[Discussion] Is Tite writing a better storyline than Kishi?

[Retsu]

Bleach to me goes over board with power ups. I admit the current arc is kind of better than this excuse of a war, but it seems like ichigo gets a power up every single time a new Manga gets released

 

[Renpatsu Dei]

I agree, although I feel like Kubo should have have actually killed off the characters that were supposedly going to die, like Byakuya, when the Quincies invaded, so far Bleach has been doing better than Naruto recently. Killing off Tsunade would have been a good start to show that they're actually in a War.

That's the problem right now, it doesn't really feel like a war.

A lot of these people not dying has a lot to do with editors: Byakuya is too popular to die. It was the same thing with Hitsugaya in fake Karakura town. In Tsunade's case, she wasn't given the Kishi treatment, with a grand death. If Tsunade was to die by being split in half by a tree off screen I would have been disgusted by Kishi. There has to be a point to the deaths otherwise it just seems false.

OT: Yeah, I would agree that right now Bleach is a lot more interesting than Naruto, I think the overall story of Naruto is still better for now because there is a deeper philosophical question about peace being answered in it while Bleach is just beating the next bad guy. Kubo's attention to detail has been superb in this arc and I am more entertained, but that has often been the case with bleach even in the bad times.

 

[Skull Knight]

Bleach to me goes over board with power ups. I admit the current arc is kind of better than this excuse of a war, but it seems like ichigo gets a power up every single time a new Manga gets released

yep that kubo giving powerup 2 ichigo makes its viewers excited abt his powers.

 

[Skull Knight]

well Bleach have no story to begin with (real goal) so idk what you're talking about,
Bleach story is limited /Arc while Kishimoto is trying to connect each arc with his so so story telling,
so in a whole i find Kishimoto as a better story teller than kubo.

firstly this is not which series is better bleach or naruto.
secondly as my 1st post was that "current bleach arc is better than naruto's current arc"has been accepted widely.even myself being a naruto fan is saying that kishi is being killed by kubo in every new bleach chapters currently.

 

[Two]

for the last year Bleach has been by far my favourite manga..and before then i was giving up on it

 

[Roy]

At the moment his writing is better.. in my opinion u-u

 

[repulse]

give me a break,will u?bleach is currently totally bs,so many asspulls out of nowhere as usual.
whereas naruto is at it's best right now,things are heating up to it's max.kishi does obvious things yet people hate it 'cause people are so much into naruto that they start to forget it's not their manga,and things won't always go their way.they hate obito because he isn't izuna and not doing what they want,dumbasses.
none of u give a shit of how things should proceed in bleech thus u love it the way it is..accept the truth,that's the only reason.
and onepiece is literally a piece of shit.712 chapter still no clue what/where the **** is onepiece,just wow.what a writing?it's as if oda has not even decided what the **** is onepiece,even.and tell me that onepiece>naruto or bleach when it's nearing it's end cause it's still midway and bleach and naruto at their middle and hell even now>onepiece.

What hole did you crawl out of? The whole thing with the Zakpakuto makes sense, and the war with the Quincies does as well. Hahaha, since when did you become the orator of OUR opinions and thoughts about manga?

You are actually making me think you're a dumbass...moreover, you have me CONVINCED that you are. One Piece isn't supposed to be revealed yet, the entire basis of the manga is discovering what One Piece is. The OP storyline is easily greater than Naruto's or Bleach's, period.

 

[Rot]

Bleach doing better then it was..

Naruto doing not as good as it was

All in all, taking into consideration all of both storys..

Naruto still better, simply because of all the BS Kubo did in pretty much every arc..he lost me at Butterfly Aizen and then confirmed it with the following "Xcution" arc which was just absolute crap and made no sense

 

[Simple Math]

give me a break,will u?bleach is currently totally bs,so many asspulls out of nowhere as usual.
whereas naruto is at it's best right now,things are heating up to it's max.kishi does obvious things yet people hate it 'cause people are so much into naruto that they start to forget it's not their manga,and things won't always go their way.they hate obito because he isn't izuna and not doing what they want,dumbasses.
none of u give a shit of how things should proceed in bleech thus u love it the way it is..accept the truth,that's the only reason.
and onepiece is literally a piece of shit.712 chapter still no clue what/where the **** is onepiece,just wow.what a writing?it's as if oda has not even decided what the **** is onepiece,even.and tell me that onepiece>naruto or bleach when it's nearing it's end cause it's still midway and bleach and naruto at their middle and hell even now>onepiece.

someone is having a bad day today

 

[Enigmatic]

Personally I think Kubo is a lazy artist...he uses up all of his panels on sword swishing and bs..example: Ulquorra vs Ichigo fight..and "The Heart"..

 

[Strata Uchiha]

The difference maker was that Tite Kubo took a month off from writing manga to get some inspiration for his final arc. He went to Europe to do this. It's paid off big time. Even chapters of Bleach where there is no action, and just talking is a better than an eventful chapter of Naruto.

 

[Erudito]

give me a break,will u?bleach is currently totally bs,so many asspulls out of nowhere as usual.
whereas naruto is at it's best right now,things are heating up to it's max.kishi does obvious things yet people hate it 'cause people are so much into naruto that they start to forget it's not their manga,and things won't always go their way.they hate obito because he isn't izuna and not doing what they want,dumbasses.
none of u give a shit of how things should proceed in bleech thus u love it the way it is..accept the truth,that's the only reason.
and onepiece is literally a piece of shit.712 chapter still no clue what/where the **** is onepiece,just wow.what a writing?it's as if oda has not even decided what the **** is onepiece,even.and tell me that onepiece>naruto or bleach when it's nearing it's end cause it's still midway and bleach and naruto at their middle and hell even now>onepiece.

You must be registered for see images