[Discussion] I'm just gonna give this a shot. top 10 strongest one piece characters and why?

tyltyl

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
May 22, 2013
Messages
1,189
Reaction score
69
1. Gol D. Roger- he's the king of the pirates who conquered the grand line enough said.

2. Edward Newgate- Strongest man in the world but mentioned by buggy is the only one (capable) of taking roger on.

3. Monkey D. Dragon- It's not fair since we've seen very little of him. But with hype, popularity, and going one on one with the world government you have to at least be stronger or as strong as an admiral.

4. Yonko/Blackbeard- I'm grouping them together. Their strength is unknown. blackbeard is quite overpowered. and the ones capable of defeating him are the yonko. and the remnants of the whitebeard pirates.

5. Garp- (maybe in his prime)cornered Roger numerous times. almost killed each other numerous times(stated by roger himself) and is a hero to the marines.

6. Sengoku- was a fleet admiral above the likes of Akainu and all the current admirals. and a zoan devil fruit user makes him close to power to garp.

7. Sakazuki (Akainu)- was the main power house in "The war of the best" he's a fleet admiral after all and the strongest of his generation.

8. Rayleigh- though out of his prime he squared off with the likes of Kizaru and was winning. and being right hand man to roger.

9. Borselino (Kizaru)- an admiral that was hardly touched in "the war of the best" and is quite cunning.

10. Kuzan- former admiral and went toe to toe with Akainu.

(number 10 was a bit difficult. Enel is too naive. Mihawk is questionable. Fugitora could have been there. Marco could have been there but was out smarted by kizaru and almost killed effecting him ain the power category. Oh and a side note I'm sorry if I didn't put your favorite characters up higher or even on the list.)

you can make your own it is much recommended
 
Last edited:

roncato

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Oct 26, 2012
Messages
3,932
Reaction score
285
Not sure if Rayleigh is stronger than Mihawk :p
 

Aquarius

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Mar 16, 2012
Messages
1,991
Reaction score
202
Hey i can't see any of the Mugiwaras. Is they really weak or what to you :what:
 

Mephew D Kensei

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Jun 14, 2013
Messages
1,201
Reaction score
62
summit of op: Roger, Shirohige, Garp(primes)
top tier: Shanks, Rayleigh, Mihawk, BB, Dragon, Sengoku
lower top tier: rest of yonko, admirals, Kuzan n Sakazuki, Ben beckman n Enel
 
Last edited:

24 12 11 to troll

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Dec 24, 2011
Messages
11,214
Reaction score
486
Primes:
1. Gol D. Roger
2. Edward Newgate
3. "Gold Lion" Shiki
4. Monkey D. Garp
5. Monkey D. Dragon
6. Silvers Rayleigh
7. Dracule Mihawk
8. "Akegami" Shanks
9. Sengoku
10. Kaidou/Big Mam

Alive and current:
1. Monkey D. Dragon
2. Dracule Mihawk
3. "Akegami" Shanks
4. Kaidou / Big Mam
5. Kaidou / Big Mam
6. Marshall D. Teach
7. Ben Beckmann
8. Sakazuki
9. Kuzan
10. Isshou/Borsalino
 

Olorin

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Aug 30, 2010
Messages
10,754
Reaction score
782
IMO:

Current top 10 I'd say (no gorosei Kong):
1. Dragon
2. Shanks
3. 4. Garp
3. 4. Mihawk
5. 6. BM and Kaido
7. BB
8. 9 Sakazuki and Ben Backman
10. Borsalino or Kuzan

Top Prime:
1. Roger
2. 3. 4. WB/Garp/Dragon
5. 6. Rayleigh/Shanks
7. 8. 9. Mihawk/Shiki/Sengoku
10. BM/Kaido

and than there's

Top-Tier
Borsalino "Kizaru"
Charlotte Linlin "Big Mom"
Dracule Mihawk "Hawk-Eye"
Edward Newgate "Whitebeard"
Issho "Fujitora"
Kaido "of the Beasts"
Kong
Kuzan "Aokoji"
Marshall D. Teach "Blackbeard" (Gura Gura, Post Skip)
Monkey D. Dragon "the Revolutionary"
Monkey D. Garp "Hero of the Marines"
Sakazuki "Akainu"
Sengoku "the Buddha"
Shanks "Red Haired Shanks"
Silvers Rayleigh "Dark King"

Lower Top-Tier
Benn Beckman
Boa Hancock "Pirate Empress"
Donquixote Doflamingo "Heavenly Yaksha"
Marco "the Phoenix"
Marshall D. Teach "Blackbeard" (Gura Gura, Pre skip)

