[Discussion] Donquixote Officers

[chopstickchakra]

This is excluding the elite officers Diamante, Pica, Trebol.

Of the officers, which Strawhats do you think they could beat in a 1v1 and explain why.

Sugar
Viola
Jora
Lao G
Senor Pink
Machvise
Gladius
Dellinger
Baby 5
Buffalo
Monet

I personally don't see any of them beating Luffy, Zoro, Sanji, Robin, Franky or Brook. Gladius might be able to beat Franky because his DF allows him to explode inanimate objects which is 80% of Franky's body so if he touched him he could theoretically explode him as well.

 

[OG sama]

They all lose to the M3 obviously, not even the seats can beat the M3. Monet could beat Robin or Brook due to them not having anything that can hurt her. Franky can probably beat them all maybe not Gladius though. Like you said.

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

All of the SHs can beat Buffalo.
All of the SHs can beat Viola.
All of the SHs can beat Jora.
All of the SHs can beat Machvise.
All of the SHs except for Robin can beat Sugar. Sugar's DF is a good counter to Robin's.
All of the SHs except for Nami and Usopp can beat Baby 5.
All of the SHs except for Chopper, Nami, and Usopp can beat Monet. Assuming Logia intangibility is turned off.
All of the SHs except for Chopper, Nami, and Usopp can beat Dellinger. Would be a high-extreme diff fight for Brook though.
All of the SHs except for Brook, Chopper, Nami, and Usopp can beat Senor Pink.
All of the SHs except for Brook, Chopper, Nami, and Usopp can beat Lao G. Would be high diff for Robin and extreme diff for Franky.
Only the M3 can beat Gladius (each can low diff him). Franky is inorganic so Gladius blows him up. Gladius can just use Metpunk to escape Robin's clutch.