No. It's what you do when you're having a problem with inactives. They're not worth any time to be spent on being lynched because info that comes out of their lynch is minimal but just letting them go free is not acceptable as they are inactive and they're a possible inactive scum. So killing them is the go.
[Game] [FIN]- Round 4- The Haunting of Hill House - Mafia Game Thread
- Thread starter MadieV
- Start date
- Status
Ansatsuken
Active member
Awards
It could be Gister is avoiding to vote in this DP because he is afraid of upcoming trouble if he mislynch wrong player as a Mafia. But of course for mafia they will always lynched the "wrong" player. But if he is truly mafia he should aware right now that his move failed. Unless he wanted to sacrifice himself as per the plan. Maybe I should say it now. What I mean by "plan" here is that one Mafia going for the bandwagon(voting his/her team mate with other players that mostly townies) but with good enough reasoning to masked his/her action. Something that we should consider here.
But if Gister is truly a townie I still will not throwing away the possibility that Mafia is among the voters. At least one.
I can only give further write up of my observation after we get the result.
But if you asking me who could be the mafia that trying to kill his/her teammate as part of the plan? it between Dragomir or Michelle.
For Michelle she actually felt very reluctant to vote for Gister eventhough she already voted him. She always asking Drago about the town position of Gister in his POV. But Drago couldn't give her something that she can be convinced with. So she stayed with her vote. But she have an option to unvote if she's unsure.
As for Dragomir, he is straight with his decision making. Like Mafia who played like this they will used the info that they think is sufficient enough and good enough for his reasoning. To be honest they will never have second thought because mafia doesn't need it. What's matter is that the reasoning should be strong to attract attention+acceptable and able to reconcile their true alignment.
And when the person he voted flip Mafia its a nice journey for him in front.
But if Gister is truly a townie I still will not throwing away the possibility that Mafia is among the voters. At least one.
I can only give further write up of my observation after we get the result.
But if you asking me who could be the mafia that trying to kill his/her teammate as part of the plan? it between Dragomir or Michelle.
For Michelle she actually felt very reluctant to vote for Gister eventhough she already voted him. She always asking Drago about the town position of Gister in his POV. But Drago couldn't give her something that she can be convinced with. So she stayed with her vote. But she have an option to unvote if she's unsure.
As for Dragomir, he is straight with his decision making. Like Mafia who played like this they will used the info that they think is sufficient enough and good enough for his reasoning. To be honest they will never have second thought because mafia doesn't need it. What's matter is that the reasoning should be strong to attract attention+acceptable and able to reconcile their true alignment.
And when the person he voted flip Mafia its a nice journey for him in front.
Ansatsuken
Active member
Awards
Something to add into my Michelle write up,
...So how it played out here? By acting all concerned towards Gister.
...So how it played out here? By acting all concerned towards Gister.
Not sure how you came to that conclusion but I was speaking in general as in the vig should kill them at night, not Strange specifically.
Michelle
Active member
Awards
@Ansatsuken i am very well aware that anyone can suspect anyone. As long as i have a solid vote i don't unvote until i am positive about the unvote.
Asking Dragomir about Gister were a form to see his oppinion who looked first like he defended Gister so I asked again. This all interaction gave me a scum read from Dragomir. I am not concerned about Gister because he planted some posts and went MIA.
I don't defend myself, you should know my playstyle.
Oh so voting is mandatory per player? I thought the no-lynch rule meant there won't be ties or that you can't vote for a "no-lynch" option
I'm gonna read the the pages I missed to make my reads and place a lynch on a player
Michelle
Active member
Awards
You quoted his post and said he could kill inactives during NP thing that scum do.
I've read your post exactly the same but i was busy to reply at Ansa's post first
6thHokage
Active member
Awards
Although I voted for Odd, my suspicion isn't as strong anymore. Gister getting lynched will reveal a lot. Ansatsuken, a confirmed townie was the first to vote for him, so it would make sense for wolves to follow his lead to blend in. Dragomir, in particular, is standing out to me because he came out strong against SoulKiller only to change his vote to join the majority.
Ansatsuken
Active member
Awards
I will stayed with my vote and Gister can be the turning point. The possibility of mafia existence within this group of players(Gister, Dr Strange, Michelle, Dragomir except me) is high. At least one.
@Ansatsuken I can't say I follow your logic here. I find my straight approach just fine. I'm an assertive player, Town should always be assertive and not beat around the bush with wishy washy reads. When I have a strong suspicion on someone, I will be straight and upfront about it. I don't see how playing like that means this
You're interpreting it wrong. I wasn't trying to specifically say that "He" should kill them but that you just kill them in a general statement.
Ansatsuken
Active member
Awards
This is just my early write up. I'm not actually directly saying you're scum same as Dragomir here. That just a "potential" write up that can be use as future reference.
Be prepared before too late.
Michelle
Active member
Awards
Ansatsuken
Active member
Awards
To be honest it doesn't matter how you play meant to be like this or like that. It can be whatever. Its not you who will judge your playing style as a mafia or indie or townie but people who play around you. For you, you played honest and upfront but other players will have different perception on you. The perception not only build through reading a post but NP action etc etc. Time will tell
Ok, will use this for my reference.
Alice in Noodleland
Active member
Awards
Shanks
Active member
Awards
- Status