If obito was successful in sucking Minato...Could Minato escape Obito's dimension?

[TouchMyMangos]

As I explained in my post, Minato doesn't know where he was being sent to, so he could've just been playing it safe. Obito doesn't know the exact physical mechanics of Hiraishin well enough to be able to correctly determine whether Minato could escape boxworld or not.

I mean, for pete's sake, Obito thought chains would be a good method to restrain Minato! I don't think we can really take his judgement into account on this.

There's no concrete evidence either way.
And does Obito know the exact physical mechanics of Minato's jutsu to the point that he could accurately determine whether Minato could escape his dimension or not? I think not.
I mean, he thought chains were a good weapon against Minato, for Christ sake's!
to my knowledge no one with a summoning contract has been warped by Obito. Who knows?

Obito had no way to know about Hiraishin's exact mechanics.
Unless something in the manga shows him having full knowledge on how Hiraishin works exactly and everything it can do, then its impossible to know.What manga canon?
Show manga canon explicitly stating/showing Hiraishin can't be used to escape Kamuiland. There's none, so its not "manga canon". Know the difference.

Why wouldn't Minato be able to escape.
S/t is s/t. Haraishin allows Minato to travel through space & time.
Obito will never be able to defeat Minato. But sadly he has the perfect jutsu to battle him.
Obito isn't a brilliant mind like his sensei or his best friend.
It reminds me of the saying, you can have all the money in he world but without respect and character, it's useless.

Kamui was created through Obito seeing haraishin and having an intense emotional desire for Minato, his sensei to show up and save him when the boulder crushed his entire right side.

why r u copying and pasting arguments?

You must be registered for see links

 

[IIB7252]

This just shows that Minato being wary doesn't mean that he can't teleport back, what makes me believe he can't escape is Obito being 100% sure that if he sucked him in he would have won, Obito knows the basics of the technique (He can teleport of any Kunai marked with the seal) so he should be able to deduce whether or not he can escape from his dimension.

Obito using the chains wasn't a bad move since it is better than bringing no weapons, but I guess you could say Obito didn't know whether or not he could escape.

Dear brother please read my post which I made before this one.... whats ur take on that 1

 

[IIB7252]

why r u copying and pasting arguments?

You must be registered for see links

Sorry about that but i agree with those comments thats y

 

[IIB7252]

If some1 has invented the wheel do i need to reinvent it again even after i knowing it...

 

[KidGamer65]

Dear brother please read my post which I made before this one.... whats ur take on that 1

FTG may be S/T but Obito's confidence in his victory against Minato was too high.

As for Kamui's creation..ehh, I don't know about that one.

 

[Blaze Release]

Most likely No. Just upload a previous post

On a more serious note, nobody has a definitive answer therefore we can only speculate. This question is very similar to the question which is that if obito managed to warp minato would minato come back due to hirashin, Tobi however seemed very assured that if he warped him, thats it for minato though you can translate this as overconfidence. He does however know that he is a fellow s/t user.

The way i see kamui, i see it as a barrier technique where only the wielder of the eye can determine who enters or leaves the technique. Infact i believe kamui is very similar to jiraiya's Kekkai Gama Hyoro. Both are s/t technique's because that is a summoning. Secondly both take the opponent into a dimension. We know that with jiraiya's its a deminsion, but its more of a barrier technique and the DB states that there is no escape;

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

To put it simple, the wielder of a kamui eye has access to enter/leave the dimension as they please;

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

"The same eye, as expected you came back"

I believe apart from the fact that kamui is a dimension, its also a barrier technique where only those with the eye have access to. Therefore anything that is trapped there cannot be accessed even with another s/t ability. Therefore this solves your question along with the question that is if tobi warped minato could he come back with hirashin and the answer is no because its a barrier technique aswell

You can say any place/dimension that doesn't exist in real life might test hirashin.

 

[Izuna Kakashi Senju]

Can't be answered yet. But probably.

 

[Shodaime Swagkage]

Blaze Release already helped me on this. read his response in my thread.

You must be registered for see links

 

[Uchihajin Sasuke]

I'd say no. Even after witnessing Minato's Hiraishin, Obito remained confident that he could indeed trap him in his pocket dimension [

You must be registered for see links

][

You must be registered for see links

]; the way it was portrayed (as a game finisher) in both examples heavily implies that Minato wouldn't have been able to escape. That dimension seems to be exclusive to Obito's eyes and Obito's eyes alone. Does Hiraishin grant Minato inter-dimensional travel? The 'S/T' aspect seems to simply relate to Minato being able to cover large amounts of space/distances in a short amount of time. If Minato could escape with Hiraishin, then anyone could escape via a reverse summoning. That's why it's not possible, for me anyway.

Same here, Minato's technique is a teleportation technique, which is basically high speed movement, while Obito's is a transportation technique, which means he can go trough the barriers and travel through the other dimensions that belong to him.

 

[JIRAIYA perv]

looking at what happened it would make more sense that obito planed it well and considered every possibility, so if obito said that teleporting minato will end the fight then he is probably right (minato can't teleport back from obito's dimension otherwise kishi would have made it happen and let minato come back like it was nothing). the only thing that went wrong in obito's plan is that he underestimated minato (he shouldn't have faced him alone)

short answer : the only way anyone can teleport back from obito's dimension is having obito's eyes (kakashi). and if it was possible for minato to escape then kishi shouldn't have written the fight the way he did, do you get it ?? (think about it, it makes sense) kishi was clear here

 

[Takos]

Obito knew about FTG and still said that teleporting him into his dimension will end the fight. This means that Minato probably cannot travel between the dimensions with FTG.

 

[shogun973]

yes if he had a kunai in the other dimension....
that would be mad fresh if he had kunai in the regular world got sucked in and left some kunai in tobi's dimension then kept going back and forth to get hits

 

[Prime Rib]

minato can get out as long as he has a kunai on the outside or a seal

 

[Sir Blades]

it is very likely

 

[Turson]

Its very unlikely, considering that Obito was sure that drawing Minato into his dimension would end the fight.

 

[mas129]

I used to think he couldn't because I assumed that when Tobi sucks you (that's what she said), the person is put in a genjutsu but when he did this with Kakashi, he just ended up beating him up inside his dimension.

 

[BloodSeed]

obitos kamui sucks

 

[NarutoFan20]

At the time of their battle it was unclear exactly how Tobi's jutsu worked.
Indeed, it was assumed if Tobi succeeded in sucking someone up, he would automatically win.

Now we have more information about the dimension he deposits you
It has no special properties in terms of genjutsu or anything else to prevent someone like Minato - with ST ninjutsu - from simply teleporting out again.

Thoughts?

Yes Minato can escape from Obito's dimension if obito successfully sucked him in. Minato has FTG kunai's in a lot of places.

 

[Legendary Broly]

Hmm idk, its in a complete different place :shrug:
Can people summon objects there ?
if not then I don't think he could if there was no ability to have contact with teh outside world, only through kakashi or tobi

 

[zinescience]

minato will be able to teleport back.