Isn't using Edo-Tensei on Madara a terrible idea ?

[Ensifer]

Think about it for a second, that technique was the primary reason on why he went wild to begin with, having access to cutting ties with the user for his own agenda. Even though Obito is now freed from his curse mark it still makes him a dangerous target that would be incapable of staying dead.

I'm just trying to figure out the 2nd Hokage's train of thought, as much as I love him it would be quite a dangerous idea.

You must be registered for see images

 

[saw2097]

I doubt Tobirama is dumb enough to do it without taking precautions, remember he invented the Jutsu.

 

[SasukeUzumakiTheGreat]

He can be controlled by the caster of edo tensei

 

[Ensifer]

He can be controlled by the caster of edo tensei

Not with Madara and Hashirama, the latter of which has broken his ties with Orochimaru(as presently seen in the current anime episode).

 

[Im Still Robin]

No kage knows that happened so it would be funny as hell if he does it again.
Though I want to see reactions when they learn about Indra/Sasuke and Ashura/Naruto, that always excites me.

 

[babaGAReeb]

I doubt Tobirama is dumb enough to do it without taking precautions, remember he invented the Jutsu.

this .

 

[ᖇ α z m α η]

Tobirama gave a probable solution [He's one of da realist characters in Naruto] :/

 

[90sKids98]

No because Tobirama will stop the Edo Tensei. Madara was able to release it b/c Kabuto was incapacitated and lost all control. Instead Tobirama will just stop the summon at any time after they seal kaguya

 

[Dãrth1]

Tobirama
Is dumber than AKAMARU
Because of HIM
MADARA LIVED
GOT RINNEGAN
ALL OF THIS STARTED
HE INPLANTED THE SEED OF THE CURSE OF HATRED
#DOWN TOBIRAMA

 

[Da Best Ever]

Godara cannot be controlled by edo tensei, if orochimaru wasn't using Hashirama cells Tobirama would have broken free of edo tensei back when they were talking to sasuke, and Tobirama wasn't going to use Hashirama dna now so it's clear madara cannot be bound by edo tensei.

The question is which version madara would be revived and since Tobirama is not the best user of edo tensei madara might come back as ems or ms his weakest self.

 

[obito uchiha the wraith]

Tobirama
Is dumber than AKAMARU
Because of HIM
MADARA LIVED
GOT RINNEGAN
ALL OF THIS STARTED
HE INPLANTED THE SEED OF THE CURSE OF HATRED
#DOWN TOBIRAMA

its not tobiramas fault that madara tried to destroy the world just because tobirama gave him the stank eye.

 

[Shadow Phantasm]

Tobirama should ask Kabuto what happened when he brought back Madara the first time.

Tobirama's idea was a very bad one.

 

[Trúth]

Guys your forgetting he can control the power at which Madara comes back at. If they bring him back weaker than in Part 1 Hashi and Tobirama Madara can't break it.

 

[Da Best Ever]

No because Tobirama will stop the Edo Tensei. Madara was able to release it b/c Kabuto was incapacitated and lost all control. Instead Tobirama will just stop the summon at any time after they seal kaguya

False Madara broke it because he knows the seals to do so as he stated. He never needed to use it obviously when Kabuto was not incapacitated because Kabuto let him roam freely, if Kabuto tried to restrict him he would have broken it. Tobirama is the weakest master of edo tensei and he was about to break himself out of edo tensei if not for Hashirama's cells orochimaru was using to enhance edo tensei.

 

[Tarinth]

Tobirama's edo tensei wasn't perfected. So Madara would come back much weaker.
Maybe as weak as Orochimaru's part 1 edo tenseis, or even weaker.
That way, it would be easy to control Madara, and even if he broke free, he would be easy to subdue.

 

[Da Best Ever]

Guys your forgetting he can control the power at which Madara comes back at. If they bring him back weaker than in Part 1 Hashi and Tobirama Madara can't break it.

Part 1Madara is ems and ms madara. Which are both still more powerful than Tobirama and comparable to Hashirama.

Whatever version of madara is brought back would still have all Madara's knowledge meaning he still knows the seals to release him from edo tensei.

 

[Da Best Ever]

Tobirama's edo tensei wasn't perfected. So Madara would come back much weaker.
Maybe as weak as Orochimaru's part 1 edo tenseis, or even weaker.
That way, it would be easy to control Madara, and even if he broke free, he would be easy to subdue.

Not necessarily easily subdued by Tobirama because a 50% madara would be still have susano and his uchiha abilities and killer instinct making him still very dangerous and still only Hashirama would be able to subdue him. Also Tobirama never showed to use edo tensei nor did he say he didn't master it, he just told orochimaru that orochimaru got better with it so you can't assume Tobirama sucks as bad as part 1 orochimaru did with edo tensei.

 

[Trúth]

Part 1Madara is ems and ms madara. Which are both still more powerful than Tobirama and comparable to Hashirama.

Whatever version of madara is brought back would still have all Madara's knowledge meaning he still knows the seals to release him from edo tensei.

You don't understand. Remember when Oro brought back the first and second and they were MUCH weaker? Thats what i mean. They can do the same to Madara. And even if he rewrites the seals so what? That doesn't change the fact he would be weaker.

 

[Da Best Ever]

I doubt Tobirama is dumb enough to do it without taking precautions, remember he invented the Jutsu.

He inventing the jutsu means nothing, he has one edo tensei jutsu and that's his infinite exploding bombs jutsu. Tobirama cannot stop madara if madara decides to break free of edo tensei which most likely he will not so much as to do evil he knows now he was fooled but I don't think he likes Tobirama at all for several reasons and I'm sure no one wants to be controlled by the person they hate the most. Hashirama is the only shinobi that can stop madara, aside from current naruto and sasuke.

 

[HiddenSound]

I'm sure they'd bring him back with nowhere near as much power as he had. Orochimaru can do that, as shown when he summoned the 1st and 2nd all those years ago. And besides, I'm pretty sure Edo Hashirama and Edo Tobirama can beat Edo Madara.