If Itachi was a villain?

Korowa

Active member
Regular
Joined
Mar 12, 2014
Messages
787
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
i rarely need to. the manga already showed us this when itachi savagely and horrifically tortured a 6 year old screaming innocent boy to madness.

which he didnt given good guys don't brutally torture innocent children for 3 days.

yes he would. this is a horrible and evil thing to do to people.
lying to the entire world and tricking them into thinking sasuke is something hes not? yeah pretty bad.
sasuke isnt a hero just because he killed off a villain. he would be shitted on and imprisoned the moment he stepped back inside konoha, or elseways enslaved by koto amatsukami the moment he met up with naruto again.
the clan wasnt avenged and itachi was never killed. he just dropped dead of his disease therefor sasukes life was a complete waste of time. but he'll never realise that because of said enslavement.




so....exactly as he is in the actual manga?

he wouldnt get past the uchiha coup. since if hes really just an ax crazy blood hungry mass murdering crazy insane nutjob then he wouldnt have stopped with his clan. he would have kept going till someone managed to stop him so all that bullshit wouldnt happen. that would take sanity to do. and manga itachi is sane, evne if hes a ruthless murderous torturer.

lol wank. obito and shisui do

he'd be exactly as he already is

your just describing things that an evil person could do. itachi is still evil even without doing all the shit your suggesting.
stealing sasukes sharingan has no purpose when his purpose is to brainwash and enslave sasuke and ensure konoha is a dictatorship that rules through fear. what your talking about is trading that dogmatic fanaticism for selfish power gathering. but BOTH ARE EVIL.
and you completely missed how EMS works. a 3 tomoe sharingan doesnt give you EMS. it has to be another MS.

not trying to kill someone doesnt mean behaving like a moron and holding back 90% of your powers. itachi was serious and fighting hard, he just wasnt aiming for kabutos vitals.
forgetting his own powers is just part of that. had it gone on longer he would have used those things.


he would be dead anyway. itachi ordered sasuke ot murder his friend. and if not for last minute kyuubi regeneration, sasuke would have succeeded. so i doubt kisame and itachi could have taken naruto at all. kyuubi would not allow this. he would go 1 tailed and hold them off long enough for jiraiya to join in. if itachi really had no intention of ever taking naruto he would have separated jiraiya from him. he would have been like "well cant beat him, so lets go home kisame".

again you can thank sasukes mercy for that.not itachi.


why? his goal in the manga was having konoha rule everyone and he was far too weak to achieve that alone. everything he did was geared towards his own beliefs of konoha superiority, and enslaving his brother against his will.
doesnt make him good, just having a different goal in mind to what your suggesting he would do.
or do exactly what he ended up doing and kill himself so he could enslave sasuke and ensure konoha's military power continues

no he doesnt. in fact hes one of the dumbest and most braindead characters and completely misunderstands human nature and the nature of his village.

he is evil, very much so, and he has no need to take over the world when his plans are supporting danzo whos goal is do so. so yeah itachis an accomplice in danzo's plans and nothing more.

well since he was never good, i think we've seen the best he has to offer

not doing so is more evil lol.danzo was a psychopath. itachi in canon is danzo's yes man loyalist buttslave and accomplice in danzo's plans to have konoha military superiority and rule through fear and brainwashing. doesnt make him any less evil for it.

itachi advantages
- immortality and unlimited chakra.
- yata and totsuka.
- could beat kabuto to near death or otherwise hurt him badly.
- could use his full defensive power quite easily. not doing so is just character stupidity.
- sasuke being there.every time itachi got buttfuked he was buttfuked because he was being a cocky moron and not paying attention and not realising sasuke could take care of himself, forcing sasuke to enter into it and save his ass from being overwritten. sauske not being there = utter defeat within 2 chapters.
- endless hax options including tsukuyomi and amaterasu. compare that to kabutos comparatively weak abilities offensively. which is where ET is so handy.

