[Discussion] Is this another plothole ?

[Keisuke1993]

So i've just rewatched the anime version of Madara vs Guy and Obito vs Kakashi ,and i noticed something :
Here Madara says Guy nearly killed him :

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

And remember that some theorized that it was because Guy slightly missed Madara's heart here :

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

But if a Juubi's Jinchuriki can't regenerate a destroyed heart then why Obito did it without a problem ?

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

In fact why was he still alive as non Jinchuriki after suffering that wound on top of a slash by Minato ?

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

 

[oxtopus]

Maddy got a thing for hearts.

You must be registered for see images

 

[konoha Sev7n]

madara got this heart broken, when this little bro died an then this clan turn against him an even this buddy Hashirama turn an new leaf an decided to end this life at valley of the end, heart broken for all those times.. even in this dark cave.. lost hope what no one ever will challenge the same way that hashirama battle him..until Might Guy came along lol.

geting stab in the heart change the person for the better or worse in madara case.. complete obsession about heart related topic lol... uchiha has strong emotion.. the heart ...the love..

 

[Rohan]

I think Madara was just praising Guy as an awesome opponent. :hmm:

 

[-Haku Yuki-]

No madara meant he nearly killed him, as in if "I wasn't the tentails jinchuriki I'd be dead"

 

[Wparker6804]

No madara meant he nearly killed him, as in if "I wasn't the tentails jinchuriki I'd be dead"

This. Madara never said anything about his heart--it was,as you said, a fan theory.

 

[Keisuke1993]

No madara meant he nearly killed him, as in if "I wasn't the tentails jinchuriki I'd be dead"

Hmm , make sense.

 

[Angelic.]

obito dies only when he wants too

 

[lolokane]

maybe if it had obliterated madara's head, he would have not been able to regenerate?

 

[AXSPOILER]

Obito had no heart he was crushed in the 3rd ninja war. Obito was only kept alive by zetsu. His heart is gone and he can regenerate whenever he wants too so plothole covered.

 

[Keisuke1993]

Obito had no heart he was crushed in the 3rd ninja war. Obito was only kept alive by zetsu. His heart is gone and he can regenerate whenever he wants too so plothole covered.

Proof ?
Because as far as i know the heart is located on the left side while only the right side of Obito got crushed.


Edit : Madara put a seal on Obito's heart to stop him from becoming a Jinchuriki or committing suicide, so next time learn to read the manga you Narutotard.

 

[BlacLord™]

"Another" plothole, as if any of the other apparent ones weren't debunked as quickly as they were made. Your whole idea rests on a theory that I've never even heard of.

Madara was playing, and he ended up with more than just a stab through the heart; just look at the top right panel, half of his torso has been splattered out of existence.