Itachi Discussion!!Do Read...

[shonu]

See what I say is people are different their opinions are different...
But considering Itachi a Hero is another topic!!
Heroes are not Stereotypical And of the same package...They may vary...
A hero is the one struggles for the sake of others,makes sacrifices...
He indeed is a Hero from this Point of view...
U may see It as He sacrificed the whole of his clan..That isn't easy you see!
Just Proving your heriocs doesn't make you a Hero But Thinking and taking actions for the Betterment of your society does!!

 

[Asami..]

I agree with you.

 

[Noni]

couldnt agree more...

 

[kooko]

:itachi: = evil

 

[Sasuke RKO]

OMFG!!! Seriously??? its not whether we consider him a hero.. its whether the hidden leaf. and the shenobi alliance considers him a hero.. im sure naruto considers him a hero.. our opinions dont rele matter

 

[shonu]

:itachi: = evil

No He isn't...what makes U think that..I'm here to debate!!! xd

 

[shonu]

OMFG!!! Seriously??? its not whether we consider him a hero.. its whether the hidden leaf. and the shenobi alliance considers him a hero.. im sure naruto considers him a hero.. our opinions dont rele matter

So who are you supporting exactly??are supporting Itachi or not?

 

[KingHashirama]

"Sacrificing" someone's life without their permission is called murder. .

Heroes do not murder innocent people.

He redeemed himself and his past mistake of killing his whole clan, by saving the Alliance after his death.

 

[USSJ Future Trunks]

the clan massacre was the only good thing he ever did with his life.

- tortured mocked and put sasuke in a coma
- ordered narutos attempted murder
- would have captured naruto if jiraiya didnt see through the genjutsu
- was going to stand there and let kisame kill asuma and tortured kakashi for no reason (regular genjutsu could serve the same purpose if he coudl apparently beat oro with it)
- planned to enslave and steal his brothers free will for eternity
- tried to kill kakashi (he never acted like he expected the water bunshin)
- failed to do anythign about akatsuki other than keep them away from konoha for a decade. gave no one any useful intel. kabuto was more helpful than him.
- helped akatsuki kill 7 people and continued to work for them when hiruzne is dead and thus his mission was done
- believed naruto could never get the power he ended up getting and still tried to send him to fight a possible evil MS sasuke.
- never trusted or even liked sasuke very much considering he manipulated him at every turn and had backup after backup in case "the right person paints his canvas black". was sasuke so mentally fragile that itachi thought any old guy could turn this kid evil? wow
- mindraped sasuke AGAIN and got him drunk on haterade

 

[Steaktacular]

It depends. From my point of view, he is. Others won´t agree with you and this might end badly.

 

[Baka Sennin]

what one man considers as heroic can be evil from another's perspective. itachi's actions were too morally gray to be able to definitely say he was heroic, when it can be so easily spun as misguided. he did the wrong thing for the right motive, let's leave it at that.

 

[USSJ Future Trunks]

"OMFG!!! Seriously??? its not whether we consider him a hero.. its whether the hidden leaf. and the shenobi alliance considers him a hero.. im sure naruto considers him a hero.. our opinions dont rele matter"
really? so we should bend over and take it when kishi tries to push the idea that itachi is oh so heroic and nagato is oh so evil when both have committed atrocities for the same goal? naruto never forgave nagato for his crimes but instantly forgives itachi. moral dissonance

 

[KingHashirama]

the clan massacre was the only good thing he ever did with his life.

- tortured mocked and put sasuke in a coma
- ordered narutos attempted murder
- would have captured naruto if jiraiya didnt see through the genjutsu
- was going to stand there and let kisame kill asuma and tortured kakashi for no reason (regular genjutsu could serve the same purpose if he coudl apparently beat oro with it)
- planned to enslave and steal his brothers free will for eternity
- tried to kill kakashi (he never acted like he expected the water bunshin)
- failed to do anythign about akatsuki other than keep them away from konoha for a decade. gave no one any useful intel. kabuto was more helpful than him.
- helped akatsuki kill 7 people and continued to work for them when hiruzne is dead and thus his mission was done
- believed naruto could never get the power he ended up getting and still tried to send him to fight a possible evil MS sasuke.
- never trusted or even liked sasuke very much considering he manipulated him at every turn and had backup after backup in case "the right person paints his canvas black". was sasuke so mentally fragile that itachi thought any old guy could turn this kid evil? wow
- mindraped sasuke AGAIN and got him drunk on haterade

If you agreed that the clan massacre was one of his good things.. then the rest of you points don't matter.

 

[Melanee]

Hero's only become true hero's after they've fallen from grace and redeemed themselves of their sins, but Itachi is not a fairy tale hero who rides in on a white horse, he's a fallen hero.

That's how I see it.

 

[P A N D E]

Itachi is a great hero to me. i don't care what other people say about him. haters gonna hate. some fools don't consider him a hero but i don't care

 

[roncato]

"OMFG!!! Seriously??? its not whether we consider him a hero.. its whether the hidden leaf. and the shenobi alliance considers him a hero.. im sure naruto considers him a hero.. our opinions dont rele matter"
really? so we should bend over and take it when kishi tries to push the idea that itachi is oh so heroic and nagato is oh so evil when both have committed atrocities for the same goal? naruto never forgave nagato for his crimes but instantly forgives itachi. moral dissonance

What are you talking about? He forgave Itachi and Nagato everything. And I agree that Itachi is hero. He's mine hero.

 

[shonu]

See from the last chap. its clear about the character of the Uchihas..
Love-hate thingy!!If the children would have been left,they would have gone crazy..who could be a better example than Sasuke?

He was well aware that there were Obito-type people who may lead to the war which is why he took this step...

 

[shonu]

Hero's only become true hero's after they've fallen from grace and redeemed themselves of their sins, but Itachi is not a fairy tale hero who rides in on a white horse, he's a fallen hero.

That's how I see it.

Thats what I wanna say..But I'm jumping between the 2 threads,thats why a bit confused about the answers!!:ghehe:

"OMFG!!! Seriously??? its not whether we consider him a hero.. its whether the hidden leaf. and the shenobi alliance considers him a hero.. im sure naruto considers him a hero.. our opinions dont rele matter"
really? so we should bend over and take it when kishi tries to push the idea that itachi is oh so heroic and nagato is oh so evil when both have committed atrocities for the same goal? naruto never forgave nagato for his crimes but instantly forgives itachi. moral dissonance

Naruto Forgave Nagato atlast...But what Nagato did was Different from Itachi!!
Itachi joined the Akatsuki To save the shinobi from where nagato could have gone wrong...As a spy!!

what one man considers as heroic can be evil from another's perspective. itachi's actions were too morally gray to be able to definitely say he was heroic, when it can be so easily spun as misguided. he did the wrong thing for the right motive, let's leave it at that.

So what do you think abt that?

 

[AnimusOra]

Its like it stated in the manga, Itachi could see the bigger picture and he also took himself out of the equation so to speak. I consider him a hero but not in the sense that he saved the village, but the fact that he saved the entire world. If he would not have done what he did the 4th world ninja war would have begun alot sooner and Obito would have taken this opportunity to start the moons eye plan.

 

[VongolaX]

Without itachi, konoha would of been finish. So you people who are saying he's evil STFU, if he was truely evil he would be running akatsuki by now.