(DrProof) How The Sharingan Really Works.

[DrProof]

You contradict urself

Madara and Itachi has susano, madara destroys while itachi protects

Madara and Itachi have tsuukoyomi both, madara is warmonger while itachi is pacifist u say

Theyre opposing ideals, so it cant be uchiha ideals unlocking sharingan abilities!

It wasn't shown that Madara has either Tsukuyomi, nor Amaterasu. So until it is shown canonically he has it don't include the said techniques as if it were factual.

I am not contradicting myself. By the way it's yourself, not urself. Anyhow, Susano'o can be triggered by many ideals, but the many ideal is power, power to protect something that someone wants. Itachi uses Susano'o to protect the things he loves, and cares for. Madara uses Susano'o because he protects his arrogant ego, along with his plan (taking over the world; creating a new one with only winner) they're really not different.

The flaw thing is with this theory, is Itachi unlocked his Sharingan at age 8, became a pacifist when he murdered his clan. This Entire Thread is denoted on this single point.

Not really. This only pertains to Mangekyou Sharingan. Sorry if I was unclear about that.

 

[Naruto hinata]

define ideology

 

[DrProof]

define ideology

It's already explained in thread. In the quoting.

No madara used tsukuuyomi when he showed it to Obito telling him about his plan, even made himself look younger even if hes old inside genjutsu, thats tsuukoyomi

No, that was Izanagi. Izanagi turned Madara's illusion into reality.

 

[DrProof]

See here madara uses tsuko

You must be registered for see links

Admit ur wrong

Izanagi turns an illusion into reality, it uses eyes as well, and is considered a Genjutsu. However, you're most likely right. However, that still doesn't deconstruct my theory.

 

[Detective L]

Hmm,so their emotion unlocks the sharingan while their ideaology affects the abilities they get.Cool theory.

 

[DrProof]

Hmm,so their emotion unlocks the sharingan while their ideaology affects the abilities they get.Cool theory.

Exactly! However, do you agree?

 

[kimeramaximus04]

Extremely well put together. Honestly, great job

 

[DrProof]

Extremely well put together. Honestly, great job

Thanks mate.

 

[SIR HERDERP PRESIDERP SDO]

It certainly seems plausible, considering the variance of each Uchiha's Sharingan abilities and the colors of their Susanoo which could be tied with the user's temperament.

 

[kimeramaximus04]

How might this theory apply to kakashi and obito though. Even though they both retain the same ' genetic eye' they achieved their mangekyo sharingan through entirely didn't experiences.

 

[Detective L]

Exactly! However, do you agree?

Well,I do agree to a certain extent.If your theory is correct,it explains the variety of abilities,but on the other hand,would Kishi make it so complex?

 

[ziggyZ]

Oh wow fast reader then. What did you think about my theory though?

It's actually interesting and well thought out to say the least ^^

 

[Putokage]

i'm sure i'll get booed for this but correct me if i'm wrong.

tobi/kakashi have mangekyou sharingan right?

kakashi doesn't have susano'o and all we ever hear him say is"I won't let my comrades die"--this pertains to the wanting to protect part yes?
all Kakashi has is the 1 technique. we all know what it is: Kamui

>KAKASHI ISN'T AN UCHIHA!< you say?

True, but his and Tobi's eyes are linked. kakashi unlocked mangekyou for both of them with the act of killing Rin.
As you say it was tobi's emotional stress that unlocked it.

so if kakashi can't unlock sharingan powers by his OWN Ideology. He Must gain it from only tobi's ideology. If this was the case wouldn't he have access to much more that Kamui spam?

we know the other dimension is linked for the both of them, obviously the eyes are linked. so why hasn't Tobi shown more powers, or kakashi gained more?

 

[Sherlock.]

I agree.... Also their MS Powers are what they wanted the most when their MS awakened....
I had made a Theory on MS.... Here take a look.... Hope you enjoy it....

You must be registered for see links

 

[PredictionGuru]

Dr Common Knowledge.​

 

[DrProof]

i'm sure i'll get booed for this but correct me if i'm wrong.

tobi/kakashi have mangekyou sharingan right?

kakashi doesn't have susano'o and all we ever hear him say is"I won't let my comrades die"--this pertains to the wanting to protect part yes?
all Kakashi has is the 1 technique. we all know what it is: Kamui

>KAKASHI ISN'T AN UCHIHA!< you say?

True, but his and Tobi's eyes are linked. kakashi unlocked mangekyou for both of them with the act of killing Rin.
As you say it was tobi's emotional stress that unlocked it.

so if kakashi can't unlock sharingan powers by his OWN Ideology. He Must gain it from only tobi's ideology. If this was the case wouldn't he have access to much more that Kamui spam?

we know the other dimension is linked for the both of them, obviously the eyes are linked. so why hasn't Tobi shown more powers, or kakashi gained more?

The thing is.. Kakashi isn't of the Uchiha blood. This theory only applies to those of the Uchiha.

 

[FearxDeath]

Proof, as a favor to me I would like you to take on a theory of mine that Sasuke and Madara are related due to the fact that they both have Tsukyomi, although Madara may not have had kids Izuna may have, and the lore never really says he dies it merely says he gave up his sight to help Madara get his sight back. There may very well be a connection there.

I would/may tackle this theory in depth with scans and all but have been busy with a theory I will be posting within the hour and prb wont have time afterwards.

The thing is.. Kakashi isn't of the Uchiha blood. This theory only applies to those of the Uchiha.

Kakashi may not be of Uchiha blood but his sharingan is, and at the same time if he had a child that child would not have a sharingan. You can consider kakashi to be the exception that proves the rule.

 

[adeshina365]

Another excellent theory from Dr.Proof

 

[natzzz]

Nice theory but i alredy knew that.

 

[Varrah]

Bearing my layout.

You must be registered for see images

Firstly, Izanagi is a Sharingan technique, not a Mangekyō Sharingan technique.

Secondly, the workings around Sasuke's ideals, that stipulation you put forth is incorrect. Sasuke's ideals are of his own and do not adhere's to Itachi's [though by your own admission, your uncertainty shows as much].

I'm still along the lines that Uchiha worked similar to the Hyūga: housing many other families in their clan as they rose to prominence. Madara, Izuna, Itachi, and Sasuke come from a purer family within the clan, and as such, they received the pinnacle of Uchiha power. Obito and Shisui were birthed into a side family within the clan, and receive powers based off their families; this combines 'primarily' with their affinities and 'secondarily' their inheritance—dictating the techniques they gained. ​