[Theory] Dragon and Garp not related by blood

[I m an Ass]

Garp never said that Dragon is his son

For all we know Oda could be tricking us in believing this like he did with Ace
to catch us off guard and pull something like he is the most wanted man alive is because
he is Gol D Roger's brother you get me ?


think about this for a sec there is much proof to think that they could
not be related by blood

P.S
I still agree that luffy is Garp's blood grandson and his biological father is Dragon
no doubt

Luffy in terms of looks and personality wise is almost a copy of garp

You must be registered for see images

young Garp
and i think if luffy never ate the devil fruit he would look like this

You must be registered for see images

just a copy of Garp

but come on who in their right mind would think that this guy

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

=

You must be registered for see images

And the fact that we don't know who luffy's mother is makes it more suspicious

have you ever noticed that when people speak of Dragon and Roger people go crazy :hyper::hyper:
and the marines compare Dragon to Roger especially Akainu stating that he would never let those two escape
even Ace says to garp : me and Luffy have the blood of a demon (wouldn't he indirectly be insulting Garp too ? Unless...Garp is not related to Dragon )

Now if Dragon is compared to Roger wouldn't that mean that everyone who is related to him too must die too ?
So why does Sengoku or the Marine not hold any grudges against Garp.... maybe because Dragon is not Garp's son
...by blood he maybe his father in law.


what y'all think

 

[Olorin]

Monkey D Luffy
Monkey D Dragon
Monkey D Garp

in Aces case oda specifically gave hm a different name, now you could say Oda gave him a name different thad Gol D, but Portgas is still the name of one of* his parents

if what u were saying were true we would not knlw either Garpspr Dragons full name and one of them would have to have been named differently

even if we go by personality it doesn't mean they are not son, father and grandfather. not to mention we can still get to see dragon as a goof buy serious when and about what he needs to be (just like luffy)

 

[straightup]

Monkey D Luffy
Monkey D Dragon
Monkey D Garp

in Aces case oda specifically gave hm a different name, now you could say Oda gave him a name different thad Gol D, but Portgas is still the name of his parents

if what u were saying were true we would not knlw either Garpspr Dragons full name and one of them would have to have been named differently

even if we go by personality it doesn't mean they are not son, father and grandfather. not to mention we can still get to see dragon as a goof buy serious when and about what he needs to be (just like luffy)

rekt. /thread

 

[Rikudou Tobi]

Besides the last names that they share which is undoubtedly unquestionable that they are blood related, we haven't seen anything from Dragon personality wise to differentiate Dragon from his Father.

Even when Sengoku grabbed Garp and started yelling in his ears about his "family again" wouldn't that tell you that Dragon had his own fair troubles with the World Govt.?
Unlike Luffy who Garp can beat up over and over again with the fist of love, I don't think Garp can do that to someone of Dragon's caliber. They seem cordial with each other and they talk about the family.

 

[Uverdore9]

Theres something funny with family tree.

 

[Sir Blades]

Maybe Garp's wife was ugly as **** and that's why Garp and Dragon dont look very similar.

 

[kiiro]

Well both have the D so it could be true in some way.

 

[Caliburn]

Garp never said that Dragon is his son

For all we know Oda could be tricking us in believing this like he did with Ace
to catch us off guard and pull something like he is the most wanted man alive is because
he is Gol D Roger's brother you get me ?


think about this for a sec there is much proof to think that they could
not be related by blood

P.S
I still agree that luffy is Garp's blood grandson and his biological father is Dragon
no doubt

Luffy in terms of looks and personality wise is almost a copy of garp

You must be registered for see images

young Garp
and i think if luffy never ate the devil fruit he would look like this

You must be registered for see images

just a copy of Garp

but come on who in their right mind would think that this guy

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

=

You must be registered for see images

And the fact that we don't know who luffy's mother is makes it more suspicious

have you ever noticed that when people speak of Dragon and Roger people go crazy :hyper::hyper:
and the marines compare Dragon to Roger especially Akainu stating that he would never let those two escape
even Ace says to garp : me and Luffy have the blood of a demon (wouldn't he indirectly be insulting Garp too ? Unless...Garp is not related to Dragon )

Now if Dragon is compared to Roger wouldn't that mean that everyone who is related to him too must die too ?
So why does Sengoku or the Marine not hold any grudges against Garp.... maybe because Dragon is not Garp's son
...by blood he maybe his father in law.


what y'all think

Your argument is that because Luffy looks more like Garp than Dragon, Dragon isn't Garp's biological son? Dude, that's how genetics work. It doesn't matter whether Dragon is Garp's son or son in law as Luffy could take after any of his grandparents in both cases, just like Dragon could take after any of his grandparents. So this is not even relevant.

And no Dragon and Roger have barely or never been compared with each other. Akainu didn't make any comparison, he just acknowledged the potential threat Luffy and Ace posed and Ace himself compared himself with Luffy, not their fathers. It just happens that the both of them are the sons of infamous characters and I don't see how Garp would take offense at this as Ace was specifically referring to their fathers, not any other family members. Pretty sure Garp knows his son isn't the greatest role model out there.

Also Sengoku has on several occasions openly showed his anger towards Garp and his family. In the end though Garp was already in the marines long before Dragon was even born and considering his strength and reputation, going after him because of what his descendants do, is rather pointless. I don't think either the marines would make a distinction between a son or son in law as in both cases Garp wouldn't come out that pretty.

The fact that we know that many members of the Monkey D family is already rather exceptional, so there's nothing suspicious about not knowing Luffy's mother. Yes it would be interesting to see what kind of woman produced Luffy, but interesting is something different than suspicious.

Lastly just by reviewing what this would mean for the story, you can almost certainly discard this. First Oda makes Luffy and Ace brothers, then foster-brothers and after that cousins? And for some reason both Garp and Roger completely disregard the existence of Dragon, but Garp lets him get married into his family? What?

 

[Liquid Snake]

Monkey D Luffy
Monkey D Dragon
Monkey D Garp

in Aces case oda specifically gave hm a different name, now you could say Oda gave him a name different thad Gol D, but Portgas is still the name of one of* his parents

if what u were saying were true we would not knlw either Garpspr Dragons full name and one of them would have to have been named differently

even if we go by personality it doesn't mean they are not son, father and grandfather. not to mention we can still get to see dragon as a goof buy serious when and about what he needs to be (just like luffy)

Isnt aces real name Gol D Ace and garp gave him Portugas name? I could be wrong just asking

 

[chopstickchakra]

Isnt aces real name Gol D Ace and garp gave him Portugas name? I could be wrong just asking

His name is Gol D Ace but he calls himself Portgas because he hated his father. Ace knew he was Rogers son and would attack people for mentioning him in general iirc.

 

[Liquid Snake]

His name is Gol D Ace but he calls himself Portgas because he hated his father. Ace knew he was Rogers son and would attack people for mentioning him in general iirc.

Yea i know ace hates roger and everything and why he claims whitebeard as his father and wasnt it garp who really changed it to portgas

 

[chopstickchakra]

Yea i know ace hates roger and everything and why he claims whitebeard as his father and wasnt it garp who really changed it to portgas

I don't think so but I could be wrong. I thought it said it was Ace's choice but I could be wrong. Unless Garp told Dadan his name was portgas and Dadan told Ace I don't know a time when Garp and Ace really interacted.

 

[Liquid Snake]

I don't think so but I could be wrong. I thought it said it was Ace's choice but I could be wrong. Unless Garp told Dadan his name was portgas and Dadan told Ace I don't know a time when Garp and Ace really interacted.

Yea but i think garp would change the name to protect ace from the navy