kabuto disadvantages
- FREAKING 2 VS 1! actually make that 40 000 vs 2.
- no edo tenseis. he was busy with the whole army that was outside.
- no killing intent. itachi cant die and sasuke wasnt going to be hurt or injured.
- cockiness and unwillingness to spam his stronger jutsus in favour of busting out new ones to show off.
- lack of defensive power to handle the uchiha firepower which is where edos come in.
- no manda 2. if uchihas broke the cave ceiling i guess he would have used him

The Tsukiyomi was done on 8 year old Sasuke. He wasn't 6 lmao. It was 48 hours not 72 hours. Uchiha get stronger through hatred and Sasuke directed his hatred towards Itachi from that moment on, thus sparing Konoha. He even awakened his sharingan that day. Uchiha massacre was inevitable, years of problems were leading up to it all staring w/ Madara & Tobirama. Itachi saved Konoha whether you like it or not and regardless of whether Itachi killed the clan or not, they were dying either way. Manga fact

Itachi's plan made perfect sense and was executed nearly flawlessly before Obito came into the picture. But Itachi's plan even now still has a chance to work through Nardo's influence.

No Obito and Shisui don't have the best MS. There's no such thing as having the best MS, they have different abilities. Shisui's just had the most potent genjutsu KA

Danzo was Itachi's b**** considering he didn't hurt Sasuke at any point that Itachi was alive and even felt fear upon seeing Itachi in Sasuke's genjutsu or even hearing Itachi's name.

Tsukiyomi wouldn't do jack in the fight against Kabuto considering he sealed off his vision. Itachi didn't forget any of his techs, considering that he wasn't brought back at his fullest as an edo. He was never in possession of Yata Mirror. Kabuto was free to go all out considering Itachi was edo, whereas Itachi couldn't kill Kabuto. Kabuto had literally no disadvantages in that fight and Sasuke was Itachi's burden. Everytime Itachi was in a fix and Sasuke saved him was due to Itachi having to save Sasuke just moments before that. Edos don't have unlimited chakra lmao. Nagato had to suck chakra from Bee and Minato even stated he ran out and couldn't save his son from the tree that was attacking the ninja alliance.

/thread
 

USSJ Future Trunks

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Nov 15, 2011
Messages
18,518
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Apparently you really don't read the same manga. Sasuke was an 8 year old.
apparently you think that changes anything. fine he tortured an 8 year old. give that man a medal\
It was 48 hours not 72 hours
again doesnt change anything. its still horrific and evil
. Uchiha get stronger through hatred
so itachi knew full well what he was doing was creating a second madara and he...does it anyway. yes your right uchiahs get stronger if they hate. they also hate when they hate. and hate leads to vicious acts like murder and destruction. itachi visited destruction on everyone.
Sasuke directed his hatred towards Itachi from that moment on, thus sparing Konoha.
the only reason he'd target konoha is if they gave him a reason to or if itachi told him the actual truth. doesnt mean he cant spin another story, one that spares sauske hate towards ANYONE and leaves him free to choose his own path. but itachi cant have that! lets torture the kid into a life of misery hate and suffering! of course! great plan!
. Uchiha massacre was inevitable
no it wasnt. it was easily avoidable
a. Itachi saved Konoha
and then helped destroy it when he did nothing to even slow down pain and helped him gather the necessary bijuus.
also no he saved nothing because he wasnt ****ing needed. if he did nothing then danzo would have picked up the slack. only difference is sasuke wouldnt get away. but thats totally worth forcing your parents to know it was their son who murdered them and for sasuke to see his beloved brother killing everyone over and over for 24 hours which drives him insane.
nd regardless of whether Itachi killed the clan or not, they were dying either way. Manga fact
um no it isnt. its just manga theories from some of the characters.
shisuis plan was going to save everyone and spare any bloodshed. but oh no itachis totally the hero, not him!
Itachi's plan made perfect sense a
no it iddnt. it was absurd and could fall apart at the slightest misstep and was dependent on way too many conviences and coincidences. it made zero sense, was stupid, braindead and failed miserably in every possible way.
was executed nearly flawlessly before Obito came into the picture.
no it wasnt. it had already met with failure and disaster the moment sasuke got tortured and told to murder his friends. then the dominoes fell and ended in sasuke losing his mind completely.
But Itachi's plan even now still has a chance to work through Nardo's influence.
itachis plan was to apparently protect sasuke and konoha. konoha has been wiped out for the most part with only a few hundred ninjas left, sasuke is still mentally broken and a murderer. whatever redemption sasuke seeks now doesnt mean itachi was responsible given he was the one who sent sasuke into the pit of darkness in the first fukin place.

