[Discussion] Erza and Irene Connection

[Spha]

Looking at next week title, gave me an Idea of how Irene and Erza are connected.

1. Irene and Erza are one Earthland person,
2. Irene represent Erza negative emotions and Erza represent the Positive.

What makes me think of this is becouse Erza had a hard life but she is unable to hate anyone, but on the other side, Irene is unable to love humans except his own creations.

Irene looks older than Erza but they might be the same age, another thing is that Irene and Erza might have Created each other just after their birth, after this process was done Irene looked older than Erza and Killed all of Erza and her Parents leaving only him and Erza until Irene was chased out of the Village and saving Erza from being killed as well.

So basically Irene is all the hostilities Erza is unable to have, and Erza represent Love..

The only way Erza will defeat Irene is if he Accept Irene, and acknowlege that she has this bad side to herself, than they will Finally become one again.

Irene=hate and Erza=love.

What do u think.

 

[Umari Senju]

Clones. Erza is a clone lol.

But no seriously I can see where you would get this theory and it does fit into the FT logic system that's for sure.

 

[Caliburn]

To be honest I think you're making an inconsistent rambling that's based on nothing.

For starters your number 2 pretty much by default contains number 1, so it's kinda redundant to make a difference. Secondly Erza has shown quite a bit of anger, hate and violence in her life, something she is very well aware of. Likewise Irene has shown some kind of love in the form of loyalty towards Zeref. You don't expect two people who are supposed to be absolute opposites, to be that ambiguous. Thirdly most of this is nonsensical. It's possible that Hiro is trying to make Erza symbolize love and Irene hatred, however that's something differently than some kind of existence purposefully separating itself in a good and bad part. On what is that even based? Unless the Force plays a part in the Fairy Tail verse, someone is not just going to decide to be born and separate itself into a good and bad part. What's even the point of that? It's also nonsensical that Irene somehow can kill her parents, but not Erza, the baby. You're also contradicting yourself as if they truly are two opposites, then why does Erza have to accept Irene? That only works if Erza is the main existence and Irene just a small part that broke of, which does not fit the duality of a good and evil part.

There is some merit in the idea that Erza and Irene are twin sisters or something. However that idea can pretty much be discarded due to the fact that there is still very well some physical difference between the two and Irene knows about Erza, but not the other way around, which indicates that it's not something two-directional, which is something you would expect.

 

[VVolfVVarrior]

Is it not possible that she is from another dimension? Like Erza from Edolas.

 

[Xāvî1]

Is it not possible that she is from another dimension? Like Erza from Edolas.

Or it could be a joke by Irene.