Did Kishimoto's assistant mislead/lie to the SS fandom?

[Darth Uchiha]

It's obvious Karin is not her mother. That DNA sample that Suigetsu used was probably sasuke's DNA, and it was in karin's desk because she probably wanted to clone him or something lol, so the DNA test matched because Sasuke is sarada's father.

You do know that you can tell the *** of an individual based on their DNA, right? The sample would have been female.

 

[V h o]

Even though I think what Kishi is doing is horrible and disrespectful to the characters involved and the fans, I will let go of my personal preferences for the time being.

Kishi's assistant lied because he had to, otherwise the plot of Gaiden would be spoiled, the same goes with all of Kishi's post-ending interviews, content, and character descriptions. This is the malicious truth.

The theme of this Gaiden is bonds and relationships going beyond genetics. This chapter was dialogue heavy just to further establish that. Sakura immediately disagrees with what Shin says about parenting being about genetics and that that isn't what being a parent is about.

There is no point to all this dialogue, all this time wasted, if Sarada is not related to Karin. Furthermore, there is no lesson to be learned for Sarada if she just ends up being Sakura's birth child. At the end of this chapter, Sarada throws a fit over not being Sakura's biological daughter and doesn't even acknowledge her as her mother. Which is completely wrong because a mother goes beyond genetics. Who raises you is your parent. Which is the theme that has been established in this very chapter. Once again, if Sakura is the biological mother, then there is nothing to learn for Sarada. There is no life lesson, their lives would go back to as they were at the beginning of the Gaiden and there would be no point.

Now all I can hope for is for the way this all went down and the reason behind this is properly justified, and does not involve cheating, for Sakura, Sasuke, and Sarada's sake. My current guess is that Karin helped Sasuke and Sakura by being a surrogate of somekind because Sakura couldn't conceive.

Probably the only way to make sense of it. Although I feel the last 2 (when they fought shin) talking about whose at fault might imply the cheating Zzz

 

[King Of Pop]

Even though I think what Kishi is doing is horrible and disrespectful to the characters involved and the fans, I will let go of my personal preferences for the time being.

Kishi's assistant lied because he had to, otherwise the plot of Gaiden would be spoiled, the same goes with all of Kishi's post-ending interviews, content, and character descriptions. This is the malicious truth.

The theme of this Gaiden is bonds and relationships going beyond genetics. This chapter was dialogue heavy just to further establish that. Sakura immediately disagrees with what Shin says about parenting being about genetics and that that isn't what being a parent is about.

There is no point to all this dialogue, all this time wasted, if Sarada is not related to Karin. Furthermore, there is no lesson to be learned for Sarada if she just ends up being Sakura's birth child. At the end of this chapter, Sarada throws a fit over not being Sakura's biological daughter and doesn't even acknowledge her as her mother. Which is completely wrong because a mother goes beyond genetics. Who raises you is your parent. Which is the theme that has been established in this very chapter. Once again, if Sakura is the biological mother, then there is nothing to learn for Sarada. There is no life lesson, their lives would go back to as they were at the beginning of the Gaiden and there would be no point.

Now all I can hope for is for the way this all went down and the reason behind this is properly justified, and does not involve cheating, for Sakura, Sasuke, and Sarada's sake. My current guess is that Karin helped Sasuke and Sakura by being a surrogate of somekind because Sakura couldn't conceive.

dunno why people say the bold as a form of evidence. sakura was simply trying to clarify to shin what being a parent means because his own idea is twisted. her not supposedly being the biological mother doesnt mean she wont reply the same way she did because she would. even if she is the biological mother, she would still tell shin the same thing. agree with the rest tho

OT. mayb, mayb not. we shall see

Probably the only way to make sense of it. Although I feel the last 2 (when they fought shin) talking about whose at fault might imply the cheating Zzz

no, it doesnt imply anything. hes simply taking the blame for everything and not something specific. like his absence for example and why he was away is part of it because sarada left to come find him afterall. if he was with them, that would not have happened

 

[Handsome Jack]

He was lying, he can't reveal the plot twist until kishimoto does it.

