[ImNoOne] The One Who Knows Everything! (Logic + Manga Evidence)

ImNoOne

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Nov 30, 2011
Messages
1,972
Reaction score
252
After my last thread I was asked to analyse a bunch of topics, some more interesting and some less, some harder and others that weren't worth the effort. One in particular though, was interesting enough and I believe I can cast some light into one of the unknowns that most people are entertaining their minds with.. While doing so uncovering some potential reviling plot developments.

This theory is based on storyline analysis and some manga evidence that the community has yet to properly analyse. The theory is quite extensive as I needed to establish some points that needed back up by manga. So please bare with me, I think it's worth while reading.

First we need to answer the most important question on this issue. Are Sasuke and Orochimaru going to meet/interrogate someone? What does Sasuke want?
You must be registered for see images

Hmmm so he wants to know every thing, every bit of information and he wants to interpret it for himself, not from others point of view but from his own and only his.

Who holds these answers? Who knows the truth about the Uchiha Clan, Itachi and the village of Konoha?
The manga has already given us this information, Chapter 397 it's called "The One Who Knows the Truth". It's Tobi although by this time in the story line he went by Uchiha Madara. It's obvious they know the truth. At least Madara was an active part on most it and where he wasn't Obito had an hand, especially concerning Itachi's fate. What Obito didn't presence himself he presence it from Madara. But... Obito and Madara are obviously not going to tell him at least not the truth, they have nothing to gain from it.

So we may ask the question differently. How do they (Obito and Madara) know all that they do? How do you keep record of all that is going on if you can't go out and witness it for yourself. Madara has been attached for some time to the Gedo Mazo before he met Obito and how did he knew Obito was there to be found any way?

The answer is the same as how did Obito learn all there is about Madara, the Uchiha Clan, the Senju and Uchiha duality, the Sage of Six Paths and his Legacy and all of the Sharingan and Rinnegan techniques.

He obtained them through Zetsu.
You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

Not that Madara could have simply imput his will and memories into Obito, yet he did not do so. He also tells Obito that he may use the rest of the Zetsus as his pawn, which implies that the one carrying Madara's memories is not to be put in harms weight. After all in the Shinobi world information is power!

We have also evidence that Zetsu can share memories with others. Actually sharing the images meaning you will see what the Zetsu saw.
You must be registered for see images

So Zetsu can store memories and share them. Unaltered, untethered, unbiased, pure. Exactly what Sasuke wants right?
We also can infer that for a large part of the story Zetsu has been the source of information to both Madara and later to Obito. It's a large amount of memories, being in so many places gathering so much info and then coming back to the base and share it.

The tree at Madara's Lair, where the Gedou Mazou sits and Hashirama cell's are implanted must have somewhat act like a central storage of information where Madara could review all the data the Zetsus collected.

Now recalling the source of Zetsu, we know that Zetsu is nothing more than a copy of Hashirama made out of Makuton:
You must be registered for see images
Madara used the Gedou Mazou as a catalysis to use Hashirama's powers. Remember that Madara could not use Hashirama's powers himself alone. He has only been able to do this in his Edo Tensei form for the first time.

Madara used the Gedou for two things. He created the Zetsus and run them via the Mazou and he fed himself Hashirama's Life force via the Mazou as well.
You must be registered for see images

Now you must be thinking: "Fair enough, but you haven't said nothing new yet + you yourself established that neither Madara nor Obito will tell anything to Sasuke and there is nothing Orochimaru can do about that. Not to mention that No one apart from Obito and Madara know this treat of the Zetsus... So what's your point?!"

That's true! Or.... is it?

That's the second part of my theory;

Orochimaru told Sasuke that they were heading some place that Sasuke knows very well. My question to you is the following, where did Sasuke sit his fat ass for almost 6 months last year? That's right Madara's Lair. What is there? The Tree, with Hashirama and Yamato and all those plugs for the Zetsus.

And you say: "But Orochimaru doesn't know about all that info! Does he?.."

He does, and as of now so does Suigetsu, Juugo and Sasuke. The scroll speaks of said property and how to retrieve that information from the tree.

How?!

