Please don't look at me as a rude person for calling you out like this, but most of your argument revolved around subjective reasoning, biased perception, false claims, and all without manga scans to prove anything that you have said.
I wouldn't ever look at you as rude. It's just what you think, after all. Nothing wrong with that.
As for subjective reasoning, biased perception, false claims, etc- to each their own I guess. People view things differently and any "vs" fight is a hypothetical situation. Anyone debating a close fight is going to seem "biased", seem "subjective", and make their own claims when another with a differing view looks at their post. The fight never happened, so any fan has their own view of how it would go down.
The lack of implementing new manga scans isn't necessarily a negative, either. Yes, manga scans are helpful to prove points but many things fans remember since we read the same manga. Then again, an argument w/o manga scans is pretty lack-luster, so I concede on that.
I have provided more than enough scans to prove my own reasoning, and I base my reasoning on logic and what has transpired in the manga. Also, clearly I'm only talking about this particular matchup as well, which is why I've spent the whole damn thread comparing 3T Itachi and 3T Kakashi as well as their confrontations which, quite frankly, a surprising amount of readers misinterpreted and just have converted it into the fuel they use to spit out the shit and falsities that most moronic Itachi fans spew even now (not talking about you, don't misundestand, though you have also said your fair share of false and biased claims here)...
Yes, I seem biased since I have a relatively clear stance on the issue. Just as some hard-core Kakashi fans that commented in this thread believe that any version of Kakashi beats any respective version of Itachi. And how I said in an earlier post that some of your points seemed biased imo.
I think that one MS Kakashi beats Itachi, DMS Kakashi beats Itachi easily, and 3-tomoe/no-sharingan lose. I've seen their feats as well, their quotes, have my views on their personalities- and that's just what I think. Many factors come into this like starting distance, location, and whatever else. And if this were going to be a canon fight, Kishimoto would just write a way for either to win. I don't think it's impossible (not that you said it was impossible, I'm just saying) for 3-tomoe Itachi to beat 3-tomoe Kakashi high-diff.
My point is that a "vs" fight is pretty subjective to begin with. All people are afforded with are some knowledge on a character's techs and the way they act, then the rest is up to them and how they debate. When people come to a conclusion it's not going to be a 100% definite one, even after an extensive thread.
Nowhere, absolutely nowhere in my post have I hinted that "lol raiton clone stun followed by raikiri GG" will defeat everyone, like some moronic and biased Kakashi fans on this site have continually asserted. Furthermore, I know both characters inside out, since I have analyzed their characterization, abilities, fights, quotes, personalities, tendencies, and everything that Kishimoto-san has layed out for us on several occasions, and I'm a fan of both characters. I couldn't give 1, or 2, or 3 cojones who wins this fight.
I think you do care who wins the fight. You went to all the trouble of researching Kakashi's best points and posting this thread. Plus, you're responding to everyone.
Most people agreeing and stating this conclusion of the OP was obvious are known Kakashi fans/wankers. Most disagreeing and not giving good replies to it are Itachi fans/wankers.
Yeah, you're implying that your thread holds more weight since you don't have a character preference- but I think you do prefer Kakashi as a character. Even if it's just a little. Which isn't a bad thing, no one can really like two characters equally unless they were the exact same.
Now I understand that nobody can completely avoid error, which is why I have explicitly stated that I'm more than happy for someone to prove me wrong using legitimate, undivided, and undeniable proof in the form of manga scans, statements, databook information, and logical reasoning, but you haven't done any of that. Once you do, trust me that I will be happy to concede and put on a metaphorical dunce cap for making this thread,
No one is ever going to prove you wrong here in a way that you'll be satisfied. Even if older debaters were here from 2011/2012. If canon material existed that would be "undeniable", "undivided", and "legitimate", then it wouldn't be arguable and this thread wouldn't even be needed since the entire fandom would know that "x character wins". The winner of this isn't as obvious as some other matchups with larger power gaps between opponents. But you know this (everyone does, this debate won't ever end until the series fandom dies out eventually) and just wanted to state your points, which is cool.
instead of having your fellow Itachi "fans" put on a giant collective dunce cap on your whole fanbase with all of the absent minded, inane, and shit-tastic jokes that they have posted not only on this thread, but on every thread of every section of every part of this god forsaken site. Until then, I will maintain my position.
Doesn't really put a "collective dunce cap on the whole fanbase" when most serious Itachi fans aren't on NB. Or even the NB-side of the fandom since wankers don't represent the
entirety of any fanbase.
Also, no need for dunce caps. lol
Sorry for typing these walls of text for this post. Isn't really a rebuttal, more just info on my perspective. (Yeah, it's useless to you, but oh well. xD ) You did make a really nice thread, good points, and put much effort into this. But there's no way to "end this debate" since people will always disagree with these two, unless Kishimoto woke up tomorrow and said "so-and-so wins".
I agree but Kakashi wins with high dificulty against a healthy 3 tomoe Itachi. His chakra levels permitted him to maintain v4 susanoo for a while when he was sick, dying, and nearly out of chakra, so his reserves shouldn't be so bad when healthy even if they're still average. Don't pay any mind to these sick asshats, Itachibase is nothing now that Owarij, FloriGori, Blaze Release, Forbidden Technique, maybe Prince Charles (he logged on the other day), Strict, and others have left NB or aren't as active anymore. Chie was never really that good either, just another fapclown that lived in lala land when it came to itachi.
@bold- They never were a part of "ItachiBase". ItachiBase is just a wank group.
And @ last sentence- Hmm, maybe. And yeah, my posts for "vs" debates do suck, we get it. Lol
Nah, I think he was just being sarcastic towards the Itachi fans. I don't blame him either, just look at all the fecal matter that the Itachi wankers have posted on this thread. Pure garbage at best, nothing but speculation and bias. Especially Nattana and parts of Chie's posts, pure ignorance at its finest.
@bold- Yes, the first few posts were filled with it. They weren't really serious and sounded pretty condescending. Lol
Did you seriously think you'd end a debate with the large amount of Itachi fanbase around? You can't end debate with them even if it was against Kaguya
Let's not exaggerate here. Wankbase =/= Fanbase. At least not always.
