In terms of being a Medical Shinobi, do you think ...

[Narutohokage324]

In terms of being a Medical Shinobi, do you think Sakura surpassed Tsunade at all in the manga? Chapter 700 is not even debatable since she was not shown in a medical facility, and we can easily just say "Yes" because it was a ... 6-10 year time skip.

 

[Venomous Cobra]

Well maybe when she shows an actual regenerating feats that isn't based on Assumptions

 

[BLAZE]

Yeah most likely

 

[Bantos]

Tsunade created arms for other people. Case closed.

 

[Amenominaka]

"I understand you saying that Tsunade shits on Sakura in medical ninjutsu (in the other thread), but it has been many years after the war. During the war Sakura's abilities in medical ninjutsu rivaled Tsunade's. One can only assumed that her abilities have grown in the following years.

Also (this probably has nothing to do with what you or I said) doesn't it say somewhere in the databook that Sakura started out with Tsunade's level of chakra control and then later blossomed. Again, this probably doesn't have anything to do with what you or I said. Just stating this."

 

[Beyond the Horizon]

I would think so, considering what she was capable of already at age seventeen.

 

[The Necromancer]

Well maybe when she shows an actual regenerating feats that isn't based on Assumptions

That's like saying Jiraiya's and Minato's rasengans couldn't bust a water tower because it never happened in the manga.

 

[Conspirator.]

I don't think she did.

 

[Venomous Cobra]

That's like saying Jiraiya's and Minato's rasengans couldn't bust a water tower because it never happened in the manga.

Nah ,i only want a clue in which suggests that she actually did ,people use this panel most of the time

You must be registered for see images

but nothing actually shows that she did ,kishi didn't hint it like he does to tsunade or kisame.




but if you're saying that she regenerates because of the fact that she has byakougo then yeah i would have no choice but to agree ,cause databook clearly states that whenever you unlock the byakougo seal ,it can regenerate all the injuries on the body.


What bothers me is that people use that panel as if she actually regenerated in which she obviously didn't ,i know that its possible but being "possible" isn't enough to count it as feat.

 

[Melanin]

Medical Shinobi (Tsunade/Sakura Practically) = Doctor's/Physician's, Tsunade has been a Doctor/Physician for over 50 years while Sakura has gone to medical school for 3 years and has been a Doctor/Physician for 10+ year's.

Doctorial excellence is reached through medical knowledge obtain but mainly on the basis of experience. Example being, there's two surgeons Surgeon 1 has successfully operated on 30 hearts through out their 15 year career while Surgeon 2 has successfully operated on 15 hearts thorough out his/her 13 career. Who's the better surgeon on paper? Who would you rather have operate on your heart?
So in a nutshell, Tsunade experience makes her superior to Sakura medically even though Sakura has excellent medical feats.

 

[Narutohokage324]

Good points made

 

[FemmeFatale]

Sakura has better chakra control
Tsunade has better control of the effectiveness of the jutsu , if that makes sense