- Joined
- Dec 4, 2012
- Messages
- 4,660
- Reaction score
- 452
Madara+Rinnegan or Hashi are the only two that can beat him IMO
1.That's your way of looking at it. Ma and Pa are used to help stabilize the Nature Chakra because Jiraiya can't do it on his own. How do you know that he simply didn't want to bring them into the battlefield before he entered SM first? It would make no sense to bring them in before he entered SM. Also it's possible that they simply can't fuse with someone unless they are in SM first. In fact that makes more sense than saying you need a contract as well as SM to summon them. I wont say your claim is baseless but it's very narrow minded and a bit of a stretch
2.Itachi is just as fast? Say who? Minato was on the other side of a room when Obito was about to kill Naruto with a kunai from point blank range and Minato still managed to save him. Itachi has never shown speed that equals that feat. Also you forget that Minato has a vast amount of kunai pre-equipped with the seals and he can place the seal on any surface. If he uses his multiple kunai+ground seals+Body flickr to decrease the distance of Itachi, Itachi is not going to be able to match kunai for kunai with him, as well as keep track of all ground seals and avoid Minato's base speed. Also, Minato still has the ability to teleport with his kunai, while Itachi doesn't, all Minato needs is for a Kunai to get close, he doesn't need it to strike. Itachi will need to use Susanoo.
3.As far as the hand seal argument, Minato doesn't need to form hand seals to place his FTG seals:
Right here you see him placing a seal immediately after using Rasengan with the same hand. It takes him little to no time to do this. You are underestimating Minato's hand seal speed.You must be registered for see images
4.You haven't seen what Minato can do with taijutsu, so saying Itachi has the better feats is speculation. We know Itacih is excellent in Taijutsu, but we haven't heard or seen anything that suggest Minato is somehow inferior to him. Also, fighting Minato in hand-to-hand combat is crazy. He can place a seal on you if he manages to touch you. If he manages to block a kick or punch from Itachi with his hand, he can easily place a seal on Itachi and then not even Susanoo can defend him then because Minato can then teleport inside Susanoo. Which we know there's room for more than one person because Sasuke brought Zetsu inside his Susanoo one time
5.Ribcage Susanoo would be stupid to use. It doesn't protect your entire body. Look at this:
Minato can teleport anywhere within the radius of his seal. Notice the seal was on Obito's back but he teleported to the front of him. If he throws multiple kunai at Itachi and one gets close, or worse if Itachi trys to avoid and gets caught near one of those ground seals, Minato can teleport to the exact spot where Itachi is open to attack. Again Itachi needs full Susanoo to defend against that speedYou must be registered for see images
6.Large Chakra reserves isn't something you achieve it's something you have. And again there is no evidence that Minato doesn't have large enough reserves for SM. That doesn't hint that Minato never had SM. The fact that he has a contract with the toads and is a pupil of Jiraiya who proclaimed to be a genius of a decade and stated there was no genius like him since, and who also is Sage, hints that he did learn SM
7.Itachi has nothing that will land a hit on him. Which I have given you a detailed battle strategy with manga evidence to suggest that Minato can indeed defeat Itachi. So I'm going to need for you to come with a little more than all of these un-backed speculations. But I do appreciate the debate though
What is best strategy to beat itachi ?
What is itachi weak point ?
I think he can't solo a taijutsu master since all uchiha members are
Weak against taijutsu .
Gai sensei may have better chance of beating him than any other ninja for many reasons:
- Hyoudara can destroy sasunoo
- itachi simply run away when gai appeared to assist kakashi and other jounin
- genjutsu will never effect gai since he can fight without open his eye
- stamina and speed are gai big advantage
- 8 gates will be real nightmare
Still I am not talking about any ninja but I am talking about most dangerous ninja (itachi).
He soloed nagato in 2 sec .
Amatarsu + totsuko blade = nagato's end
Surely itachi is solo king ..
But I wonder which ninja has chance of beating him and do you think itachi is perfect ninja ?
Although sasuke said it not me..
So what do you think about it?
What is best strategy to beat itachi and what is his weak point ?
1. actually it makes more sense for Jiraiya to summon Ma and Pa first, they have the perfect counter for an invisible enemy, who Jiraiya was struggling with at the moment, and why would he not summon them when he clearly said to Gamaken he was about to summon them? after the contract, you need chakra to summon toads, you need Sage Chakra to summon Sage Toads, which part of it makes less sense than "he didn't want to?". until you prove someone has summoned the Sage Toads without Sage Chakra, your claim is baseless as well as narrow minded and a bit of a stretch.