Orochimaru has researched and obsessed on Hashirama's DNA and Mokuton for the larger part of his life. He got expelled from the Leaf in part because of that:
You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

And the extent of his research and practical applications far exceed what one might have thought at first. Long before he was caught by Hiruzen he had already made this far:
You must be registered for see images
Note how a young but twisted Orochimaru is standing beside a younger Danzo that already has the bandages around his right arm. Shisui's eye might have been added later on but I believe Orochimaru had given his "gifts" to Danzo long ago when Danzo trade his normal sharingan for Shisui's eye.

So through years of research and experiment with Hashirama's cells; from DNA transplants and toying with sharingans (hint to a very old knowladge of what Madara tried to do) to completely making Hashirama clones without the catalysis of Gedou Mazou Orochimaru must have come to know of this property of Mokuton, it can store and share memories.

Obito understood this possibility here:
You must be registered for see images
And the both the perception of that threat and the confirmation on how far Orochimaru's knowladge on this isseu went is patent here:
You must be registered for see images
Obito immediately denies Kabuto access to the Zetsus, he fears Orochimaru knows about the Zetsus ability to store and share memories and he has no wishes to further promote Kabuto's knowledge on the truth.

And you say: "Wait a minute!!! You are assuming to much! That would mean that Orochimaru knew about Madara's Lair, the Mazou and the existence of Zetsus long ago, and where all that is!!"

But the truth is he does! He has seen Zetsu before, when he was a member of Akatsuki or even maybe before that. That might have been the reason he joined Akatsuki for all we know!

(Please don't forget that he did not join the Akatsuki because of Itachi, that is a misconception. Before Itachi joined Akatsuki Orochimaru used to team up with Sasori. It was when Itachi joined that Orochimaru teamed up with Itachi in order to attain his body.)

Orochimaru also knows where Madara's Lair is he had to the proof is double here:
You must be registered for see images

There is a double problem here for Obito, not only has Kabuto present him with all that is needed to prove he is not Madara he also presents the proof that he has known who Obito is, where Madara died and that he/Orochimaru have been there before. That's the shock.

Conclusion, this is only a theory. A reading of the story line and I'm not claiming it to be a dogma nor even the only interpretation. It is however, the most plausible scenario that connects these points: What Sasuke sicks, Orochimaru and the info Suigetsu found.

Hope it was worth reading. What do you think?
 

Joten Uchiha

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Jul 19, 2012
Messages
1,971
Reaction score
164
*Didn't read* Lool nah i'm not an a**hole, let me give it a flick through..
 

DeadManWonderLand

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Jul 2, 2012
Messages
7,167
Reaction score
712
After my last thread I was asked to analyse a bunch of topics, some more interesting and some less, some harder and others that weren't worth the effort. One in particular though, was interesting enough and I believe I can cast some light into one of the unknowns that most people are entertaining their minds with.. While doing so uncovering some potential reviling plot developments.

This theory is based on storyline analysis and some manga evidence that the community has yet to properly analyse. The theory is quite extensive as I needed to establish some points that needed back up by manga. So please bare with me, I think it's worth while reading.

First we need to answer the most important question on this issue. Are Sasuke and Orochimaru going to meet/interrogate someone? What does Sasuke want?
You must be registered for see images

Hmmm so he wants to know every thing, every bit of information and he wants to interpret it for himself, not from others point of view but from his own and only his.

Who holds these answers? Who knows the truth about the Uchiha Clan, Itachi and the village of Konoha?
The manga has already given us this information, Chapter 397 it's called "The One Who Knows the Truth". It's Tobi although by this time in the story line he went by Uchiha Madara. It's obvious they know the truth. At least Madara was an active part on most it and where he wasn't Obito had an hand, especially concerning Itachi's fate. What Obito didn't presence himself he presence it from Madara. But... Obito and Madara are obviously not going to tell him at least not the truth, they have nothing to gain from it.

So we may ask the question differently. How do they (Obito and Madara) know all that they do? How do you keep record of all that is going on if you can't go out and witness it for yourself. Madara has been attached for some time to the Gedo Mazo before he met Obito and how did he knew Obito was there to be found any way?

The answer is the same as how did Obito learn all there is about Madara, the Uchiha Clan, the Senju and Uchiha duality, the Sage of Six Paths and his Legacy and all of the Sharingan and Rinnegan techniques.

