[Discussion] Imagine if Jewelry Bonney had made WB younger..

[Mugiwara kun]

First things first,No warlord can defeat the trio of Marco,Vista, and Jozu except they are hanged upon,I mean Marco and Jozu were taking on Kizaru and Akoiji with So much frightening ease that makes me wonder if we're just overestimating the admirals, They only got owned because they were distracted when WB got injured. Now imagine a prime WB. I do think the marines would have been destroyed

 

[Hexuze]

You must be registered for see images

There you go, that's why I refrain from debates!
If it is a Hypothetical situation, then why do marines get all these defenses, + the schibukai at 100% and shit?
Lets make it on a plain ground with no Pacifista and that marineford fortress. Both sides face each other and fight. The marines would have been Whooped with a prime WB to lead the WB pirates. Because this also lifts the restriction on WB to use his quakes as it wont damage ace anymore + no wall to stop those quakes either.

And I never said anything about ace fighting! WTF?

Bro you are being silly.​

Lol lemme rephrase, I meant that Ace being needed to be rescued. I was assuming that there wasn't an execution for him. Let's ignore that since it's a fight to see who would win. It was pretty late at night when I was posting that >.> Prime WB + his crew would lose by quite a gap.

 

[kageking]

Gol D. Roger would've lost. Prime WB would've lost. Shanks would've lost. People seem to forget that it was WB, his cew, 44 NW Captains with their crews and Luffy's team VS not even the full MARINE forces(not WG. some marines were shown at other bases) and the WB group suffered a CRUSHING defeat. No marine top tier or high tier were beaten.

Also, Old WB and Akainu stalemated each other. The only reason Akainu got hurt was because of a sneak attack for WB but he STILL beat Ivanko, Jinbei and fought all the WB Commanders together(including Marco and Croc) and didn't receive a scratch All that after taking 2 point blank gura punches and didn't lose consciousness. Don't know why people say Akainu was outclassed.

Everyones entitled to have an opinion I guess...but yours is wrong and reject it entirely

 

[Vandenre1ch]

Lol lemme rephrase, I meant that Ace being needed to be rescued. I was assuming that there wasn't an execution for him. Let's ignore that since it's a fight to see who would win. It was pretty late at night when I was posting that >.> Prime WB + his crew would lose by quite a gap.

That guy seems to forget that his is WAR and that only thing changing about the scenario is WB being in his prime. The question is, would WB have defeated the marines if WB was in his prime? The obvious answer is no.

-top tier fights never end quickly. They last for a LONG time. Akainu, Aokiji or Kizaru can hold off WB for a long ass time in a 1v1.

-Akainu EASILY stalemated Old WB. When WB swung a Gura Bisento as hard as he could, Akainu EASILY stopped it with one foot with both hands in his pockets.

-Marco and Jozu aren't top tiers. One distraction is all it took to cost them a fight with an admiral and almost died. WB got hindered but it didn't cost him his fight with Akainu and still had a lot left in the tank. Akainu got distracted but still had alot left in the tank after WB's attacks. Aokiji was distracted twice, got hit twice(Jozu and Marco each) and it didn't do anything to him.

-Garp and Sengoku didn't do anything in the war. They didn't fight WB nor any Commanders.

People assume WB is MUCH stronger than Old WB for some odd reason. Reason for that is:
-He was stabbed. So? Just a superficial wound for a top tier. More superficial than Akainu getting hit by 2 point blank gura punches and still beat Jinbe, Iva and the Commanders.
-He couldn't use CoC. His CoC would've knocked out the fodder with low willpower with a certain range. Key word: willpower. There were plenty of fodder around Luffy who didn't fall to his CoC.
-He couldn't prevent Ace's execution because of his heart so Luffy had to use his CoC. WB......Luffy.....Same outcome with the guards being knocked out.
-He got heart attacks mid fight. And? Heart attacks or no, WB wasn't beating an admiral anytime soon. Akainu woul still stalemate him.