[Theory] How the World Government took control of NORTH BLUE (it makes sense now) vinsmokes &

[asurakenpachi]

How the World Government took control of NORTH BLUE (it makes sense now) vinsmokes &

After reading last chapter, i think ive finally figured out a key event in one piece that occurred within the last 100 years. If any of yall make theory videos, use any of my theorys just give the boi a shotout.

So to begin, we learned many things last chapter, but what i found to be the most interesting was the conversation between brook and reiju vinsmoke. Brook said that the vinsmokes ran the entire north blue for a "long time" and with an "iron fist".

Now think about this, brook has been alive for at most 100 years or so. So he was born while the vinsmoke family was in power in the north blue and at some point in his 100 years of existence, the vinsmokes lost that power and their land.

With that in mind, i now ask yall to think, how were the vinsmokes controlling the north blue while the world government was in power and in control of the other 3 seas (south, east, and west blue)? Well i have a pretty good idea of what occurred

We know that there is 5 members of the gorosei and that they were the ones who created the world government. Out of the 5 members of the gorosei, im sure youve all noticed that 1 member stands out from the rest... the guy with the blonde hair.

Think about this, its been said that the gorosei hold the tree of life and have been alive since Making the world government. Just because you live forever though doesn't mean you retain your same youthful features. When you look at the gorosei, they all have greyish white hair except for the baldie (baldness shows his age) and the blonde guy. Based on this information, i believe that the blonde guy joined the gorosei years after they were already established. I also believe that the blonde gorosei member is INDEED A VINSMOKE.

If it was alot to take in ill try to go more in depth. when brook was born, north blue was ran by the vinsmokes. Now if the blonde gorosei is/was vinsmoke, itd make sense for him to be a gorosei for 2 major reasons. 1st. The fact that for a certain amount of time, the vinsmokes ran the entire north blue means that whoever was the vinsmokes leader at the time was strong enough to hold off the world government. 2nd. The fact that he look distinctly younger than the other 4 members. He still has his natural hair color whereas the other gorosei hair are as white as doflamingos strings.

I believe there was a deal struck up between the 4 goroseis and og vinsmoke. Part of the deal guranteed the world government control of north blue and on the blonde vinsmokes side, he was granted a seat in the gorosei, a fruit from the tree of life, and the safety of the rest of the vinsmokes.

What'd yall think

 

[Bimbonium]

If the blonde Gorosei was a Vinsmoke, the Vinsmokes would still have some sort of control over the world (more than they already do) and wouldn't need the BM alliance, though it could be that he betrayed them or something, your theory is pretty plausible tho

 

[Your Creepy Stalker]

Realistically, they could just send Akainu at them and call it a day.

 

[asurakenpachi]

The control that the vinsmokes(as a whole) had was when they had north blue on lock. Based on the vinsmokes current situation, id say that as a whole, the vinsmoke family wants to continue ruling as they were but are much weaker than they were in the past and cant gain their territories back. When the blonde gorosei sold out the vinsmokes, the wg probably killed off and destroyed most of germa 66 but part of the deal they had in place probably ensured the safety of the vinsmoke family. Germa 66 needs bigmams forces to compensate for the lost germa 66 forces. Part of the reason why the vinsmokes are able to attend the reverie now may be due to the fact that they are much weaker than in the past and part of the deal with the blonde gorosei may have included something along the lines of recognizing the vinsmokes as a kingdoms despite them owning no land. Essentially it's the government saying "hey you don't run 1/4 of the sea anymore but you can participate in this 20 leader meeting so no hard feelings".

 

[Son Ryuto Uzumaki]

I like it better than saying he's Sanji dad or what if he is Sanji dad and gave up his power in the North for a Gorsei seat but now is plotting a change so he is trying to ally with a yonko

 

[Simpleatitsbest]

As theory's go, this is pretty common knowledge, I guess the only new bit or thought was that the Blond Gorosei guy gave up North Blue for a seat in the WG...
However, what if maybe he still controls Germa 66, a group of assassins and actually this whole marriage is a way to get close to Big Mom so that the WG can "assassinate" her?
Or maybe he just straight up commands Germa 66 as a task force that is now being used by the government in general and that him joining the Gorosei just guaranteed them safety from the WG?

 

[Caliburn]

Brook is 90 years old. He spent more than half of his life being trapped inside the Florian Triangle and only very recently he escaped from it. So the fact that he is talking about a certain age and that he says it was long ago, pretty much means he's talking about something he lived through. Also Brook was born in West Blue and it has been clearly stated that it's incredibly difficult to go from one of the four seas to another and that the four seas are practically four different worlds. So Brook has absolutely no connection whatsoever to North Blue and there is nothing that indicates he was alive while the Vinsmoke ruled North Blue and even if that was the case, it has absolutely no relevance whatsoever to him as he lived in West Blue before going to the Grand Line.

So your first assumption that Brook lived during the time that the Vinsmokes ruled North Blue is both questionable and irrelevant.

Your second assumption that the WG had no power in North Blue, is even more questionable. The Vinsmokes are allowed to participate in the Reverie even while they don't have any country. If they are allowed that in such a situation, why wouldn't that be the case if they still had lands? Having the Vinsmokes rule North Blue really is not a contradictory to WG institution. The Vinsmokes could have easily been ruling North Blue and be a part of the WG. It would be extremely illogical to think that the WG, who have existed for 800 years, would have no power whatsoever in North Blue only one century ago.

Your third assumption that is questionable and baseless, is that you think that the WG controls the entire world, which is not the case or in the least never stated. The WG consists out of several hundreds of countries and kingdoms spread over the entire world, however it was never stated nor implied that all the countries are part of the WG. You are apparently under the impression that the WG is one huge kingdom, but that's not what they are.

So your entire idea of "what might happened" is based on nothing.

Your fourth assumption, and this one is plainly wrong, is that you think that the Goorosei made the WG. They didn't. The WG was created by the ancestors of the Celestial Dragons 800 years ago. The Goorosei is merely the highest ruling organ of the WG. Also it's highly subjective to say that the blond guy stands out as another one of them looks like Ghandi with a katana and another one looks like he has white dreads and a huge scar on his face. So there is no reason whatsoever to single the blond guy out.

Your fifth assumption is plainly ridiculous. Tree of Life? Being alive for 800 years? No one has said this, unless maybe some crackpot theorists. You can completely erase this, so everything you said after that can be discarded completely as it's based on nothing. Frankly what you do is randomly making stuff up. You made a story, not a theory; you made a story and then tried to make everything fit your story.


In the end all of this comes down to that blond guy being a Vinsmoke. Why? Because he's blond =/ It's really really really simple. There are three confirmed Vinsmokes. What is their most prominent shared trait? Curly one-directional eyebrows. That dude doesn't have them.