He obtained them through Zetsu.
You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

Not that Madara could have simply imput his will and memories into Obito, yet he did not do so. He also tells Obito that he may use the rest of the Zetsus as his pawn, which implies that the one carrying Madara's memories is not to be put in harms weight. After all in the Shinobi world information is power!

We have also evidence that Zetsu can share memories with others. Actually sharing the images meaning you will see what the Zetsu saw.
You must be registered for see images

So Zetsu can store memories and share them. Unaltered, untethered, unbiased, pure. Exactly what Sasuke wants right?
We also can infer that for a large part of the story Zetsu has been the source of information to both Madara and later to Obito. It's a large amount of memories, being in so many places gathering so much info and then coming back to the base and share it.

The tree at Madara's Lair, where the Gedou Mazou sits and Hashirama cell's are implanted must have somewhat act like a central storage of information where Madara could review all the data the Zetsus collected.

Now recalling the source of Zetsu, we know that Zetsu is nothing more than a copy of Hashirama made out of Makuton:
You must be registered for see images
Madara used the Gedou Mazou as a catalysis to use Hashirama's powers. Remember that Madara could not use Hashirama's powers himself alone. He has only been able to do this in his Edo Tensei form for the first time.

Madara used the Gedou for two things. He created the Zetsus and run them via the Mazou and he fed himself Hashirama's Life force via the Mazou as well.
You must be registered for see images

Now you must be thinking: "Fair enough, but you haven't said nothing new yet + you yourself established that neither Madara nor Obito will tell anything to Sasuke and there is nothing Orochimaru can do about that. Not to mention that No one apart from Obito and Madara know this treat of the Zetsus... So what's your point?!"

That's true! Or.... is it?

That's the second part of my theory;

Orochimaru told Sasuke that they were heading some place that Sasuke knows very well. My question to you is the following, where did Sasuke sit his fat ass for almost 6 months last year? That's right Madara's Lair. What is there? The Tree, with Hashirama and Yamato and all those plugs for the Zetsus.

And you say: "But Orochimaru doesn't know about all that info! Does he?.."

He does, and as of now so does Suigetsu, Juugo and Sasuke. The scroll speaks of said property and how to retrieve that information from the tree.

How?!

Orochimaru has researched and obsessed on Hashirama's DNA and Mokuton for the larger part of his life. He got expelled from the Leaf in part because of that:
You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

And the extent of his research and practical applications far exceed what one might have thought at first. Long before he was caught by Hiruzen he had already made this far:
You must be registered for see images
Note how a young but twisted Orochimaru is standing beside a younger Danzo that already has the bandages around his right arm. Shisui's eye might have been added later on but I believe Orochimaru had given his "gifts" to Danzo long ago when Danzo trade his normal sharingan for Shisui's eye.

So through years of research and experiment with Hashirama's cells; from DNA transplants and toying with sharingans (hint to a very old knowladge of what Madara tried to do) to completely making Hashirama clones without the catalysis of Gedou Mazou Orochimaru must have come to know of this property of Mokuton, it can store and share memories.

Obito understood this possibility here:
You must be registered for see images
And the both the perception of that threat and the confirmation on how far Orochimaru's knowladge on this isseu went is patent here:
You must be registered for see images
Obito immediately denies Kabuto access to the Zetsus, he fears Orochimaru knows about the Zetsus ability to store and share memories and he has no wishes to further promote Kabuto's knowledge on the truth.

And you say: "Wait a minute!!! You are assuming to much! That would mean that Orochimaru knew about Madara's Lair, the Mazou and the existence of Zetsus long ago, and where all that is!!"

But the truth is he does! He has seen Zetsu before, when he was a member of Akatsuki or even maybe before that. That might have been the reason he joined Akatsuki for all we know!

(Please don't forget that he did not join the Akatsuki because of Itachi, that is a misconception. Before Itachi joined Akatsuki Orochimaru used to team up with Sasori. It was when Itachi joined that Orochimaru teamed up with Itachi in order to attain his body.)

