did she deserve it yes, did he have to smack her like that no, but she REALLY looked like she was asking for it when she smacked him, i mean what do you expect when your a full grown up THAT CAN THINK and you play with fire ?? YOU GET BUREND U_U but he should have resolved to something other than slapping her back like taking her in coz assaulting a police officer is a serious crime, yet he just slaped her back, an eye for an eye and we will be both blind so no he really shouldn't have done it he can hurt her badly