Is photographic memory legit?

Nagi

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Apr 7, 2014
Messages
7,112
Reaction score
411
Photographic memory is a term often used to describe a person who seems able to recall visual information in great detail. Just as a photograph freezes a moment in time, the implication for people thought to have photographic memory is that they can take mental snapshots and then recall these snapshots without error.

Some initial tests have suggested that quite a number of children, and perhaps adults too, have a special ability – something like a photographic memory, called “eidetic imagery”. This allows them to continue to 'see' an image, in detail, for a short while even after it is taken away.

How come some of us have this special ability?​
 

SKTupac

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Aug 22, 2008
Messages
1,362
Reaction score
37
I can remember anything of a place where i have been once. For example i went to a city i never went before and my father and uncle were in the frontseat and i was in the backseat and we took a certain path to a hotel and then from there i went to this and that bar (i was like 15 years old) and that was the first time i went there.
After 7 years on my 22th age i went there with my friends, this time i was the driver and i found my way to the same hotel through the same path we took and knew exactly where to eat, go out to bars and buy clothes, etc. like i did 7 years ago. I don't know if that counts, but yeah. Every place i have been once.
 

Nagi

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Apr 7, 2014
Messages
7,112
Reaction score
411
I can remember anything of a place where i have been once. For example i went to a city i never went before and my father and uncle were in the frontseat and i was in the backseat and we took a certain path to a hotel and then from there i went to this and that bar (i was like 15 years old) and that was the first time i went there.
After 7 years on my 22th age i went there with my friends, this time i was the driver and i found my way to the same hotel through the same path we took and knew exactly where to eat, go out to bars and buy clothes, etc. like i did 7 years ago. I don't know if that counts, but yeah. Every place i have been once.

Things like that, nearly everybody can remember it. But I'm talking about looking at piece of paper with information on it. For some reason, if I don't care about the information on the paper, I'll remember it. If I do care about it a lot, I'll forget the information right after I put the paper down.
 

Pyro NB

Amegakure
Elite
Joined
Apr 22, 2015
Messages
8,809
Reaction score
406
Just genetics I guess some are gifted with it some aren't
 

Nick01

Legendary
Joined
Mar 18, 2014
Messages
12,556
Reaction score
796
It's a lesser version of the 1 tomoe sharingan. :hint:
 

Avani

Supreme
Joined
Jan 26, 2009
Messages
20,751
Reaction score
4,013
It's probably a myth. Just that some people are always more gifted and train themselves well:-
 

ChicagoJhawk

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Jul 1, 2015
Messages
4,577
Reaction score
422
It's a lesser version of the 1 tomoe sharingan. :hint:

So if a person were to kill his best friend to activate ms photographic memory and then I took his eyes...would that mean I would have eternal magyeakou photographic memory!?!?
 

Nick01

Legendary
Joined
Mar 18, 2014
Messages
12,556
Reaction score
796
So if a person were to kill his best friend to activate ms photographic memory and then I took his eyes...would that mean I would have eternal magyeakou photographic memory!?!?

MS definitely. :scorps:
I'm afraid the eyes would need to belong to a sibling in order to achieve Eternal Mangekyou Photographic Memory. :sweat:
 

Aim64C

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Dec 18, 2012
Messages
3,681
Reaction score
608
There was a case mentioned in a psychology book I had in college back in 2005 about a girl who was the strongest among a set of case studies investigating the concept of a photographic memory. She could recall details from the image for about ten seconds, if I remember correctly, before it faded from memory.

The 'problem' is in how the brain tends to remember things. The brain doesn't remember 'raw' information so much so as it remembers 'quirks.'

When you take a picture with a camera, information is recorded as to the state of individual photocells at the given time of the picture. Every photo cell is recorded and the information is stored to be recalled again. Unless it is compressed, in which case, information about groups of data points is collected. All of this can be pulled up to produce an exact replica upon demand.

However, there is only so much need for this within typical patterns of human behavior. The fact that we bothered to create photographs or that good portrait painters were held in esteem in older societies is a testament to our limited ability to both retain information about exact appearance and our difficulty in communicating it to others through oration.

Put simply, we tend to suck at remembering images and use tools to solve the problem.

This is because, as I said, the brain remembers 'quirks.' It is, you could think of, a sort of compression. You remember that a person is missing a tooth more readily than you could pick out their cheek bone. You remember a hair style more easily than you remember the face associated with the hair style (one of the reasons people look so different to us based on how they wear their hair). You might remember a particular set of freckles a person had or a peculiar stance in their posture.

For example... what color is the couch in the latest AVGN video you've seen? Was he even sitting on a couch? Can you even remember what he was sitting on (or substitute any other video series you may watch)?

We don't have photographic memories because these details tend to get lost. We may remember that there was a pizza box in the background - but from where? In what position? And what was it sitting on, or what was next to it?

The brain remembers quirks and concepts. Everything tends to get reduced to the level of detail you would use in conversation. Even things you remember well enough to 'see again' are heavily subject to the way our brain tends to 'compress' information.

Granted - the exact processes of memory are still being researched, and it is likely that different people have considerably different ways in which their brain remembers information. Some of which may be better suited to 'photographic memory' type things.... but it has, to my knowledge, never been demonstrated for a person to have a truly photographic memory in the sense that they can take a sort of 'snapshot' to look at and pull details from, later.

Another problem arises when we consider the limitations of the eye. If you hold out your hand at arm's length and extend your thumb - your thumb-nail is about how big the area is that your eyes have 'maximum' resolution for. The quality of vision drops rapidly as you extend into the peripheral - where image resolution can be as low as 'feet per pixel' depending upon the exact distances involved.

You must be registered for see images


This is pretty close to how your eyes see things. Because you sweep your eyes very quickly across a scene on instinct to 'stitch together' a scene, it is rare for you to ever have a 'photograph' to work with.

In marketing, researchers use devices to track eye movement and determine where people are looking when they encounter an advertisement and what-not. "heat maps", as they are called, are used to highlight where people spend their time looking at an image:

You must be registered for see images


The colors on the lower images relates to how much time the eyes of people spend there.

In the left image, the model for the product is looking at the viewer - in the other, she is looking at the product - and whether conscious of it or not, people instinctively react differently to the simple adjustment to eye placement.

Notice, however, that the eyes spend very little time elsewhere in the scene. To drive this point home:

You must be registered for see images


The eyes spend a lot of time on the face, do a brief scope-out of the twins, and try to figure out what is with that dark line on her arm.

Since the focal point of the eyes is so narrow and the range covered so contextual - it's difficult to understand how someone could remember that the drapes on the wall behind her had an accompanying blue top or that the display behind her had some kind of red and blue fabric.... unless a point was made to try and grab those details with the part of the eye that can actually perceive them.
 

random girlz

Member
Joined
Nov 14, 2015
Messages
240
Reaction score
15
You might have a photographic memory at the end of you're life as your entire life is flashing before your eyes.
 
Top