Orochimaru also knows where Madara's Lair is he had to the proof is double here:
You must be registered for see images

There is a double problem here for Obito, not only has Kabuto present him with all that is needed to prove he is not Madara he also presents the proof that he has known who Obito is, where Madara died and that he/Orochimaru have been there before. That's the shock.

Conclusion, this is only a theory. A reading of the story line and I'm not claiming it to be a dogma nor even the only interpretation. It is however, the most plausible scenario that connects these points: What Sasuke sicks, Orochimaru and the info Suigetsu found.

Hope it was worth reading. What do you think?



Logical and sound my only gripe with this is oro wants nothing do to with the war and my theory points to oro having to get something out of the journey as well since taking sasuke wherever he wants just because seems far fetched.

Here is my theory

 

FlareBlitz

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Veteran
Joined
Oct 27, 2011
Messages
2,408
Reaction score
167
I read most lol and you do have alot of proof and I agree but if it turns out to not be madara tobi or zetsu. It will probably be hashi. Seeing as technically they are all connected.in some way
 

Meowazziel

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Aug 2, 2012
Messages
4,852
Reaction score
463
So the one who knows everything is zetsu and ''them'' could be the zetsus black and white or zetsus in general?
However the original white one has been killed and the black one doesnt look to be in such a good condition either (slashed by Chojuro). Sasuke even has casted genjutsu on a white zetsu to get info about the war (before he ran into Itachi). Damm that hurts lol. He could have asked his questions to that white zetsu back than, could he not?

To interrogate zetsu, there must be some of them left though.
The gedo isnt there anymore at least to create more zetsus.

The black one knew more than the white one though.
Can the white one answer questions like, what is a village and such?
Zetsu's have been getting some of their info through Madara and through spying.
White zetsu does not possess Hashi's knowledge, if i am not mistaken, so its 1 side of the story. Info from madara, being around obito and spying.

I am still not certain though.
Deadmanwonderland's theory about the death god being a Yurei and the place where Yurei live (shikkotsurin) sounds pretty solid as well. He linked it in your thread I see.

Thanks + like (would rep, but cant).
 
Last edited:

ImNoOne

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Nov 30, 2011
Messages
1,972
Reaction score
252
Logical and sound my only gripe with this is oro wants nothing do to with the war and my theory points to oro having to get something out of the journey as well since taking sasuke wherever he wants just because seems far fetched.

Here is my theory


I believe Oro is binding his time and doesn't want Sasuke wondering around on his own. He must be waiting for an opportunity to stoke, plus we have to remind ourselves that Oro is always knowledge thirsty. He might be curios about what all Sasuke do when he learns the truth.


So the one who knows everything is zetsu and ''them'' could be the zetsus black and white or zetsus in general?
However the original white one has been killed and the black one doesnt look to be in such a good condition either (slashed by Chojuro). Sasuke even has casted genjutsu on a white zetsu to get info about the war (before he ran into Itachi). Damm that hurts lol. He could have asked his questions to that white zetsu back than, could he not?

To interrogate zetsu, there must be some of them left though.
The gedo isnt there anymore at least to create more zetsus.

The black one knew more than the white one though.
Can the white one answer questions like, what is a village and such?
Zetsu's have been getting some of their info through Madara and through spying.
White zetsu does not possess Hashi's knowledge, if i am not mistaken, so its 1 side of the story. Info from madara, being around obito and spying.

I am still not certain though.
Deadmanwonderland's theory about the death god being a Yurei and the place where Yurei live (shikkotsurin) sounds pretty solid as well. He linked it in your thread I see.

Thanks + like (would rep, but cant).

Who they are going to meet is not a Zetsu in particualr nor any random Zetsu neither. It's the tree where Hashirama and Yamato are. The Mazou might not be there but the tree itself shouldn't have gone anywhere.
 
Last edited:

I AM GOD 666

Member
Joined
Dec 12, 2012
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
I want to read but i just dot have the patience. can someone put this all in 2 sentences?
 

Meowazziel

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Aug 2, 2012
Messages
4,852
Reaction score
463
I want to read but i just dot have the patience. can someone put this all in 2 sentences?

