edo madara vs. edo hashirama.?

[dawoodahmad]

in people's top ten, they forget edo hashirama and add edo madara!?. what is the reason behing that?
hashirama > madara
edo hashirama > edo madara

 

[-S-]

Because Madara has fire release.

But Hashirama has will of fire release.

 

[saratobi sasuke]

Edo Madara>edo Hashirama

Madara's strength is already surpassed edo Hashi.

Reasons?

Madara knows all hashis moves/jutsu name it. (minor or ultimate jutsu)
Madara has Rennigan. Hashi dont
Madara has PS which he didn't use against Hashi in there last battle cause he didn't have Rennigan yet at that time.

 

[genii96]

Edo hashirama got pwned by old hiruzen alongside his brother,edo madara is schooling the 5 kages,see the difference?xd

 

[Chatte]

Edo hashirama got pwned by old hiruzen alongside his brother,edo madara is schooling the 5 kages,see the difference?xd

He was not in full control of his powers.

And if Edo Madara said that the only one who could stop him is Hashirama well I am sure that this will turn out to be a great battle...
The only difference between now and when they fought is that Madara has Rinnegan now.

 

[AmaniPaz]

Edo hashirama got pwned by old hiruzen alongside his brother,edo madara is schooling the 5 kages,see the difference?xd

LOL seriously man, c'mon son. Hashirama was not in full control of his powers. Its like a basketball player being controlled by someone else in a game. Only the basketball player knows his skills, his tactics and his limits. The person controlling him will just **** it up.

 

[KidGamer65]

Full powers or not Hashirama loses.

 

[BlkMagk]

Edo Madara

 

[USSJ Future Trunks]

And if Edo Madara said that the only one who could stop him is Hashirama well I am sure that this will turn out to be a great battle...

the comment was "only hashirama was ever able to stop me" and the VIZ translation confirms he didnt have perfect susano at VOTE. he never said hashirama can stop his current form. hes shown no sealing techs but madara has human path.

Hashirama was not in full control of his powers

neither was nagato or third raikage but no one ive seen berates those two for that.