2. Obito let Minato grab Naruto on purpose so he could separate them from Kushina, that's barely even a speed feat, Itachi had great speed feat since age 13-14 and showed great speed in every battle since then, backed up with a 5/5 speed in the databook, there's no feats showing Minato without FTG any faster than base Itachi, Itachi also has Sharingan which makes it easier to follow Minato's linear movements.
Minato's Kunai requires more space than a normal once, there's no way Minato can carry more Kunai than Itachi can, matching the enemy kunai for kunai is never a problem for Itachi, against anyone, ground seals don't matter, they can't move, it would be a waste of chakra.
3. tagging people isn't hand seal feat, it doesn't require hand seal, but it requires touching people. what makes you think Minato would get the chance to touch Itachi. it's been heavily hinted tagging during battle either require a good amount of chakra or the seal isn't permanent, or both, that's why he had to prepare those kunais with special yellow paper seals on them, instead of jus using normal kunai and tagging them before throwing. Itachi has one of the fastest hand seal speed that gives him huge advantage in close to midrange battles, easily distract opponent with a quick attack in between.
4. that's why I said Itachi has better taijutsu feats, I don't know if Minato is better than Itachi at taijutsu or not, but as for now, Itachi has shown to be the better one, no advantage for Minato there, point made.
5. Ribcage Susanoo protects the entire body, the visible chakra acts as defense, bones acts as support, that's why A had to break the bones to get to Sasuke while attacking with his hand. why would a jutsu with a "gap" tank an attack like Kirin?
Minato can throw all his kunai at Itachi at once, none will get close to Itachi, here's the manga panel proof:
You must be registered for see images
why would a stationary seal marking matter to Itachi, when Minato can't force Itachi to move, and when Itachi moves, he moves as fast as Minato without FTG.
6.sorry buddy no sage mode for Minato. Which I have given you a detailed explaination with manga evidence to suggest that Minato doesn't have Sage Mode. So I'm going to need for you to come with a little more than all of these un-backed speculations. But I do appreciate the debate thoughYou must be registered for see images
7. Itachi lands hit on him the same way he always lands hit on people, by deceiving and then surprise attack while enemy being distracted. I already gave you the reasons why ur battle strategy does not work on Itachi, Kunai countered with better Kunai skills, so no FTG or lvl 2 through Kunai that's gonna concern Itachi, taijutsu countered with better taijutsu, so no FTG through body tagging should concern Itachi, intelligence countered with better intelligence, so no surprise attack or outplanning Itachi. so where's the bad match up for Itachi?
1. By bringing Ma and Pa into the battlefield before he entered SM, he put them in harms way. Again, it's possible that in order for Sage Toads to fuse, you need to be in SM first. Why would he summon them when clearly they wouldn't be of any use until after he entered SM because their purpose is to help stabilize the SM chakra. You saw how his first toad was struggling as is. Ma and Pa would've been in danger just waiting for Jiraiya to gather sage chakra
2. Obito was clearly about to stab Naruto. Saying he let Minato grab him is stupid. Even after the feat, Obito complimented him on being so fast. Why would he do that if his plan was simply just to let Minato grab Naruto in the first place? And your databook reference makes no sense. Itachi having 5/5 speed does not mean he's as fast as Minato. The databook rankings only go up to level 5, but Minato, who is clearly the fastest ninja in the manga, is only 5/5 too? as is Raikage, who is slower than Minato but faster than Itachi. You are reaching desperately at this point. Itachi has shown no speed feat that matches saving Naruto from an incoming kunai at point blank range. Until you show me that, you have no argument here. And as Lee said, having sharingan doesn't mean anything if you aren't fast enough to counter the movements. And you underestimate how many kunai Minato can carry. He has been shown to take out entire armies with his kunai+FTG combo. And setting the seals don't require chakra, so no it's not a waste. Where are you getting your information? If Minato has seals on the ground as well as the kunai seals, Itachi has too much to watch out for at once. What is to stop Minato from luring Itachi back near a seal that he has placed on the battlefield ground? The more seals he places the less floor space Itachi has. It's simple.
