Edo flaw hiruzen.

[Summer]

So with recent chapters we see once again no logic to how edo really works I say this because of three points.

1: hiruzen was summoned old makes no sense why he is not in his prime. Minato prime/ tobirama prime/ hashirama prime. Seems like a flaw.

2: hashirama was said to have grown old and died :| yet he is in his prime we might see hints of how he really died.

3: this is the biggest troll yet madara he met obito and was really old and yet he was edo in his prime and so it makes me think that was not madara. But who cares about that right now

Multiple people have been shown now in there prime when summoned all but sarutobi did Kishi forget about the professor?

 

[The Western Wheel]

Everybody was edo'd at the time their demise EXCEPT Madara. As stated by Kabuto.\

 

[OnPoint]

- They have been summoned in the condition they were in when they died. It's no surprise that Hiruzen came back as an old man.

- It said he died in one of the raging wars of his era.

- Kabuto already said that Madara's Edo Tensei was special and that he was revived in a state greater than his prime; all the powers he acquired in life but in a youthful body.

 

[Summer]

Everybody was edo'd at the time their demise EXCEPT Madara. As stated by Kabuto.\

Yes but supposedly hashi grew old

 

[BREAKD]

I can't help but to keep thinking, where did it every state that edo people get revived in their prime?
Ofcource its logical, but hey, since when is kishi into the logical bit?

 

[Forbidden Twilight]

like he said and edo madara is no where no near as strong as he should really be, He is using hashi's powerup afterall and kabuto proved that

 

[FreakensteinAG]

hiruzen was summoned old makes no sense why he is not in his prime. Minato prime/ tobirama prime/ hashirama prime. Seems like a flaw.

Edo Tensei summons the dead as they were when they died. For instance, Chiyo died old and she was resurrected old. Minato and Tobirama sacrified their lives in their prime.

2. Hashirama is iffy

3. Hmm....

 

[Edo Odin]

The Edo's are resurrected like they were before they died. Hashirama didn't grow old, otherwise, Tobirama wouldn't have become Hokage at such a young age.

 

[-Raviel-]

they were all brought back the way they died and kabuto stated that he completed madara beyond his prime and as for hashirama maybe he didnt live as long as people think

 

[3MESSIAH]

hashirama didnt die old,he died out of unknown reason in the war,tobirama also died young when he fought those 20 elite shinobi and well minato also died young when he sealed the kyuubi.only madara was brought back to his prime

 

[Summer]

Edo Tensei summons the dead as they were when they died. For instance, Chiyo died old and she was resurrected old. Minato and Tobirama sacrified their lives in their prime.

2. Hashirama is iffy

3. Hmm....

Yeah so the Rumour of hashi growing old would be false then from all of this data.

 

[Elio]

1. Edo Tensei summons people when they died.

2. When was that stated? o.o

3. Kabuto modified Madara.

 

[HadouKage]

- They have been summoned in the condition they were in when they died. It's no surprise that Hiruzen came back as an old man.

- It said he died in one of the raging wars of his era.

- Kabuto already said that Madara's Edo Tensei was special and that he was revived in a state greater than his prime; all the powers he acquired in life but in a youthful body.

The Edo's are resurrected like they were before they died. Hashirama didn't grow old, otherwise, Tobirama wouldn't have become Hokage at such a young age.

It was also stated that he lived long enough to teach Tsunade to gamble, I'm sure she wasn't alive in his era

 

[ThomasJeffersonwasasadist]

They are brought back in the condition they died in unless otherwise specified (Madara). Hashirama didn't grow old he died in an unknown battle in a ninja war.

 

[Makoto]

*sigh* Hiruzen is in his prime because he doesn't lack stamina or chakra reserves anymore because of being edo. -.-

When will people get it?

 

[Multiply]

It was also stated that he lived long enough to teach Tsunade to gamble, I'm sure she wasn't alive in his era

We don't know how old she is. She is significantly older than Obito, and Minato. So it's quite possible she was alive in the later years of his life.

 

[Omnipotent]

It was also stated that he lived long enough to teach Tsunade to gamble, I'm sure she wasn't alive in his era

Which was still 50+ years ago, if you take Tsunade's age which is 54 to her appearance in that panel which is 3-4.