Edo Madara < Edo Itachi

[Killer Vision]

I had a poll about who's the strongest uchiha at their prime & it was a landslide Madara domination.

I know eyeballs are rollin...but please my fellow members, explain why...

If Madara was so powerful, why is that Edo Itachi was able to break free from kabuto's control while Edo Madara has been reduced to a mere remote-controlled pawn of kabuto's arsenal?

Let the debate begin.

(Note: ill be throwing in ideas to your posts.)

 

[pensilol]

Do you read the manga?

 

[SSS12]

Because of a jutsu that's not even Itachi's.

 

[Punk Hazard]

madara is controlling himself

 

[UZUNaruto]

Nah!! Edo Madara is rooming free and Kabuto ain't controlling him..
Edo Madara has Rinnegan and wood release not to mention the power of EMS..
Edo Itachi was freed by Naruto(well the eye of Shusui to be exact) further he is actually in Genjutsu Kotoamatsukami. So???
Edo Madara>> Edo Itachi..

 

[CleverMonkey]

Itachi got his hands on a jutsu that Madara don't have

 

[Memoria]

Just because Itachi broke out of Edo Tensei's control doesn't mean he is > Madara, he broke out of it with the help of Shisui's eye, you're comparing characters who are really not in the same level in terms of power, Madara is far stronger than Itachi.

 

[TPM48]

I had a poll about who's the strongest uchiha at their prime & it was a landslide Madara domination.

I know eyeballs are rollin...but please my fellow members, explain why...

If Madara was so powerful, why is that Edo Itachi was able to break free from kabuto's control while Edo Madara has been reduced to a mere remote-controlled pawn of kabuto's arsenal?

Let the debate begin.

(Note: ill be throwing in ideas of my own as I read along your posts.)

Ur a very funny guy... When Itachi was alive, he expected that possibly one day someone might use the edo to bring him back. As a result, he made preparations for this. He didnt just break out on his own. It was Shisui s power which he placed in Naruto which helped him.

And even that doesnt make him stronger than edo madara. Edo madara has the rinnegan, which is like 2 levels above Itachi s mongekyo sharingan.

Read the manga bro.

 

[Vasto Lordé]

Madara > Itachi only by Hype and Mokuton, though we all know Totsuka blade got this <_< >_>

Give anyone a Mokuton and a Rinnegan and watch the magic...

And that power wasn't Itachi's it was Shisui, I'm sorry to say this but threads like these would never win, just cause people are determined to see what they wanna see.

 

[Punk Hazard]

Itachi got his hands on a jutsu that Madara don't have

considering madara was probably dead when shisui was alive, not a good argument

 

[Zlad]

Itachi is in Sasuke's level or slightly better. Madara is in god mode, get it?

 

[ronus]

Nah!! Edo Madara is rooming free and Kabuto ain't controlling him..
Edo Madara has Rinnegan and wood release not to mention the power of EMS..
Edo Itachi was freed by Naruto(well the eye of Shusui to be exact) further he is actually in Genjutsu Kotoamatsukami. So???
Edo Madara>> Edo Itachi..

This^.
Itachi is strong but not strong enough to be compared with Madara..:shrug:

 

[kmrasengan]

dude when madara got rinnegan when he was alive he became the strongest uchiha ever and just because itachi broke free from edo tensei with a genjutsu that doesn't belong to him doesn't make him stronger than madara.

 

[Deadai]

Omg did you really just ask that? Itachi only broke free by cuinsidance besides Madara has no reasion to brake out he is given a long leash so to speak so he can do most of what he wants :/

 

[Killer Vision]

I had a poll about who's the strongest uchiha at their prime & it was a landslide Madara domination.

I know eyeballs are rollin...but please my fellow members, explain why...

If Madara was so powerful, why is that Edo Itachi was able to break free from kabuto's control while Edo Madara has been reduced to a mere remote-controlled pawn of kabuto's arsenal?


Let the debate begin.

(Note: ill be throwing in ideas of my own as I read along your posts.)

This the question. im not asking if he was stronger per se.

Anyway TP48 got d riddle right. Itachi's advantage was his preparations.

 

[Solo]

According to Itachi, Madara is a loser.

 

[Killer Vision]

[/QUOTE]Ur a very funny guy...

Read the manga bro.[/QUOTE]

How can I be the funny guy if im the one surrounded by clowns...and for those asking "do you read manga" please read the thread first before posting in your sarcasm...and if you still can't get enuf of ur melodramatic "sarcasms", I'd be glad to have a debate with you anytime, any topic, anywhere so roll ur dices.

 

[Kratos of cruxis]

Ur a very funny guy... When Itachi was alive, he expected that possibly one day someone might use the edo to bring him back. As a result, he made preparations for this. He didnt just break out on his own. It was Shisui s power which he placed in Naruto which helped him.

And even that doesnt make him stronger than edo madara. Edo madara has the rinnegan, which is like 2 levels above Itachi s mongekyo sharingan.

Read the manga bro.

No itachi wanted naruto to fight sasuke and shuisui's eye to be use on sasuke it was a mistake that it was used on itachi

 

[Kristjan]

Madara > Itachi only by Hype and Mokuton, though we all know Totsuka blade got this <_< >_>

Give anyone a Mokuton and a Rinnegan and watch the magic...

And that power wasn't Itachi's it was Shisui, I'm sorry to say this but threads like these would never win, just cause people are determined to see what they wanna see.

Okey yamato already has mokuton and is a fodder with it now lets give him rinnegan and still it wount to him any good xd

 

[Punk Hazard]

This the question. im not asking if he was stronger per se.

Anyway TP48 got d riddle right. Itachi's advantage was his preparations.

but madara did break free..and he did it by himself