3. It has NEVER been hinted that Minato's seals require chakra to set. You are now beginning to make totally baseless claims just because you have no real manga evidence to back any of this up. You were the one that tried to bring up Itachi's taijutsu feats. And I'm saying that it would be foolish to battle someone who can place something as dangerous as a FTG seal on you in a taijutsu battle. One counter from Minato could lead to contact that would spell demise for Itachi. You brought up taijutsu not me. I'm just simply showing you the foolishness of that approach. And no attack Itachi has is going to be a match for Minato's reflexes and speed. He's the fastest character in the manga with the best reaction timing. On top of that, he's a genius just like Minato. In fact, Jiraiya praised him and said there was no genius like him since, which would include Itachi since Itachi is younger. You underestimate Minato's intelligence. You aren't just going to catch him with a distraction.
4. Like I said before, it would stupid to fight Minato in a taijutsu battle. Hand to hand combat with him is asking to be tagged with FTG seal which I proved can be done instantly. point made. Minato has the advantage clearly when it comes to a taijutsu battle
5. It was the angle at which Raikage was attacking. He was trying to break directly through Susanoo, ofcorse that's not going to work. Even if ribcage susanoo is enough to protect him, that still doesn't change the fact that all Minato would have to do then is focus his attention on the ribcages or the chakra surrounding Itachi rather than look at Itachi's body. To use Susanoo means to give his opponent something to look at besides himself, which means they are avoiding his visual genjutsu.
And your picture further proves my point. Notice there are shuriken that are near Itachi. There are also shuriken that are directly between him and Sasuke. This proves that Itachi isn't fast enough to keep all of them away from him at that distance. Because if he were then most of the kunai would be near Sasuke, and there wouldn't be any near Itachi since Itachi. But the fact that there is a trail of them leading directly from Sasuke right on up to Itachi, proves that some of Sasuke's shuriken managed to get close and Itachi blocked it only a short distance away from his body. Otherwise those shuriken right by his body would end up hitting him, but since they didn't we know they were blocking Sasuke's, which also had to be close to him. The thing you are failing to realize (or you just don't want to admit) is that Minato can TELEPORT to his marked kunai, thus the closer his kunai get, he can then teleport himself and shorten the distance between him and Itachi. If he does that, he can then start to throw more kunai from an even shorter distance, making it even harder for Itachi to keep all of them soundly getting to close. You can even see on your pic that there is an impact bubble that shows where the kunai hit one another. It's only a few inches away from Itachi. If Minato teleports to that spot and starts throwing more, Itachi wont have the time to match him with kunai, he'll have to move. Like I said, Itachi can't match Minato kunai for kunai, because Minato has the edge since he teleports to his. Thank you for posting that page and proving me right.
6. Are you really that dense? You do realize at this time that Minato was still a taboo subject and people rarely brought up that subject to him right? He didn't know Minato was his dad yet. So how do you know Pa wasn't doing what everyone else has done the entire manga before that and just avoid the subject with Naruto? Also it doesn't matter if he has SM, because my point is that he can summon Ma and Pa to do that Paralysis genjutsu on Itachi. Which you have not proven that he can't, so stop trying to focus avoid the direct issue
7. Again, you are not just going to surprise Minato. I already gave you reasons why your arguments lack base. You proved with your own pic that Itachi can't keep the kunai away from him. He can block them yes, but he can't stop them from getting close to him, and since Minato can teleport each time he throws one and shorten the distance, it's impossible to use this method against him and expect to win, so no he doesn't have better kunai skills. Minato can tag you with a seal instantly, so taijutsu is a stupid way to fight him, so no Itachi doesn't have better taijutsu either. Jiraiya said no genius like Minato since Minato was born, so your better intelligence argument tanks according to the manga. The bad match up is clear. I'm sorry but you are letting your fanboysim get the better of you.
