[Discussion] Is One Piece better Naruto?

[Our Lord Sasuke]

Is One Piece better than Naruto? As story-line I can say yes is alot better but fights in the OP are pretty lame but it focus more on story
Also One Piece doesn't have characters development (except Zoro maybe)

 

[Zexion~]

No, only thing its better at is world building.

 

[JStar King]

Is One Piece better than Naruto? As story-line I can say yes is alot better but fights in the OP are pretty lame but it focus more on story
Also One Piece doesn't have characters development (except Zoro maybe)

Plot wise, One Piece is better. Fight wise, ehh, I'll say Naruto.

On another note, no character development? What have you been watching? You've obviously never read or watched One Piece have you, because if you did, you wasn't paying attention.

You must be registered for see images

 

[Our Lord Sasuke]

Plot wise, One Piece is better. Fight wise, ehh, I'll say Naruto.

On another note, no character development? What have you been watching? You've obviously never read or watched One Piece have you, because if you did, you wasn't paying attention.

You must be registered for see images

Idk I just said that they not have so much training, Straw Hats become strong after they left a island

 

[Passerby]

is one piece better than naruto? As story-line i can say yes is alot better but fights in the op are pretty lame but it focus more on story
also one piece doesn't have characters development (except zoro maybe)

#facts!

 

[Deadlift]

Nice fanfic..........

 

[Skull Knight]

Idk I just said that they not have so much training, Straw Hats become strong after they left a island

They do train when they are moving from one place to another.
It was already shown pre timeskip where Zoro was lifting weights in the gym.

 

[ToshiZO]

In terms of character development Naruto is the gutter. The characters either develop too radically (Sasuke), or get downright ignored (entire konoha 11). There are like 2 characters in Naruto that get any attention. Naruto and Sasuke, that's it.

Fights Naruto > One Piece by far.

Overall as a story Naruto doesn't even know what it's doing, Kishimoto wasn't following his own manga tbh, the timelines are all over the place creating plot holes. One Piece is much more coherent.

 

[JStar King]

Idk I just said that they not have so much training, Straw Hats become strong after they left a island

Since when is training the only way to develop a character?

You must be registered for see images

You have the Strawhat crew's backstories and what they've went through to get to this point in the story.

In terms of character development Naruto is the gutter. The characters either develop too radically (Sasuke), or get downright ignored (entire konoha 11). There are like 2 characters in Naruto that get any attention. Naruto and Sasuke, that's it.

Fights Naruto > One Piece by far.

Overall as a story Naruto doesn't even know what it's doing, Kishimoto wasn't following his own manga tbh, the timelines are all over the place creating plot holes. One Piece is much more coherent.

Nothing, but pure facts here.

 

[Our Lord Sasuke]

Since when is training the only way to develop a character?

You must be registered for see images

You have the Strawhat crew's backstories and what they've went through to get to this point in the story.




Nothing, but pure facts here.

I just saying that training make development obvious.

 

[Tauren Chieftain]

One piece is too childish in my opinion.

 

[JStar King]

I just saying that training make development obvious.

And so does a character having a consistent backstory and being tested throughout the series with hardships and tribulations.One Piece isn't Dragonball Super, where you just train and get a massive power up calling it development.

Two separate story prompts when it comes to creating consistent characters. Well, there's nothing consistent about the Dragon Ball series, but you get my point.

 

[JStar King]

One piece is too childish in my opinion.

You obviously never seen the Marineford Arc.

 

[Skull Knight]

In terms of storyline & chatacter development OP is obviously better than Naruto.
In terms of fights and emotion I think Naruto is better than OP.

 

[Our Lord Sasuke]

And so does a character having a consistent backstory and being tested throughout the series with hardships and tribulations.One Piece isn't Dragonball Super, where you just train and get a massive power up calling it development.

Two separate story prompts when it comes to creating consistent characters. Well, there's nothing consistent about the Dragon Ball series, but you get my point.

Yes I get it.

 

[JStar King]

In terms of storyline & chatacter development OP is obviously better than Naruto.
In terms of fights and emotion I think Naruto is better than OP.

I can agree 100% on that. I love the fights in Naruto. The only thing I don't like about it are the asspulls.

If you look up the definition of an Asspull, Naruto would pop up.

 

[Tauren Chieftain]

You obviously never seen the Marineford Arc.

Its too childish I simply can´t stand it .I see you have Berserk in your signature so compare berserk and one piece to realise what I am talking about.

 

[HokageKid]

The fights are cooler in Naruto but One Piece has a much better story.
One Piece has also been going on a lot longer than Naruto, so it's even more impressive that it hasn't become lame or boring, or just stupid.
Naruto got really shitty towards the end.

 

[Hexuze]

OP is better in all aspects. (Unless I'm forgetting some)

The issue with OP fights is that Oda switches too much or just pointless talking. Other than that, they're still better than Naruto. My problem with OP ATM is the time skip...SH's feel bland with little development. Also arcs feel a bit lazy when Oda uses a similar structure from the pre-TS arcs. They're still good but I'd like something entirely fresh.

 

[JStar King]

Its too childish I simply can´t stand it .I see you have Berserk in your signature so compare berserk and one piece to realise what I am talking about.

You can't compare Seinen with Shounen. Two different genres with two different themes.

You must be registered for see images