Edo Minato Fail!(Has more questions than Sasuke)

[Zelyix]

Minato can give Sasuke some info that the others cannot. Which are the attack of the leaf, he also is the most honest and seems to be the kindest of the Hokages. If Minato tells Sasuke that a "Masked Man" that proclaimed to Madara Uchiha attack the leaf using Kurama when Naruto was born, then Sasuke will quickly make the link to Tobi and ask about who he is. Seeing how Hiruzen and Sasuke knows that the only Uchiha which is still alive is Sasuke, then they might find out who Tobi really is on there own. Making Minato a valid person to have around, since Minato is the only one who knew Obito personally.

 

[Sharinganuser10]

He had questions to each one of the first three, so will have a question also for the 4th. Tobi told him the Uchiha were suspect in the kyuubi attack 16 years ago, and that led to the coup. Without a doubt Sasuke will want to find out what happened - and yes, maybe even why Naruto ended up with 9T.

That question could be answered better by Hiruzen since the suspicion would have arose AFTER the 9 tails attack which would mean AFTER the 4th Hokage died so what you said actually supports my point

 

[Sharinganuser10]

Let us Enlighten you... do you know why the massacare took place? Because leaf suspected Uchicha's were behind the whole summoning kurama act. That is leaf went ahead with the mission. How will you think Sasuke will feel knowing tobi was the cause of the final push towards their clan's annihilation?

OK Sasuke will Find out TObi tried to Crush the leaf, But how does that help Sasuke decide whether HE should crush the leaf or not. Your not getting the point of the thread. Just because Minato says something true or interesing to sasuke doesnt mean it is relevant to Sasuke's questions which is should he crush the leaf or not.

 

[Sharinganuser10]

@ title and OP.

Given the way Minato left this world and his newborn and the village .... as hokage

It's logical to conclude that he would have more questions than Sasuke anyways.

Also, I've never heard of having more questions than someone as a fail :\

I guess I don't share in your sense of humor in the slightest.

You misunderstand. Of course its logical for Minato to have questions because of the way he left the world. Thats why he should not have been resurrected so it is a fail resurrection because he has no answers that are relevant to sasuke's questions. Minato is not a fail for having more questions "Edo" Minato is a fail resurrection because he is irrelevant to the discussion.I hope that makes sense

 

[Naru2GT]

Prolly off topic, you think Minato will tell Sasake, that Naruto is his son??

 

[chancek7]

Minato will speak on the Kyuubi incident or about Naruto.

 

[Sasuke Uzumaki]

"OK Sasuke will Find out TObi tried to Crush the leaf, But how does that help Sasuke decide whether HE should crush the leaf or not. Your not getting the point of the thread. Just because Minato says something true or interesing to sasuke doesnt mean it is relevant to Sasuke's questions which is should he crush the leaf or not."

Sasuke's determination to crush the leaf came after Tobi had given his version about nine-tails attack and about the massacre of his clan, so if this story is not the true one and finds out Tobi had used the ninetiles for his own purposes... Sasuke may feel he is being manipulated which he hates, because he likes to believe he takes his own decisions.

That reason alone, and not suddenly loving the leaf, maytrigger his determination to be against Madara and Obito (which he still does not know to be different persons).