1. why does Jiraiya has to fuse with them to summon them? why can't Ma and Pa help Jiraiya the same way they were helping out Naruto? Ma and Pa has Toad Sage Strength, multiple elemental jutsu and perfect way to counter an invisible summoning, how is that not n any use? and to prove your false claim:
You must be registered for see images
2. if Obito didn't plan to let Minato grab Naruto, why would he put the explosive tags on Naruto? and how else do you think Obito was planning to seperate Minato from Kushina? who said Itachi has 5/5 speed has anything to do with Minato? it means he's fast, it's Minato who needs proof that his base speed is as fast as Itachi's, since he barely has any legit speed feats. saving a baby which Obito planned for him to, is not an impressive speed feat, he only jumped the distance of a room, while Itachi has jumped greater distance than that many times in battle against Kurenai, Killer Bee and Naruto. Lee's statement only holds true when the Sharingan user is a lot slower than the taijutsu user, while Itachi is just as fast as base Minato, of course Sharingan gives him an advantage. it doesn't matter how many Kunais Minato can carry, Itachi can always carry more, because normal kunais take less space. If Minato has ground seals, Itachi can simply move a little further from it, once there's a distance there no need to watch out for a ground tag, and if Minato doesn't have better taijutsu, offensive ninjutsu nor kunai skills than Itachi, how is he planning to lure Itachi to anywhere? the more seals Minato places on the ground the easier for Itachi to use Amaterasu to get rid of all of the Kunais at once.
3. any jutsu requires chakra, that's common sense, why would Minato's seal not require chakra? how would Minato place a FTG seal on Itachi if he can't beat Itachi in taijutsu? Minato would get a kunai to the throat before he gets the chance to touch Itachi fully and place a seal on him in a taijutsu battle. Itachi's reaction is just as good as Minato, FTG is a fairly simple jutsu to be figured out, Itachi is the master of deceiving people, it's more likely for Itachi to surprise attack Minato than the opposite to happen. You aren't just going to catch Minato with a distraction, but this is a distraction from Itachi we talking about.
4. plz tell me how Minato would get a chance to tag Itachi if Itachi is better at taijutsu, Killer Bee with 7 swords can't even touch Itachi, how would Minato get to do it?
5. I did not even bring up Itachi's genjutsu yet, let's not go there, if Minato can't gain upper hand on Itachi without bringing genjutsu in the convo, then Minato getting caught with a genjutsu is just a matter of time, Minato has made eye contact with a MS user many times in the manga.
first of all how do you know those shiruken near Itachi aren't his own reflected back, 2nd of all Minato doesn't have the luxury to summon Kunai from his wrist like Sasuke does, making him throwing kunais a lot slower and less in number, 3rd what's the maximum number of FTG Kunai Minato has thrown at once, with an aim, yes 1, that's it. what you failing to realize, is that there's no way Itachi letting Minato's kunai getting anywhere near him, not only Minato can't throw kunai as frequent as Sasuke, also if Itachi wants to keep distance from a dropped Kunai, he can simply jump back, even if he doesn't, Minato teleporting to a throwing kunai towards Itachi gets very predictable, it will put himself in danger for a counter attack from Itachi. I don't know why u always make Itachi sound like a stationary object, and let's say after a few kunai/shuriken exchanges, Minato got a Kunai near Itachi, he teleports to Itachi's "blindspot", it is very likely there will be a shadow clone made during the kunai exchange waiting for Minato to stab him already, just like during the Sasuke fight.
As far as the kunai page that you failed at using, I know the kunai impact near Itachi isn't likely his own because there are kunai directly inbetween Sasuke and Itachi. If Itachi were blocking all of Sasuke's kunai well before they reached Itachi's side, there would be no kunai inbetween them, they would all be heavily centered around Sasuke since that's where they would all be getting deflected. But the fact that there are some shown leading all the way from Sasuke to Itachi and everywhere inbetween proves that Itachi wasn't fast enough to keep all of Sasuke's kunai from him. Case closed
6. lol u are the one who said Minato has SM, so now you can't come up with an explanation on why Pa only mentioned Jiraiya and Naruto, you use "taboo" as ur excuse lol, why did Kakashi "taboo" the subject while Naruto was training for FRS? but I'm okay with it if u don't wanna talk about Minato can use SM or not, my point is to summon the 2 Sage Toads you need to use Sage Chakra, the manga facts are on my side, try to prove me wrong.
7. prove me Minato can throw kunai as frequent as Sasuke did in that panel, then I will say Itachi doesn't have better kunai skills. with FTG lvl2 out of the question, prove me how Minato tags someone hand to hand without taijutsu, then I will say Itachi doesn't have better taijutsu than him. n when it comes to intelligent you bring up hype, Jiraiya could be biased and how does it compare to "reason at Hokage's level at age 7"? actually the Ninja Academy teacher's statement about Itachi being the best student the Academy had is enough when it comes to this.
all ur arguments have been flawed, still not seeing the bad match up.
You addressed none of my counter arguments while simply continuing to spit baseless claims.