The one who knows everything is zetsu and the place where Oro and Team taka are heading is Madara/Obito's base (Sasuke know its well, he has been in there for several months. He had his EMS implant in here). Oro has figured all this out about zetsu, during Oro's time in Akatsuki and that is how the information got on the scroll that Suigetsu found. The tree with Yamato and the Hashi clone is there(including the info).

This sums it up really short more or less.
 
Last edited:

Meowazziel

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Aug 2, 2012
Messages
4,852
Reaction score
463
Who they are going to meet is not a Zetsu in particualr nor any random Zetsu neither. It's the tree where Hashirama and Yamato are. The Mazou might not be there but the tree itself shouldn't have gone anywhere.
But the one who knows everything is zetsu right? However they will gain the information from the tree?
 

chibaku

Member
Joined
Nov 30, 2012
Messages
78
Reaction score
1
zetzu is the one who recorded almost every important fight like sasuke vs itachi...
 

binderr

Member
Joined
Dec 3, 2012
Messages
468
Reaction score
23
I dont understand, madara made the zetsu tree like 80 years ago

how does that tree know everything from the beginning of the ninja world?
 

I AM GOD 666

Member
Joined
Dec 12, 2012
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
The one who knows everything is zetsu and the place where Oro and Team taka are heading is Madara/Obito's base (Sasuke know its well, he has been in there for several months. He had his EMS implant in here). Oro has figured all this out about zetsu, during Oro's time in Akatsuki and that is how the information got on the scroll that Suigetsu found. The tree with Yamato and the Hashi clone is there(including the info).

This sums it up really short more or less.


you make sense but i thought sasuke kiled the black zetsu? why would he help him?
 

Valen

Banned
Veteran
Joined
Oct 6, 2012
Messages
4,087
Reaction score
392
Logical and sound my only gripe with this is oro wants nothing do to with the war and my theory points to oro having to get something out of the journey as well since taking sasuke wherever he wants just because seems far fetched.

Here is my theory


Why do you always quote the whole goddamn thing
 

AnimusOra

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Veteran
Joined
Jul 3, 2008
Messages
2,086
Reaction score
226
Is a good read and I agree with some extent. When you mention the scroll suigetsu showed Sasuke it still does not mean that Orochimaru can be the only one to use it. If what your implying the scroll might be the key to unlocking all of Zetsu's memories?
 

ImNoOne

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Nov 30, 2011
Messages
1,972
Reaction score
252
But the one who knows everything is zetsu right? However they will gain the information from the tree?

Zetsus were created by Madara from Hashirama's DNA via the Tree, which is a catalysis made from the Gedou Mazou.
Madara was linked to the tree at all times in order to keep receiving Hashirama's Life Force. And the Zetsus plugged into the tree as well whenever they were in the Lair.

There were several Zetsus running errands for Madara, and it's only obvious that they all were collecting info for Madara in order to keep him posted of what was going on about in the rest of the world.

I'm supposing that the tree acted like a central for all the information and if the ability to record memories comes from Mokuton there is a good chance it has all been recorded into the tree and Hashirama's body.

I dont understand, madara made the zetsu tree like 80 years ago

how does that tree know everything from the beginning of the ninja world?

It doesn't need to know all from the beginning, Sasuke is interested only in the History of Konoha and the Uchiha's from the time of Madara on. And that all should be recorded either on the tree or on Hashirama's body.

you make sense but i thought sasuke kiled the black zetsu? why would he help him?

That's not accurate. Sasuke didn't kill the Black Zetsu.. but even if he had would make no difference.
 

Zol

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Dec 11, 2012
Messages
1,803
Reaction score
94
Hm...unlike 99% of the pretty stupid theories on this forum, this one could be possible. Them returning to the lair doesn't sound bad at all, that would also give Kishi a chance to bring in Yamato again.
 

ImNoOne

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Nov 30, 2011
Messages
1,972
Reaction score
252
More important it might give Kishi a chance to bring some part of Hashirama back into the picture.
 

Tragic Nous

Member
Joined
Dec 3, 2012
Messages
76
Reaction score
30
The largest fallacious error in this is the unaccountable element of the Jūbi, which symbolizes the world itself. Though an accurate prediction, I advised you to realize you're messing a rather obvious power that is engrossing the very Shinobi world, and will play a dramatic part in Orochimaru's goals.
 
Top