How do you rate Kishi? :)

[Sabaki]

Approximately a 2 out of 5; and barely so. Recently, his writing has become terrible—the amount of irrelevant shit occurring, the amount of regurgitated plot devices, and so on. However, my rating may be predicated off of the fact that I have been reading far more well-written manga; Seinen, rather than shitty SJ.​

​

 

[Cosman]

4/5

Unbelievable talents in terms of characterization and storytelling, but he is a rather campy writer, and goes for shock value over decent plot progression sometimes. However, his art skills are fantastic (considering this is a demanding weekly series). Unique designs a lot of the times, and a very immersing world he's created.

 

[The7thHokage]

5/5 for part 1
3.5/5 for part 2

 

[Sasukenumberonelover]

3.5/5 .. u_u

 

[Anbu Itachi]

3/4 :eww:

 

[illidanson]

9/10

Sry but I always rate things out of 10, 5 just ain't enough!!

But yea Naruto is probably my favorite anime/manga of all time! I'll admit Kishi makes some mistakes here and there, but in my opinion the overall epicness and all the awesome moments totally overrules the few flaws that the series has.

 

[Lordofd100x]

4/5 Just for making Tobi predictable... A word puzzle and Kakashis old team mate.... what a shame.

This may go to 2/5 depending on how it ends.

 

[sumbul]

4.5/5 because he atkes many brakes

 

[jorgelius]

about 1 guy voted 5 stars that tell me he isnt such a great man, when u get older your idea's arent same when u was young, everyone get tru this

 

[Klad]

9/10

Sry but I always rate things out of 10, 5 just ain't enough!!

But yea Naruto is probably my favorite anime/manga of all time! I'll admit Kishi makes some mistakes here and there, but in my opinion the overall epicness and all the awesome moments totally overrules the few flaws that the series has.

This ^^ :bouncy:

 

[Renpatsu Dei]

I'm not really one to judge, because I don't have the sort of literary background to judge but I would say 3.5 out of 5.

Kishi has the best talents in characterization out of the big three IMO, and he has tried to tackle quite complex and mature concepts. However, I think in general he's bitten off more than he can chew, adding many characters that he struggles to keep up with and develop and the concepts he has tried to go into haven't been fleshed out enough because of the flashy plot twists he always loves to produce and time constraints he seems to be under. He also has a bad habit of overplaying the relationships between characters making their relationships seem forced or overly obsessive. However, he writes a very solid story, with great characters and overall plot.

 

[esenn1]

5 ..... 5 ...... 5 ....... 5 ...... 5

 

[- J AV -]

5/5..... naruto is best manag i have read=D

 

[Homertime06]

4/5

Everybody who rate him under 3

I dont understand why ur here on this base.

His drawing are amazing

His story amazing



Lets wait for Naruto to end before being too much harsh. Lets not forget alots of stuff is going to happen. Madara trumps card. Maybe.. I hope Orochimaru is still a badass. Sasuke need a power up and alots more.

This is not asspull it is PNJ.



Deal whit it, 80 more chapter.

 

[ANONNEWBIE]

not more than 2 out of 5

 

[Naruto99Uzumaki]

4/5

plot no jutsu
the manga needs more action

 

[ChrisWolf]

4.5/5 for me. it would be 5 if sakura died already

I love your sig man