1. If Jiraiya would've brought them into the battle before he entered SM, they would be fending for themselves against pain while he would be helpless to assist because in order to enter SM he has to stay still. Ma and Pa help him to stabilize his sage chakra, they don't help him to enter SM. Just like with Naruto. They taught him how to gather nature chakra on his own FIRST. Then Pa suggested afterwards that he and Ma could fuse with them to help him keep SM active if only he didn't have the fox. Which is why I say it probably takes Sage chakra to fuse with the them together, that doesn't imply that it takes Sage chakra to summon them. It would make no sense to bring them into the battle and in harms way before they could serve their purpose. Do you not remember that Pa DIED against pain when he was actually in the fight without being fused with someone?
2. You completely ignored everything I said in this point because you know I'm right. Minato can TELEPORT with his seals. And I already proved that he carries a lot of them. By throwing a kunai then teleporting to it then throwing another one, he's inching closer and closer to Itachi every time. Eventually he'll get too close to Itachi and Itachi will have to dodge him. And if Minato has MULTIPLE ground seals scattered about, he'll have to watch where he steps because he doesn't want to get caught trying to dodge and accidentally jumping near a ground seal. Itachi probably does have more kunai and shuriken than Minato, that doesn't change the fact that Minato has the ability to utilize them better because of his teleportation. So you have lost the argument there completely.
3. It requires chakra to use the FTG, not to place the seals. Minato can place as many seals as he wants. Clearly he can do that because otherwise he wouldn't have so many pre-equip FTG seals on hand. He only uses chakra when he actually does FTG. Placing the seals have no effect on his chakra. He can place as many as he wants. Minato is the fastest ninja in Naruto with the best reflexes of any ninja we've seen. Including Itachi. Itachi is not going to just hit him with a kunai in the throat. Minato was praised for his reflexes, Itachi has never been. So you saying his reaction is just as good as the fastest ninja in Naruto is ridiculous. Just stop with that all together. If Itachi tries to strike Minato in hand to hand combat and Minato simply BLOCKS with his hand, once his hand makes contact with any part of Itachi's body Itachi will be tagged. You think it's more likely for Itachi to catch him off guard because that's what you want to happen. It's more likely for Minato to catch him off guard because he is the faster ninja. Itachi's speed feats do not compare, nor do his reflexes. It takes reflexes to know when to activate FTG. Minato dodged Raikage's high speed at point blank range. Never in your life say that Itachi has just as good reaction. He's never been shown to do anything that fast. Fail
4. I answered this in number 3. If Minato simply blocks an incoming punch or kick from Itachi, which we've seen happen before, Itachi will be tagged. End of story
5. Minato's trademark in war was throwing multiple kunai into enemy ranks and taking them all out at once. So your argument about him not having multiple kunai is fail. He dodged Raikage at point blank range, the second fastest ninja in naruto. Itachi isn't going to catch him with a shadow clone. Minato's reaction is too good. Eventually Minato will get the upper hand unless Itachi uses Susanoo, which like I said, if he does that then there goes his genjutsu advantage. In your strange mind you keep trying to match Itachi's speed and reflexes with Minato's when Itachi has done nothing comparable to Minato. Give it up. Regardless of how "predictable" you think it may get, Itachi isn't nearly fast enough to handle FTG level 2. And like I said, no matter how good your eyes are, if your opponent isn't fast enough it doesn't matter
6. No you are smart one that said "Minato needs SM to summon the toads". That's what started all of this. And then you claimed that manga says he can't have it due to his lack of chakra reserves. I wasn't going to point this out but do you remember how the 3 ninja struggled to do FTG on the Mizukage and commented on how insane the amount of chakra it took to do this ONCE was? Minato does this at will. Thus proving your lame argument wrong that he didn't have the chakra reserves to learn SM. And since he's jiraiya's pupil and clearly had the reserves for nature chakra, chances are he learned it. Even if he didn't, that still does not prove you need it to summon Ma and Pa. Case Closed
7. You commented on me not the other way around. I presented an arugment, and you've done nothing to prove your claims. All you've said is I don't agree. I could care less about your personal opinion, so I don't feel the need to prove anything to you. But I have come with more manga evidence to support my claims than you have and I even turned one of yours around. Like I said people have already repped me saying either I proved my point or you are just arguing because you are low on manga facts. It's over
1. fail, Ma and Pa helped Naruto during his battle with Pain without fused together, why can't they do the same with Jiraiya. and what does the fact Pa died has to do with anything, Ma and Pa fused with Jiraiya, Jiraiya died, Ma and Pa didn't fuse with Naruto, Pain died, I don't see ur point here.
