[Discussion] Garp vs Shanks

[Yonko]

When Shanks stopped the war. What if Garp confronted him once and for all and ended up in an all out 1 v 1 fight

MF Garp vs MF Shanks. No one interferes.

 

[Pirate King]

shanks extreme dif

 

[Hexuze]

Shanks high diff.

 

[A v i]

Shanks wins.

 

[Meee]

I say Shanks.

 

[DemonicAvenger]

Shanks Mid-Diffs this. He's above the admiral's by portrayal/hype, Garp isn't taking him on.​

​

 

[Kiri Starstalker]

No one beats Garp the Hero

 

[Dęvîa Puęrî]

Garp because he would have more to fight for and more emotion his grandson just died from what I remember Shanks didn't have any interactions with ace... Garp already in that mode should put up more of a fight from get go and has more emotion towards it.. Lol it won't be easy fight tho highest of difficulty for each party

 

[IPulseZz]

Garp is like on the level of whitebeard so it would be a very difficult fight but I thinks shanks would win this. Imo shanks was slightly stronger than old whitebeard

 

[Magi]

Shanks high diff.. Garp is well past his prime

 

[Anduril]

Shanks wins somewhere between mid to high diff.

 

[kageking]

It's 50-50 extreme diff both ways. I'd say shanks but not with any confidence or reasoning greater than fanboy logic.

 

[Ridoku X]

I say Shanks high diff just because of Garp's age. v_v

 

[giostep]

To say that Old Non prime WB or Garp is > Current shanks is really underrating Shanks...

 

[MickNerks]

I honestly cant answer this question. Either Shanks wins with Extremely High difficulty and leaves the fight in a near death state, or Garp win with High Difficulty and leaves the fight in a rough state.

Actually I see garp winning more times then shanks. Garp seems like the type of person who would tank most of the attacks thrown his way. I really strongly think there is a reason Oda did not involve garp in the war. It was bad enough having whitebeard running around embarressing admiral. Garp would have done the exact same except to the pirate side.

It only took one punch from garp to put Marco down and bruise him. Mind you that is something not even Kizaru an admiral could do.

Shanks Mid-Diffs this. He's above the admiral's by portrayal/hype, Garp isn't taking him on.​

​

Garp is also above admiral level. All his life his only chanlleges were yonko level opponents

 

[Bogard]

Shanks very high-extreme difficulty

 

[OG sama]

Shanks wins. There should be know doubt about this, Garp is far from his prime and Shanks has been portrayed to be above the admirals. Only way this can be doubtful is if you believe MF Garp was >MF Akainu. Which should put them on the same level.

 

[David1996]

Shanks.

 

[ultraChalk]

Shanks Mid-Diffs this. He's above the admiral's by portrayal/hype, Garp isn't taking him on.​

​

Nobody is mid diffing Garp. Not even Roger XD

But Shanks, with some severe injuries.

 

[Bogard]

Nobody is mid diffing Garp. Not even Roger XD

But Shanks, with some severe injuries.

Pretty certain Roger will mid diff MF Garp