Is it possible that Ashura and Indra weren't the only ones that transmigrated?

[Kirby1]

It has been well established in the manga that Ashura and Indra transmigrated throughout the generations. But personally, I don't think that they were the only two out of the Otsutsuki family to transmigrate from generation to generation.

Yes, I know Hagoromo didn't transmigrate, but what if he is just an exception? What if his mother, brother and father (if he has one) transmigrated as well?

My theory: All of Hagoromo's family tansmigrated except for him, Hinata is Kaguya's reincarnation and as for the other two, I don't know who they could be the reincarnations of.

 

[sage of the sharingan]

we have to wait for kishi to reveal this kinds of things.

 

[Cunning Linguist]

Submit proof about Hinata

 

[blackstar9]

You dont think the sage would have mentioned that ?

 

[Sir Blades]

Ok Kishi calm the fuk down.

 

[Xlad]

No, that only happened because they're chakra was powerful enough to stay even after death. Not surprising considering they were direct halves of Hagoromo himself. And no, he already gave out his family extension when he revealed he had a brother.

 

[Mari Makinami]

I like how people make Hinata Kaguya's reincarnation just because both of them have byakugan though absolutely nothing else in common. Where the heck does it come from? You want to tell that Kaguya wants to bang her own grandson?..
What's next? Sakura being Kushina's incarnation?..

OT: Care to give any arguments that support your 'theory', or it's just a fanfiction of yours?

 

[odara rasengan]

We know very little about hagoromo and his family. We cant possibly make any prediction on who else transmigrated other than ashura and indra.

 

[AlastorNazura17]

Lmaoo, I laugh at all the fools saying Hinata is Kaguya's reincarnation.

Just because they both have Byakugan? That doesn't prove/ mean anything.

Hagoromo only said his sons transmigrated, no one else.

 

[BLAZE]

It has been well established in the manga that Ashura and Indra transmigrated throughout the generations. But personally, I don't think that they were the only two out of the Otsutsuki family to transmigrate from generation to generation.

Yes, I know Hagoromo didn't transmigrate, but what if he is just an exception? What if his mother, brother and father (if he has one) transmigrated as well?

My theory: All of Hagoromo's family tansmigrated except for him, Hinata is Kaguya's reincarnation and as for the other two, I don't know who they could be the reincarnations of.

just tell me brother why a side char irrelevent to 95% of the story will be kaguya's reincarnation

 

[BLAZE]

I like how people make Hinata Kaguya's reincarnation just because both of them have byakugan though absolutely nothing else in common. Where the heck does it come from? You want to tell that Kaguya wants to bang her own grandson?..
What's next? Sakura being Kushina's incarnation?..

OT: Care to give any arguments that support your 'theory', or it's just a fanfiction of yours?

common bro sakura is older than naruto she was born before kushina died

 

[Mari Makinami]

common bro sakura is older than naruto she was born before kushina died

I've already seen "theories" about Danzo being Tobirama's incarnation, nothing would surprise me

 

[Kirby1]

we have to wait for kishi to reveal this kinds of things.

True! Hopefully he will soon! I also hope Kishi reveals who Hagoromo's father was!


Now As for my theory on Hinata being Kaguya's reincarnation, let me point out two other things of why I think that other than Byakugan:

1. Noble Status

2. Women

3. Hime style cut (at least at the back end for Kaguya).

So there you have that!

 

[BLAZE]

True! Hopefully he will soon! I also hope Kishi reveals who Hagoromo's father was!


Now As for my theory on Hinata being Kaguya's reincarnation, let me point out two other things of why I think that other than Byakugan:

1. Noble Status

2. Women

3. Hime style cut (at least at the back end for Kaguya).

So there you have that!

hey bro reincarnation is not same as transmigration.
by your logic naruto and sauce will become grandsons of hinata

 

[Mari Makinami]

True! Hopefully he will soon! I also hope Kishi reveals who Hagoromo's father was!


Now As for my theory on Hinata being Kaguya's reincarnation, let me point out two other things of why I think that other than Byakugan:

1. Noble Status

2. Women

3. Hime style cut (at least at the back end for Kaguya).

So there you have that!

Ultimate facepalm. Then why not Hanabi? Her hair looks more like Kaguya's:

You must be registered for see images

Naruto and Sasuke don't look like Ashura and Indra. Your arguments are not valid here, appearance has nothing to do with reincarnation.
Howerver they do resemble Ashura and Indra with their personalities, ideals and fate, which are the main traits of reincarnation, as it was explained by Hagoromo. How does Hinata resemble Kaguya? Even if she was the main heroine, not a fodder, they have absolutely nothing in common. Hell, even Hanabi has more similar personality to Kaguya than Hinata. This is not a theory, dude, this is idiocy.

/thread

 

[BLAZE]

why can't any understand that
transmigration is a cycle the chakra is is always there it just needs a host.
there isn't any reincarnation in NV

 

[Mari Makinami]

why can't any understand that
transmigration is a cycle the chakra is is always there it just needs a host.
there isn't any reincarnation in NV

I guess you read some other manga. Look at the bottom panel:

You must be registered for see images

 

[BLAZE]

i guess i was wrong what r they transmigration or reincarnation

 

[coolcoolaman]

dude who told u that hinata is the reincarnation of kyuga
and only indira and ashura souls transmigrates coz they never get solution to their problem with each other....
so6p and his brother didn't seems to have any problem since we they faught together with jubbii and nothing mention about ther rivalry..

 

[Kirby1]

dude who told u that hinata is the reincarnation of kyuga
and only indira and ashura souls transmigrates coz they never get solution to their problem with each other....
so6p and his brother didn't seems to have any problem since we they faught together with jubbii and nothing mention about ther rivalry..

This is all theory/speculation that I have been spouting off on this thread. We'll never know if Hagoromo's mother, brother and father (if he had one) transmigrated as well until Kishi reveals it.

/thread