an idiot for caring for their family and people. It may be time to reevaluate some of your viewpoints, mate.

Itachi was being a full on retard​

No, his decision was smart. U_U

LOLOLOL

I love how he promised to protect sasuke too and let deidara fight him :rolleyes:

He did protect Sasuke given that Sasuke would have died numerous times had it not been for Itachi's influence in some way or another.

He let Deidara fight him because a) Killing Deidara would blow his cover in front of other Akatsuki and b) He knew Sasuke would win. Even when Zetsu told him and the other members Sasuke had died, he knew he hadn't. He had faith in him.

Having faith in a younger sibling is not bad at all. It allows room for them to grow.

Well, he did prevent an invasion by the Uchiha. Sure, there were others afterwards, but he did prevent one of them. Was it worth killing his whole clan? I don't know.

His clan was dying regardless even if he didn't do it himself. He just chose to kill them himself to preserve their honour as well as prevent further conflict. That's worth it no matter how you slice it and from his side the situation is very clear-cut.

The real question is if it was worth it for Hiruzen and Danzo/Koharu/Homura to not actively try alternatives. Of which, it wasn't.

Perhaps but that was just sole example.
Infact sasuke was left on his own and then could die on the missions, he nearly did.
Chunin exams could go wrong and then gaara.
Whole oro invasion.
Orochimaru could be more lucky too.

Itachi wasnt protecting shit Lol

Your points just proved some of the many ways Itachi protected Sasuke.

Sasuke nearly gave up against Orochimaru and Gaara. Then, he recalled his hatred for Itachi and that caused him to strive to live.

If Itachi didn't make Sasuke hate him, he would have died long ago.

Sasuke was not mega fodder but itachi couldnt expect him to go against konoha enemies just like that. Checking up isnt protection :p

Usually you supervise the training and then determine the capabilities to know what dangerous what isnt, not just torture one and incite him to hate and become stronger.

In case of oro curse mark alone it had 90% chance of sasuke being a goner, would you risk it?

Genin aren't expected to go against Konoha's enemies. That's the job of the Jounin and higher-level shinobi.

One cannot train someone when they're living miles away and living a facade just for the benefit of that very latter.

Itachi has no control over where Orochimaru goes. He didn't give Sasuke the CM, Orochimaru did.

We call it plot armour :cool:



Yeah itachi should have said so to his parents inb4 doing poor job protecting him.
One would think that it would be his main goal since he planned to die by sasuke's hand and give him his eyes, but then again this plan was worthless if sasuke wouldnt live up to the fight and he's done little to no protection.

He protected Sasuke and his plan worked up until his death. He kept his promise to his parents for much more than what was needed.

if you look at his hero Shisui, you would find where he inherited that stupidity.

Shisui wasn't his hero and Itachi was not stupid.

I'm going to murder all my family, friends and clan to prevent a war. Instead of just killing obito.

Aidachi logic

13 year olds with brand new MS cannot beat grown men with Kamui.

Also, killing Obito doesn't do anything. In fact, that doesn't even relate to the situation given that the coup is still in effect.

Thats what I have been saying to these Itachi and Danzo fappers. lol.

Itachi was a mere kid. Danzo was a power-hungry anti-uchiha dictator.

It doesn't take a fapper to notice that Itachi's choice was correct given his clan was dying if he didn't do things himself anyway.
 

Chazzi

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Veteran
Joined
Jul 5, 2014
Messages
2,404
Reaction score
201
It wouldn't have and the person that wrote it probably knows it himself.

The Uchiha had to die. All that Itachi did was preventing deaths, saving Sasuke and giving him a reason to live.

Indeed. Itachi just made the best out of the situation, the blame goes to Danzo.
 

Char Aznable

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 14, 2014
Messages
6,779
Reaction score
494
Itachi was a 13 year old brat who got TnJ'ed into killing his whole clan by Danzo. Danzo exploited Itachi's idealism for peace and used him to achieve his (Danzo's) own ends.
 

LordRevan

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Jul 31, 2012
Messages
549
Reaction score
34
Indeed. Itachi just made the best out of the situation, the blame goes to Danzo.

Itachi got used like a tool, by a guy named Danzo.... hence he is the "ideal" shinobi, like Haku.

Was a tool in the akatsuki
Was a tool to Danzo

Didn't make the best out of the sitation at all.
 

Chazzi

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Veteran
Joined
Jul 5, 2014
Messages
2,404
Reaction score
201
Itachi got used like a tool, by a guy named Danzo.... hence he is the "ideal" shinobi, like Haku.

