Do you agree with the villages treatment of the Jinchuurikis and Uchihas?

[mikeeozua]

As we all know, the Jinchuuriki's were all isolated and lonely because people always stayed away from them. But do you think their motives were reasonable? I mean wouldn't you keep your children away from them just in case? We know from Gaara's case that they could break out at any moment. Also Tobirama experienced the symptons that drove the Uchihas to hatred and insanity so he tried to distance them to protect the people of Konoha.

But on the other side, we need to consider the emotions of the Jinchuuriki and the Uchihas. For the Jinchuuriki, by isolating them, the village could be potentially turning them into the exact thing they did not want them to turn into: a monster. Instead of taking the route of isolation, maybe they could have involved them into more activities and gradually make them feel welcome into the society like with Naruto and Bee's case. And for the Uchihas, they could have been based in the very centre of Konoha. This would have got them to interact more with the people of Konoha, and give them something to protect.

So anyway what are your opinions?

 

[Zuru]

I understand that they wanted to keep them isolated to avoid tension, but by making them be isolated, they caused them to hate the village, or feel deep sadness. I feel that this would cause them to hate the villages even more, and cause problems other then avoiding them.

 

[Nous]

Why is reasonable but still unjustified - specially if theyre a child or an orphan,

 

[abcdefgh]

The Uchiha Massacre was better than having another Madara appearing when Hashirama's not around.

 

[Fodder#4]

For the Jinchuurikis, no. . Doesn't seem rational for the government itself to outcast and NOT improve their best weapon. For villagers to hate or fear them? Yes. It is rational for them to not trust the carrier of a demon that killed their leader and attacked their village. Plus, they most likely do not understand the way seals work and are unsure if Kurama could break out at any time.



For the Uchiha's? Yes. They planned a revolt and got what they deserved. Though, I personally would have tried to be more diplomatic and not wipe out a clan, they were rather powerful and in case of war or attack they would be very useful. But if your back is against the wall. . .Gotta let the Uchiha die.

 

[Totsuka gg Amaterasu gg]

For the Jinchuurikis, no. . Doesn't seem rational for the government itself to outcast and NOT improve their best weapon. For villagers to hate or fear them? Yes. It is rational for them to not trust the carrier of a demon that killed their leader and attacked their village. Plus, they most likely do not understand the way seals work and are unsure if Kurama could break out at any time.



For the Uchiha's? Yes. They planned a revolt and got what they deserved. Though, I personally would have tried to be more diplomatic and not wipe out a clan, they were rather powerful and in case of war or attack they would be very useful. But if your back is against the wall. . .Gotta let the Uchiha die.

this ^^^^^^ Danzou and Itachi were righteous

 

[EliteRamenNinja]

Yes. Uchiha's need to die. Sorry.

Grtz, mankind.

 

[Champ]

No the Uchiha's should've took over the Village

 

[DylanSwerve]

Its resembling our society; say a there was a young boy whose dad was a mass murderer. We wouldn't accept the boy because of his father's actions. Same with the Uchiha and Jinchuuriki. Because of Madara's actions, the rest of the Uchiha (minus a select few) couldn't be trusted. And because the Nine tails caused so much damage, the vessel that carries him isn't accepted.

 

[Cosman]

The Uchihas are a soft clan. "BOO We were isolated. Boohoo." They rationalized this by trying to destroy Konoha. What kind of morons think that's a good idea? They got what was coming to them, I'm sorry. The treatment they received wasn't very fair, but the way they reacted to it proved Tobirama somewhat right.

The jinchuurikis never warranted such prejudice. In fact what Naruto, Killer Bee, and Gaara had to sacrifice was all for the betterment of their village (for the most part). Most of these jinchuurikis were pressured or forced into becoming one.

That being said, wiping all the uchihas out was probably not a good idea. And it wasn't "the village" that treated them that way and wiped them out. It was a select few of the higher ups in Konoha. The rest of the civilians treated them like gods.