[Theory] does jack represent the famine horsemen of the four horsemen???
- Thread starter Lance171
- Start date
jiraiya lives
Active member
Don Q? .... Dofailmingo? nah if anything it'd be someone in kaido's crew. Doffy is just a branch to the immediate crew.
chopstickchakra
Active member
There's only 3 calamities so probably not, unless I'm misunderstanding you. They would all have to be on the same crew to reflect the 4 horsemen and would have to serve under someone as well.
Uzumaki Macho
Active member
Your Creepy Stalker
Active member
Awards
Doubt it. Only one of them has a horse, and Jack wouldn't make a good Famine anyway. Even if there were four horsemen, Doc Q isn't badass enough to outrank Kaido.
chopstickchakra
Active member
Yea but that wouldn't work unless kaidou also served under someone, Kaidou's the boss he can't be a horseman as well, the horsemen would serve him. Also for it to be a reflection of the 4 horsemen they'd have to be together so Doc Q couldn't also be one or the correlation doesn't work.
As said before he can only represent one of the four horsemen if he is part of a group of four, otherwise it's meaningless. Doc Q has absolutely nothing to do with Kaidou or Jack, now you are just randomly selecting characters so that it suits your hypothesis. That way you can find countless of characters who fit the profile. There are many characters that can be associated with war, death or conquest, hence the only possible way of this being true is that Jack is part of a clearly defined group. Considering there are only three Calamities, not four, it's unlikely Oda intentionally made him represent famine. Unless of course you count Kaidou in the bunch, but then it means one of the four is higher than the others, which doesn't really rhyme with the concept of the horsemen.
Not to mention the Yonkou itself could be considered the four horsemen. Big Mum = famine, BB = conquest, Kaidou = war and Shanks = death. It's rather easy to see something like the four horsemen if you want to see it. This is also why exactly they are the four horsemen: because they have a universal character.
Not to mention the Yonkou itself could be considered the four horsemen. Big Mum = famine, BB = conquest, Kaidou = war and Shanks = death. It's rather easy to see something like the four horsemen if you want to see it. This is also why exactly they are the four horsemen: because they have a universal character.
the fourth horseman of death is all the horsemen combined so kaido could be death. I was more looking at it from the stand point of the final WG war arc that maybe black beard and kaido would team up and then the four horsemen would be united. idk though just speculation but it could also go for just kaido's crew with jack being famine and kaido being death. jack works perfectly for famine because he causes drought which in turn equals famine. btw it wasn't cool to ban me like two month ago just cause you were being a Debbie downer.
Now you are just forcing things. The final arc of OP could go into any direction. There are countless of possible scenarios and there is nothing that points towards any kind of collaboration between BB and Kaidou and even if that would be the case, there would be no reason to randomly pick out characters from their respective crews and call them the four horsemen. It's meaningless if there is no distinguishable group of four people.
And I don't even remember you. I have banned a lot of people and all of them were justified. If I banned you, it means you completely deserved it. I'm a realist, I say how it is. Fooling yourself doesn't help anyone, so if you only expect people to agree with what you say and ignore all the flaws, you're in the wrong place.