And how would you know.

 

[iNotorious]

And how would you know.

I'm kishimoto's daughter.

 

[Endles Waltz]

Probably the only way to make sense of it. Although I feel the last 2 (when they fought shin) talking about whose at fault might imply the cheating Zzz

No he was apologizing for Sarada's whole situation, running off looking for him and being uneasy, remember he never met her for years because of his mission.

It wasn't cheating, that would be immoral and OOC, and wouldn't make sense for Karin to just let go of Sarada, Karin was probably just helping them one way or another like I previously said.

dunno why people say the bold as a form of evidence. sakura was simply trying to clarify to shin what being a parent means because his own idea is twisted. her not supposedly being the biological mother doesnt mean she wont reply the same way she did because she would. even if she is the biological mother, she would still tell shin the same thing. agree with the rest tho

OT. mayb, mayb not. we shall see


no, it doesnt imply anything. hes simply taking the blame for everything and not something specific. like his absence for example and why he was away is part of it because sarada left to come find him afterall. if he was with them, that would not have happened

If she was the biological mother she would have said the same thing, but the mere fact that the issue what brought up and she said that is set up and foreshadowing that she didn't pass her genes to Sarada.

 

[MAN OF SIN]

It's obvious Karin is not her mother. That DNA sample that Suigetsu used was probably sasuke's DNA, and it was in karin's desk because she probably wanted to clone him or something lol, so the DNA test matched because Sasuke is sarada's father.

How could she possibly get Sasuke's umbilical cord?

 

[Handsome Jack]

I'm kishimoto's daughter.

Wow. I've been blind all this time then, wat's his favorite fish.

 

[zeezzay]

Even though I think what Kishi is doing is horrible and disrespectful to the characters involved and the fans, I will let go of my personal preferences for the time being.

Kishi's assistant lied because he had to, otherwise the plot of Gaiden would be spoiled, the same goes with all of Kishi's post-ending interviews, content, and character descriptions. This is the malicious truth.

The theme of this Gaiden is bonds and relationships going beyond genetics. This chapter was dialogue heavy just to further establish that. Sakura immediately disagrees with what Shin says about parenting being about genetics and that that isn't what being a parent is about.

There is no point to all this dialogue, all this time wasted, if Sarada is not related to Karin. Furthermore, there is no lesson to be learned for Sarada if she just ends up being Sakura's birth child. At the end of this chapter, Sarada throws a fit over not being Sakura's biological daughter and doesn't even acknowledge her as her mother. Which is completely wrong because a mother goes beyond genetics. Who raises you is your parent. Which is the theme that has been established in this very chapter. Once again, if Sakura is the biological mother, then there is nothing to learn for Sarada. There is no life lesson, their lives would go back to as they were at the beginning of the Gaiden and there would be no point.

Now all I can hope for is for the way this all went down and the reason behind this is properly justified, and does not involve cheating, for Sakura, Sasuke, and Sarada's sake. My current guess is that Karin helped Sasuke and Sakura by being a surrogate of somekind because Sakura couldn't conceive.

I dont think sasuke cheated on sakura, he was with karin had *** with her obviously. But they split for what ever reason so then he was with sakura, but karin came told them she was prego, considering how sakura would give sadarra much better life she took salad as her own

 

[Endles Waltz]

I dont think sasuke cheated on sakura, he was with karin had *** with her obviously. But they split for what ever reason so then he was with sakura, but karin came told them she was prego, considering how sakura would give sadarra much better life she took salad as her own

What do you think this is some kind of Soap Opera? Seriously read what you just wrote lol. This is Shounen, Sasuke pretty much committed to Sakura in 699 and showed no interest in any other person (you can tell by The Last and her novel), there was no cheating or pimping involved, there are many unconventional ways of conceiving babies, especially in Naruto.

