Full metal alchemist Live action movie

[Guy Fawkes]

Next year we will have a live action FMA movie. The cast will be strictly Japanese, which I think is awesome and refreshing. My only problem is, isn't Edward European? In fact, most in FMA either have European names or they have European features(blue eyes, blond hair, round eyes instead of slanted, European names "Van Hoenheim") and the rest Look to be from the middle east.


So, this is probably the only Anime-movie adaptation that I think should have more Europeans than Asains, I only say this because I always pictured most of the characters, white. Now when Naruto or Bleach or AOT get live action adaptations I expect mostly Japanesse casting, because I readily identify most characters in those series as Japanesse( Ay and Killer Bee of the few obvious exceptions) despite having white features (Naruto, Ichigo) and even AOT the walls have Latin names ("maria" etc etc).

Basically casting for comics and casting for manga live adaption is not going to be same simple process.

 

[Filosoofis]

Next year we will have a live action FMA movie. The cast will be strictly Japanese, which I think is awesome and refreshing. My only problem is, isn't Edward European? In fact, most in FMA either have European names or they have European features(blue eyes, blond hair, round eyes instead of slanted, European names "Van Hoenheim") and the rest Look to be from the middle east.


So, this is probably the only Anime-movie adaptation that I think should have more Europeans than Asains, I only say this because I always pictured most of the characters, white. Now when Naruto or Bleach or AOT get live action adaptations I expect mostly Japanesse casting, because I readily identify most characters in those series as Japanesse( Ay and Killer Bee of the few obvious exceptions) despite having white features (Naruto, Ichigo) and even AOT the walls have Latin names ("maria" etc etc).

Basically casting for comics and casting for manga live adaption is not going to be same simple process.

>is about germanic people
>cast japanese


atleast they won't screw it up.I know attack on titan is nowhere near the manga or anime but atleast it is better than dbz evolution

 

[Guy Fawkes]

>is about germanic people
>cast japanese


atleast they won't screw it up.I know attack on titan is nowhere near the manga or anime but atleast it is better than dbz evolution

every and anything is better than that garbage

 

[-immortal-]

*reads anime*
*reads live action movie *

*sees both in same thread*

You must be registered for see images

 

[Guy Fawkes]

*reads anime*
*reads live action movie *

*sees both in same thread*

You must be registered for see images

...was i not suppose to do that or...?

 

[SilverfoxUchiha]

Expect it to be awful.

 

[Guy Fawkes]

Expect it to be awful.

the special affects in Japanesse movies are ****ing terrible. like death note

 

[chopstickchakra]

Next year we will have a live action FMA movie. The cast will be strictly Japanese, which I think is awesome and refreshing. My only problem is, isn't Edward European? In fact, most in FMA either have European names or they have European features(blue eyes, blond hair, round eyes instead of slanted, European names "Van Hoenheim") and the rest Look to be from the middle east.


So, this is probably the only Anime-movie adaptation that I think should have more Europeans than Asains, I only say this because I always pictured most of the characters, white. Now when Naruto or Bleach or AOT get live action adaptations I expect mostly Japanesse casting, because I readily identify most characters in those series as Japanesse( Ay and Killer Bee of the few obvious exceptions) despite having white features (Naruto, Ichigo) and even AOT the walls have Latin names ("maria" etc etc).

Basically casting for comics and casting for manga live adaption is not going to be same simple process.

This is a terrible idea. name me 1 good let alone great anime live action adaptation and I'll name you 5 bad ones. Funniest part is I bet you no one who complained about Scarlett Johanssen being cast in Ghost in the Shell will complain about this casting not being accurate. Make a white fictional character white when people want him to be something else and you're racist, make a primarily white fictional cast not white, nobody bats an eye.

 

[Melanin]

Yea no thanks, they need to leave manga to animation.

but Scarlett>>>>>>

You must be registered for see images

 

[Guy Fawkes]

Yea no thanks, they need to leave manga to animation.

but Scarlett>>>>>>

You must be registered for see images

yea thats one fine white lady

 

[Natsu Shazneel]

****the Japanese. Get some brown people in to make it look prettier.

 

[Guy Fawkes]

****the Japanese. Get some brown people in to make it look prettier.

I would agree if this was anything else. But Full Metal? come on.. we all know they suppose to be German or Swedish or sum shit.

 

[Natsu Shazneel]

I would agree if this was anything else. But Full Metal? come on.. we all know they suppose to be German or Swedish or sum shit.

Than why you happy with Japanese though?

 

[Guy Fawkes]

Than why you happy with Japanese though?

because they created it, it makes since....a little

 

[Natsu Shazneel]

because they created it, it makes since....a little

Regardless of who created it. A character needs to look like the character if they don't they fail. Japanese can't do the character right cause most of these anime characters don't even look Japanese. And if they did I doubt they would be famious around the world.

 

[Guy Fawkes]

Regardless of who created it. A character needs to look like the character if they don't they fail. Japanese can't do the character right cause most of these anime characters don't even look Japanese. And if they did I doubt they would be famious around the world.

these are the people who still participate in black face...still. Besides, I already said I pictured them white and not Japanese, I'm just excited the story and characters are going to be in a live action film. Hollywood has been racist since it's inception (birth of a nation (check out the new one, its about Nat Turner ironically)), so it doesn't bother me that the Asian Film Industry are as well , besides its not black face this time, its white face.

 

[Princess Kaguya]

I will watch it as soon as it's available. I am curious of how it will turn out.:lol

 

[Bad Touch Yakushi]

FMA and AoT having a full Japanese cast is just as silly as any of the other whitewashing 'scandal'.

The CGI budget looks huge and even with all that high production they still can't fix Ed from looking like a cheap cosplay. Live action Japanese film outside of Chambara and animation suck, and they certainly can't do adaptations.

 

[Avani]

FMA and AoT having a full Japanese cast is just as silly as any of the other whitewashing 'scandal'.

The CGI budget looks huge and even with all that high production they still can't fix Ed from looking like a cheap cosplay. Live action Japanese film outside of Chambara and animation suck, and they certainly can't do adaptations.

Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't. FMA is a fictional universe despite being inspired by RL in some way. As a matter of fact people got it wrong when they thought FMA was referring to a particular community when writer mentioned some incident much closer to home. Their primary audience is local community which is relatively homogeneous and movie relies on anime like diversity.

America actually has more diversity and still most movies were limited to a certain groups even when they needed other people.

You must be registered for see links

But how many people complained? (Some did call it a Brexit movie but mostly it was seen as fine.)