2. lmfao what makes you think Minato would teleport to the thrown seals safely? once he starts repeating it Itachi can simply attack at the location of the Kunai, very very bad strategy, pretty sure Minato is smart enough to know better than that. Itachi has more Kunai and Shuriken than Minato and he uses them with better skills, no FTG Kunai is getting anywhere near Itachi and any stupid moves such as teleporting to a kunai that Itachi is staring at directly as u suggest would be fatal. So you have lost the argument there completely.
3. then what is the seal made of? Minato's piss? I don't think so, looks like its made of chakra, and no chakra required LOL. the fact Minato had to pre-equip FTG seals shows the fact it requires chakra, or else he can just use a regular kunai and tag them as he grabs them, common sense man. Minato has never shown better reflexes than Itachi, and he had bad reflexes a few times:
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
this is ur so called "best reflexes in the manga", it was stated A while in his lightning armor has reflexes matches Minato, but he had to go lvl2 to dodge Amaterasu, Sage Naruto has more precised anticipation than 3rd Raikage in his lightning armor, ur claim of Minato's reflexes are completely baseless, his best reflexes feat was reacting to a straight punch of A, the same thing even likes of Juugo and Suigetsu could manage, while Itachi has one of the best reflexes feat in the manga, activate Susanoo before Kirin hits, which was said to be "instant". Big fail for you right there.
4. another fail, if Minato can block Itachi's taijutsu with his finger and palm, that means if he had a kunai in his hand instead, he could inflict wound on Itachi through taijutsu the same way he blocks Itachi with his finger, it will only happen when Minato's taijutsu is better than Itachi's, which is clearly not the case, on top of that Minato is being handicapped during a taijutsu battle because he can't look at Itachi's eye, tagging him is almost impossible through taijutsu battle. if Itachi is the one initiating taijutsu battle, Minato better have a kunai in his hand or he's gonna get sliced wide open, if Minato is the one intiating taijutsu battle, sure he ain't touching Itachi, Killer Bee couldn't even do it, and if he's not careful, this will happen:
You must be registered for see images
5. from manga evidence, Minato actually had his comrades throwing the kunai for him, he has only shown throwing 1 FTG kunai at a time with aim, in manga, which is put to shame by Itachi's kunai feats. and I already showed why ur claim of "Minato's reaction is too good" is false with manga evidence. in ur straight mind you are trying to convince urself Minato's speed and reflexes are above Itachi's, in fact by feats Itachi is actually the better one, give it up. no need to worry bout FTG level 2, no kunai gets near Itachi, again, stands true until you prove Minato having much better reflexes and much better speed.
6. Minato needs SM to summon the toads is actually a counter argument against ur baseless claim "Minato can summon Ma and Pa", SM is required, Minato does not have SM, therefore Minato cannot summon the toads, simple n straight forward, Pa mentions Jiraiya and Naruto, while leaving Minato out in the large chakra reserve convo, what's ur excuses again? what does 3 ninja doing FTG have anything to do with chakra reserve, it's a S-ranked technique, 3 special Jounin fodder don't have the skills to master it, simple as that, FTG is reverse summoning, how much chakra does it take to summon an object that's the size of a human? plus it's not like Genma and them got tired after performing FTG, it has nothing to do with chakra reserve. "since he's Jiraiya's pupil and clearly had the reserves for nature chakra, chances are he learned it", sounds like you are talking about Nagato over here. Show me one time where the 2 Sage Toads were summoned without Sage chakra, then you can close ur case.
7. I actually had all my facts from the manga, was just too lazy to find the actual panel, now if you insist, I will make sure I find the manga scan to show how false ur baseless claims are, just like the "Minato reflexes" in this one. but sounds like you weren't getting much facts from the manga either, just arguing based on ur "personal opinion", of course you feel like you don't need to prove anything, you can't anyways.
Dont forget everyone that:
Itachi can never use Susano, Totsuka blade, and Yata Mirror anymore because he has lost the light in his eyes.
You need both MS eyes to activate Susano. He will be edo'd missing 1 eye.
Him losing the light of the Sharingan prior to his second death because of using a forbiden technique Izanami is connected to his soul.
Every edo was revived at the level/condition that they died!