Was a tool in the akatsuki
Was a tool to Danzo

Didn't make the best out of the sitation at all.

No, he wasn't.
Yes, he did.
 

Chie

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 10, 2014
Messages
8,333
Reaction score
1,599
Itachi was a 13 year old brat who got TnJ'ed into killing his whole clan by Danzo. Danzo exploited Itachi's idealism for peace and used him to achieve his (Danzo's) own ends.

I wouldn't necessarily refer to a scenario where his clan is dying no matter what he does as "tnj".

Itachi got used like a tool, by a guy named Danzo.... hence he is the "ideal" shinobi, like Haku.

Was a tool in the akatsuki
Was a tool to Danzo

Didn't make the best out of the sitation at all.

So, you're saying that it's better for the clan to be annihilated by Leaf forces and to be hated by all for their betrayal?

And yeah. Tools hinder plans. /sarcasm

No. He made the best of the situation.
 

RasenUchihaChaos

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Aug 2, 2012
Messages
9,150
Reaction score
702
Only the last one is legit the rest have reason oh the leaf defeated and captured the nine tails no way we are messing with that since kumo also has that problem also kumo did got to war with leaf remember they tried to kidnap hinata

Second pains invasion a summit was about to go under way kumo had dispatched team Samui to Konoha after sasukes assault on been

As for SS invasion hmmm we have reports that jiraiya is at the leaf should we mess with one of the sannins ?

And. Also each village risk attack from another if they go to war

The uchiha clan is different they are already inside the village they are uchiha so the damage and casualties would be high
 

LeSauce

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Apr 12, 2013
Messages
3,649
Reaction score
286
-Invasions at this point are unheard of. Simply because Akatsuki were hired by the nations to eliminate select shinobi from others. Ironically, the framework of Akatsuki prevented invasions and thus war started by the nations.

-The Kyuubi attack happened one year after the 3rd shinobi war concluded. No nation was ready to invade at that point.

-Suna was ruined at that point and Konoha was quickly rebuilt. The Sound shinobi took a worse beating than anyone from Konoha did. No one could invade at that point. Also, once again Akatsuki members are used at this point instead of invasions.

The Uchiha clan was not killed off only due to the possibility of invasion. Itachi killed them off to protect their honour and prevent a definitive conflict in Konohagakure itself. He didn't have a choice over the fate of their lives, only how they died.

You're saying one is an idiot for caring for their family and people. It may be time to reevaluate some of your viewpoints, mate.



No, his decision was smart. U_U



He did protect Sasuke given that Sasuke would have died numerous times had it not been for Itachi's influence in some way or another.

He let Deidara fight him because a) Killing Deidara would blow his cover in front of other Akatsuki and b) He knew Sasuke would win. Even when Zetsu told him and the other members Sasuke had died, he knew he hadn't. He had faith in him.

Having faith in a younger sibling is not bad at all. It allows room for them to grow.



His clan was dying regardless even if he didn't do it himself. He just chose to kill them himself to preserve their honour as well as prevent further conflict. That's worth it no matter how you slice it and from his side the situation is very clear-cut.

The real question is if it was worth it for Hiruzen and Danzo/Koharu/Homura to not actively try alternatives. Of which, it wasn't.



Your points just proved some of the many ways Itachi protected Sasuke.

Sasuke nearly gave up against Orochimaru and Gaara. Then, he recalled his hatred for Itachi and that caused him to strive to live.

If Itachi didn't make Sasuke hate him, he would have died long ago.



Genin aren't expected to go against Konoha's enemies. That's the job of the Jounin and higher-level shinobi.

One cannot train someone when they're living miles away and living a facade just for the benefit of that very latter.

Itachi has no control over where Orochimaru goes. He didn't give Sasuke the CM, Orochimaru did.



He protected Sasuke and his plan worked up until his death. He kept his promise to his parents for much more than what was needed.



Shisui wasn't his hero and Itachi was not stupid.



13 year olds with brand new MS cannot beat grown men with Kamui.

Also, killing Obito doesn't do anything. In fact, that doesn't even relate to the situation given that the coup is still in effect.



It doesn't take a fapper to notice that Itachi's choice was correct given his clan was dying if he didn't do things himself anyway.

I meant that he could have let another child live since they would be as innocent as Sasuke. That's if there were anymore though, but I think it was implied there was somewhere.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top