[Discussion] Do u guys think Luffy acc defeated Shiki?

[sage1999]

According to Oda, it is canon. But how can a guy who managed to take on Sengoku and Garp, and seriusly injure them, lose to a pre Haki Luffy.


IMO shiki can be used or nother nteresting plot device, such as that he could kill Big Mom and take over her yonko status, and work with BB or even Enel and wreck havoc. This would have been a much better fight than the fodder Shiki vs Luffy.

 

[Naruto rikuduo mode]

movies are not cannon

 

[IndraGripen]

movies are not cannon

exactly

 

[WhistleBlower]

Yes , according to the movie. This said movies are not cannon, meaning irrelevant to the main story.

Although, seeing Shiki again would be nice. He seems like a man who can cause quite a stir hehe

 

[MartinRico]

According to Oda, it is canon. But how can a guy who managed to take on Sengoku and Garp, and seriusly injure them, lose to a pre Haki Luffy.


IMO shiki can be used or nother nteresting plot device, such as that he could kill Big Mom and take over her yonko status, and work with BB or even Enel and wreck havoc. This would have been a much better fight than the fodder Shiki vs Luffy.

The history of Shiki is canon, but not the events of the movie he was in.

 

[VongolaX]

The history of Shiki is canon, but not the events of the movie he was in.

^^This exactly, as far as canon is concerned...

Shiki vs luffy match has gone untainted this far.

In the movie they pulled a Crocodile because he was introduced too early, he was way stronger, he best luffy 2/3 of their fight, and his lose was just unrealistic.

 

[BigGuns Reloaded]

He is rubber he can attract lightning can't remember it that's what he did but both his fight against shiki and z had the biggest plot shields

 

[Legend Slayer]

His defeat was badass though.