Upper High-Tier
Bartholomew Kuma "the Tyrant"
Don Chinjao "Chinjao the Drill"
Emporio Ivankov "Okama King"
Eustass Kidd "Captain Kidd" (Post Skip)
Ex-Admiral Zephyr (Movie Z)
Jozu "Diamond Jozu"
Magellan
Marshall D. Teach "Blackbeard" (Yami Yami)
Monkey D. Luffy "Straw Hat Luffy" (Post Skip)
Portgas D. Ace "Fire Fist Ace"
Squard "Maelstrom Spider"
Trafalgar Law "Surgeon of Death" (Post Skip)
Vergo "Demon Bamboo Vergo"
Vista "Flower Sword Vista"

High-Tier
Avalo Pizarro
Bartolomeo "the Cannibal"
Basil Hawkins "The Magician"
Catarina Devon
Cavendish "Pirate Prince"
Doc Q
Enel "God"
Franky (inside BF 38, "Iron Pirate Franky Shogun")
Jesus Burgess
Jinbe "Knight of the Sea"
Laffitte
Little Oars Jr.
Momonga
Oars
Onigumo
Pekoms
Roronoa Zoro "the Pirate Hunter" (Post Skip)
Sanji "Black Leg Sanji" (Post Skip)
Sanjuan Wolf
Sentomaru
Shiliew "of the Rain"
Smoker "the White Hunter" (Post Skip)
Van Auger
Vasco Shot
X Drake "Red Flag"
 
Last edited:

Hijey

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Feb 9, 2010
Messages
797
Reaction score
37
All time

  1. Gol D. Roger and Edward Newgate
  2. Monkey D. Garp
  3. Monkey D. Dragon
  4. Dracule Mihawk
  5. Shanks
  6. Silvers Rayleigh
  7. Sengoku
  8. Sakazuki
  9. Kaido
  10. Kuzan

Current

  1. Monkey D. Dragon
  2. Dracule Mihawk
  3. Shanks
  4. Sakazuki
  5. Kaido
  6. Kuzan
  7. Monkey D. Garp
  8. Marshall D. Teach
  9. Kizaru
  10. Big Mom

The ones on both lists I am confident about their placements are Roger/WB at #1 and Sakazuki above Kuzan.
 

Olorin

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Aug 30, 2010
Messages
10,754
Reaction score
782
I have a question for the OP: so you say Rayleigh is out of his prime so you obviously rated him when he was past his prime ... but Roger is dead, how come you rated him during his prime ... it's either current or prime
 

ziggyZ

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Apr 11, 2012
Messages
7,387
Reaction score
593
*All list exclude the Gorosei.


1. Kong/Shanks/Dragon/Mihawk
2. " "
3. " "
4. " "
5. " "
6. Akainu
7. Aokiji/Kaido/BM
8. " "
9. " "
10. Marco/Kizaru/Beckman





1. Roger
2. Garp
3. Garp/WB
4. Shanks/Dragon/Kong/Mihawk/Rayliegh
5. " "
6. " "
7. " "
8. " "
9. Akainu
10. Aokiji/Kaido/BM





1. Luffy
2. Zoro, Sanji, Roger
3. Garp/Coby
4. Garp/Coby/Law/Kidd/Sabo/Drake
5. " "
6. " "
7. " "
8. " "
9. BB/Shanks/Mihawk
10. Shiryuu


 

Dr Strangelove

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Oct 20, 2011
Messages
10,057
Reaction score
608
I kinda agree although I see no Shanks :yeah:

Imo it goes,

1. Roger
2. Newgate
3. Dragon
4. Shanks
5. Teach
6. Sengoku
7. Garp
8. Kaido
9. Rayleigh
10. Shiki (the one that almost took own Marineford)
 

TheHokage

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Jul 10, 2011
Messages
3,014
Reaction score
200
I kinda agree although I see no Shanks :yeah:

Imo it goes,

1. Roger
2. Newgate
3. Dragon
4. Shanks
5. Teach
6. Sengoku
7. Garp
8. Kaido
9. Rayleigh
10. Shiki (the one that almost took own Marineford)

Really You think Sengoku is stronger than both Garp ans Rayleigh?
 

Hexuze

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
May 19, 2011
Messages
20,359
Reaction score
1,533
Current
1. Shanks
2. Kaido
3. Big Mam
4. Akainu/BB
5. Akainu/BB (weaker one from #4 is #5)
6. Benn Beckman or Mihawk
7. Aokiji
8. Kizaru
9. Rayeligh/Garp
10. Sengoku

Actually now that I think of it BB is lower than Akainu cause he clearly fled when he saw his ass but now with a TS I don't think he had mastered his DF/haki to surpass Akainu...yet. I won't give an explanation why I think Shanks is one of the strongest cause it will just start a sh*t storm.
 
Last edited:

LeEvilTongue

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
May 21, 2012
Messages
762
Reaction score
20
Good list! Finally someone who doesn't jerk off to Mihawk
 

TheHokage

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Jul 10, 2011
Messages
3,014
Reaction score
200
Current top 5 for me top 10 is just to hard to decide.

1) Monkey D Dragon
2) Monkey D Garp
3) Shanks
4) Sakazuki
5) Marshall D Teach
 
Top