Edo Nagato Mistake?

[copilot1307]

Should Edo Nagato have been revived with the Rinnegan, since it isn't originally his and therefore, his DNA should not have brought that back with him?

I realize that of course, he had to have been brought back with it for the sake of plot (Bringing back Nagato without Rinnegan would be pointless) but he technically should not have had it, right?

I suppose Kabuto could have fixed it like he fixed Madara's Edo; but still, the Rinnegan is Madara's and not assciated with Nagato's DNA, so logically, his Nagato's Edo should not possess it, right?

 

[shubzy123]

Madara's eyes were TRANSPLANTED into Nagato. Technically they belong to Nagato... But theyre still Madaras

 

[Cosman]

I think edo tensei revives a person exactly as they were when they died. Meaning their abilities and weaponry come with them regardless of where they got them from. Exactly how the gold and silver bros brought the kyuubi chakra with them when that residual chakra wasn't theirs.

The only exception is when someone makes "modifications" like Kabuto did for Madara and Oro did for the senju bros (minimizing their power).

Edo tensei is just a weird broken technique. But hey, I'm not complaining ^^

 

[Avonomemi]

Plausible
Do remember he awoke it himself too
So it kind of his also

 

[Avonomemi]

Plausible
Do remember he awoke it himself too
So it kind of his also

 

[Dęvîa Puęrî]

Yes he should have because he's had it for so long in NV. Just because the eyes r Someone else's doesn't mean u will have same exact powers like them they will grow with u and its powers would reflexed with how ur powers r


Hypothetically speaking if sasuke were to die and come back to u think it would be write for him to come back witH EMS ??
They're itachi's eyes

I mean Minato got revived with his kunai
Kakazu got revived with hearts tht weren't his to begin with

 

[Dęvîa Puęrî]

I think edo tensei revives a person exactly as they were when they died. Meaning their abilities and weaponry come with them regardless of where they got them from. Exactly how the gold and silver bros brought the kyuubi chakra with them when that residual chakra wasn't theirs.

The only exception is when someone makes "modifications" like Kabuto did for Madara and Oro did for the senju bros (minimizing their power).

Edo tensei is just a weird broken technique. But hey, I'm not complaining ^^

No if tht were case itachi wouldn't have eyes seeing as obits took them out and if he did they would b blind since he basically went blind right before he died

 

[Cosman]

No if tht were case itachi wouldn't have eyes seeing as obits took them out and if he did they would b blind since he basically went blind right before he died

No I mean the second they died. After he dies his body is fair game and doesn't count. I mean Nagato got his rinnegan jacked by Obito too before the war, but he was edo'd with them on.

I think it just resets the ability you've got, which is why Itachi came back with full vision. Nagato came back with the same crippled leg which is what led to believe that was the case.

 

[kotoamatsukami]

Should Edo Nagato have been revived with the Rinnegan, since it isn't originally his and therefore, his DNA should not have brought that back with him?

I realize that of course, he had to have been brought back with it for the sake of plot (Bringing back Nagato without Rinnegan would be pointless) but he technically should not have had it, right?

I suppose Kabuto could have fixed it like he fixed Madara's Edo; but still, the Rinnegan is Madara's and not assciated with Nagato's DNA, so logically, his Nagato's Edo should not possess it, right?

Nagato had the rennigan when he died so he was brought back with the rennigan.

 

[KidGamer65]

Edo Tensei revives you with all abilities you had in life. Rinnegan was an ability Nagato had in life so he gets it.

 

[kotoamatsukami]

Edo Tensei revives you with all abilities you had in life. Rinnegan was an ability Nagato had in life so he gets it.

Wrong as long as you had it when you died you can be brought back with it..if Nagato eyes wer removed befor he died he would not have then as an edo-tensi.

 

[htmwall]

following that logic madara shouldn't even has rinnegan since these eyes are izuna's.

 

[KidGamer65]

Wrong as long as you had it when you died you can be brought back with it..if Nagato eyes wer removed befor he died he would not have then as an edo-tensi.

Kabuto disagrees.

You must be registered for see links

Rinnegan was Nagato's ability so he gets to keep it. Whether or not he died with eyes has nothing to do with it.

 

[Nous]

You are revived in the same state that you died in. Nagato died with the Rin'negan, therefore he is revived with it as well. This explains Nagato's White Hair as well as Hiruzen's Elderly Body.

 

[KidGamer65]

You are revived in the same state that you died in. Nagato died with the Rin'negan, therefore he is revived with it as well. This explains Nagato's White Hair as well as Hiruzen's Elderly Body.

This as well.

 

[kotoamatsukami]

You are revived in the same state that you died in. Nagato died with the Rin'negan, therefore he is revived with it as well. This explains Nagato's White Hair as well as Hiruzen's Elderly Body.

This as well.

You agree with him he basically said the same thing I said you are brought back with what you died with.

 

[KidGamer65]

You agree with him he basically said the same thing I said you are brought back with what you died with.

You said that he wouldn't have his eyes if they had been removed before he died so I showed you why you were wrong. Partly wrong.

 

[kotoamatsukami]

You said that he wouldn't have his eyes if they had been removed before he died so I showed you why you were wrong. Partly wrong.

The other guy said "Nagato died with the rennigan there for he is revived with it aswell" same thing I said basically.