Danzo was Itachi's b**** considering he didn't hurt Sasuke at any point that Itachi was alive
danzo had no reason to, till itachi tortured sasuke into madness and forced him to desert the village for power. then danzo concocted a plan, based on his knowledge of oroochimaru, to stop him getting sharingan. itachi could go fuk himself for all he cared.
even felt fear upon seeing Itachi in Sasuke's genjutsu or even hearing Itachi's name.
if someone you know to be dead suddenly teleported behind you, you wouldnt be a little bit scared of sasukes seeming necromancy powers?
Itachi didn't forget any of his techs, considering that he wasn't brought back at his fullest as an edo.
yes he did. he forgot he could use amaterasu to incapacitate kabuto and then turn it off when hes almost dead.
. He was never in possession of Yata Mirror
so he magically got edo'd with totsuka but not the other one? thats a fallacy which you made up
Kabuto was free to go all out
he was outnumbered, lost his strongest puppets, was distracted by the war outside and swore he wouldnt hurt sasuke, nor did he. he also cant damage itachi too badly or else he cant rewrite him
Kabuto had literally no disadvantages in that fight
this is a bullshit lie and you know it. how is he not at a disadvantage when he lacks the entire army he started the war with? when it wasnt 1 vs 1? and when he was facing an immortal invincible ulimited chakra monster?
Sasuke was Itachi's burden
other way around. sasuke was having to stop his attacks and save itachi whenever itachi got himself slashed up.
was due to Itachi having to save Sasuke just moments before that.
this was never the case at all. when your in a debate you cant lie like that. it makes you look very stupid.
first time itachi took a hit
- white rage. he couldnt do shit about it and only resisted because of his immortal ash body
second time
-impaled on rocks. kabuto CLAIMED that itachi got slower due to moving his susano to sasuke but sasuke was never in any danger as kabuto points out. so itachi doing that was his own fukin stipidity and underestimation of his teammate. sasuke is fine. hes reacted to and blocked stronger things.
- the genjutsu. now this i admit is the only time where itachi took a hit AND saved sasuke. but you got the order reversed. he took the hit then freed sasuke after he did, and sasuke saved him too by being there
- fourth time itachi took a hit. he was cut in half, because he stupidly let down his susano while kabuto was villain ranting, allowing for kabuto to blitz him.

and if the argument is that izanami started way before that, then all the hits never took place and thus sasuke was never a "burden"
Nagato had to suck chakra from Bee
to defeat bee, not power himself up lol
 

Conspirator.

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Mar 10, 2014
Messages
19,435
Kin
124💸
Kumi
6💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
@ussj future trunks
I always wandered why danzo didn't allow shisui's plan to occur. It was actually a peaceful, foolproof solution to the whole uchiha/konoha mess.(although, I don't the blame the uchiha. Konoha was corrupt under danzo.)
 

Chie

Active member
Elite
Joined
Mar 10, 2014
Messages
8,333
Kin
5💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
@ussj future trunks
I always wandered why danzo didn't allow shisui's plan to occur. It was actually a peaceful, foolproof solution to the whole uchiha/konoha mess.(although, I don't the blame the uchiha. Konoha was corrupt under danzo.)
Danzo said that he didn't trust Shisui and was paranoid. Shisui's KA was the only solution to the problem but once it failed due to Danzo's influence the massacre became inevitable. I think that it's both Tobirama's and Madara's fault, the fall-out they had resulted in years of tension. And Danzo's obviously as well as Hiruzen's for being such a push-over. The Uchiha is also at fault though, they should have talked it out with Hiruzen, I doubt he would turn them down if he asked for more political power. Not really possible to blame just one side. I don't blame Shisui and Itachi because by the time the mess came to them, there really wasn't anything that they could do to fix it at that point and the massacre had become inevitable.
 
Top