Edo Nagato vs Edo Itachi

Who would win in a battle?

  • Edo Nagato

    Votes: 27 67.5%
  • Edo Itachi

    Votes: 12 30.0%
  • Draw

    Votes: 1 2.5%

  • Total voters
    40

Unbiased King

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Nov 3, 2012
Messages
769
Reaction score
58
Yata Mirror and Sword of Totsuka < most of what was said about sasuno'o, these weapons are spiritual weapons, and anything spiritual can be taken by human path, hell king/demon, and definately by outer path, which is the bridge between the afterlife (pure world) and the real life(impure world) or spiritual world and physical world. Also Itachi seems to need chakra to maintain the weapons as well, in fact from what we have seen, all the weapons of the sage of the six paths require A LOT of chakra to use, preta could pose problems.

Human path only affects the soul and mind. Susano'o is chakra.

Also King of Hell requires the victim to be immobile or pinned down.

Same thing for Preta path; Preta path can only be used in close proximity.
Tsukiyomi < rinnegan and Uzumaki heritage plus genjutsu barrier. Itachi once said to Kakashi that only a person of his blood or heritage who has the sharingan can brake his tsukiyomi, and since Kakashi was not an uchiha, he failed to break it. But Nagato is an Uzumaki, and both Uchiha and Uzumaki are descendent from the sage, so they are of the same heritage, plus rinnegan is not only a stronger doujutsu then the sharingan, but it is the ultimate level of sharingan mastery based on what we saw and heard from real madara, so then, this makes nagato fit the profile of the people who can break Tsukiyomi, based on Itachi's own words, though he was a top class liar, Itachi didn't have a reason or motive to lie in this case. Nagato also seems to specialize with barriers and more specifically, genjutsu barriers, he had these genjutsu barriers placed on his subordinates to prevent interogation, so it is possible that he has an even stronger one on himself. We have also never seen him get caught in a genjutsu, just three of his bodies, but not the real him, besides, those three paths could have broken the frog song if they wanted too (I have good reasons for saying this but it is irrelevant to the current topic). In any case, Nagato trumps tsukiyomi too.

Like you said, only those of the same blood can have a chance of breaking Tsukuyomi. However, although Uzumaki stems from Senju which stems from the SO6P, the Uchiha shares ABSOLUTELY NO RELATION to the Uzumaki nor the Senju. It is only lineage, not blood.

Yasaka Magatama won't work for obvious reasons, shinra tensei or chakra absorbtion.

Once again, Preta path can only be used in close proximity.
 

Simple Math

Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2012
Messages
0
Reaction score
932
Nagato has no counter to Tsukuyomi.

The reason genjutsu didn't work on the path is because, well, IT'S A PATH, just a corpse being pulled and pushed with chakra.

simply just dont look into the eyes. every god shinobis know that...
 

Unbiased King

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Nov 3, 2012
Messages
769
Reaction score
58
simply just dont look into the eyes. every god shinobis know that...

You imply that every God (or good if a typo) shinobi knows this by spontaneously developing knowledge on something they're experiencing for the first time, eh?

Name one shinobi that knows this WITHOUT any experience/advice against the sharingan that instructed so.
 
Last edited:

KidGamer65

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Aug 5, 2012
Messages
38,776
Reaction score
2,272
Nagato has no counter to Tsukuyomi.

The reason genjutsu didn't work on the path is because, well, IT'S A PATH, just a corpse being pulled and pushed with chakra.

Linked Vision with summons renders Tsukuyomi useless.
 

Unbiased King

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Nov 3, 2012
Messages
769
Reaction score
58
Linked Vision with summons renders Tsukuyomi useless.

How so?

Under normal circumstances, to break out of genjutsu, the chakra flow must be disturbed. I doubt any of his summons can disturb his chakra before Itachi impales him with the Sword of Totsuka.

I don't see how his shared vision with his summons overcomes genjutsu. But even then, hasn't Itachi raped his summons by going for their blindspots?
 

KidGamer65

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Aug 5, 2012
Messages
38,776
Reaction score
2,272
How so?

Under normal circumstances, to break out of genjutsu, the chakra flow must be disturbed. I doubt any of his summons can disturb his chakra before Itachi impales him with the Sword of Totsuka.

I don't see how his shared vision with his summons overcomes genjutsu. But even then, hasn't Itachi raped his summons by going for their blindspots?

He can see out of their eyes so he doesn't have to fight with his eyes open so Itachi can't hit with Tsukuyomi, Nagato can also sense chakra.

Itachi got the summons when Nagato wasn't even paying attention to him, he was busy trying to suck Naruto's soul out and he was going to blast Bee's head off with his cannon, this time around he can easily use a Bansho Tennin or fire that Asura Path cannon at Itachi so he can't disable the Shared Vision.
 

Unbiased King

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Nov 3, 2012
Messages
769
Reaction score
58
He can see out of their eyes so he doesn't have to fight with his eyes open so Itachi can't hit with Tsukuyomi, Nagato can also sense chakra.

Itachi got the summons when Nagato wasn't even paying attention to him, he was busy trying to suck Naruto's soul out and he was going to blast Bee's head off with his cannon, this time around he can easily use a Bansho Tennin or fire that Asura Path cannon at Itachi so he can't disable the Shared Vision.

Ah but look what you said, he wasn't paying attention yet he had all his summons all over the place and their shared vision. Even if I agreed that he wasn't paying attention and that his focus was on Naruto, he still was able to detect KillerBee.



Itachi was able to reach his blind spots even with this shared field of vision. If he knocks out all the summons' eyes, then Nagato would have to use his. Sensing chakra will not give him the same advantage as sage mode, if you were implying that.

But it is agreeable that Nagato may be able to protect his summons.
 

KidGamer65

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Aug 5, 2012
Messages
38,776
Reaction score
2,272
Ah but look what you said, he wasn't paying attention yet he had all his summons all over the place and their shared vision. Even if I agreed that he wasn't paying attention and that his focus was on Naruto, he still was able to detect KillerBee.



Itachi was able to reach his blind spots even with this shared field of vision. If he knocks out all the summons' eyes, then Nagato would have to use his. Sensing chakra will not give him the same advantage as sage mode, if you were implying that.

But it is agreeable that Nagato may be able to protect his summons.

Nagato only got Killer Bee because Bee came for him, Nagato didn't go for Bee, like he could do when Itachi attacks his summons, in the event he gets some of them, Nagato can just summon more.

Also I was just throwing it out there that he can sense chakra.

Nagato also has the Gedo Mazo to protect the summons in the event Nagato can't do it himself.
 
Top