 

[Deadmed]

I'm me.



Not that you would believe me if I said yes.



That's unnecessary, but you wouldn't know that as you have no knowledge in the field of psychology. Your posts frequently consist of idiocy, so believe me when I say your entire character can be boiled down to one word: idiosyncratic



Most probably a chain of retarded thoughts and ass licking all based around a fictitious character.



What you just said above proves why I call you stupid. It is a fact that if you stab yourself you will get hurt, yet there is no mathematical equation that can surmise this. Do you go to school?



For me to have personal feelings for you would mean I care about you, and quite frankly, I don't. As far as I'm concerned you're no better than a cockroach.



Take your L and FOH.

You must be registered for see images

Hey now Femme is awesome let her do her thing

 

[Shruikan]

Even though I think what Kishi is doing is horrible and disrespectful to the characters involved and the fans, I will let go of my personal preferences for the time being.

Kishi's assistant lied because he had to, otherwise the plot of Gaiden would be spoiled, the same goes with all of Kishi's post-ending interviews, content, and character descriptions. This is the malicious truth.

The theme of this Gaiden is bonds and relationships going beyond genetics. This chapter was dialogue heavy just to further establish that. Sakura immediately disagrees with what Shin says about parenting being about genetics and that that isn't what being a parent is about.

There is no point to all this dialogue, all this time wasted, if Sarada is not related to Karin. Furthermore, there is no lesson to be learned for Sarada if she just ends up being Sakura's birth child. At the end of this chapter, Sarada throws a fit over not being Sakura's biological daughter and doesn't even acknowledge her as her mother. Which is completely wrong because a mother goes beyond genetics. Who raises you is your parent. Which is the theme that has been established in this very chapter. Once again, if Sakura is the biological mother, then there is nothing to learn for Sarada. There is no life lesson, their lives would go back to as they were at the beginning of the Gaiden and there would be no point.

Now all I can hope for is for the way this all went down and the reason behind this is properly justified, and does not involve cheating, for Sakura, Sasuke, and Sarada's sake. My current guess is that Karin helped Sasuke and Sakura by being a surrogate of somekind because Sakura couldn't conceive.

You keep saying surrogacy yet why would a MC's kid be involved in such shit?This is unprecedented

 

[Endles Waltz]

You keep saying surrogacy yet why would a MC's kid be involved in such shit?

I mentioned it in my comment, to convey this "theme" of bonds>DNA.

That's just 1 of many possibilities though.

This is unprecedented

True.

 

[Mikasa Hagaromo]

What do you think this is some kind of Soap Opera? Seriously read what you just wrote lol. This is Shounen, Sasuke pretty much committed to Sakura in 699 and showed no interest in any other person (you can tell by The Last and her novel), there was no cheating or pimping involved, there are many unconventional ways of conceiving babies, especially in Naruto.

You must be registered for see images

As you can see,a SS fan PMed his assistant and he replied:

"Karin has nothing to do with Salad"


Was he lying here OR has the majority of the Gaiden been a huge troll and a smokescreen to be cleared next few chapters? (3 to be precise)

Well, the assistants aren't necessarily privy to the author's future plans. He wasn't necessarily lying but thought that was the end of the series and had no knowledge of Kishi's plans for part 3.

 

[Vulpini]

Dude, love your sig

 

[lndra]

Kishimoto's assistant lied when someone asked them if Madara was the final villain.

So yes :lol

 

[shelke]

So far, it does appear to be nothing more than a red herring to me. SS is too popular in Japan to ignore, when Kishimoto went by the popular opinion for the end-game.

There's a possibility that Orochimaru has taken over Karin's body. If so, last chapter could have been one giant setup and a smokescreen. Regardless, we'll find out soon enough. Gaiden would still be terrible though, irrespective of whether it's a troll or not.

Stealing my theories, are you? :bdpf:

 

[zeezzay]

What do you think this is some kind of Soap Opera? Seriously read what you just wrote lol. This is Shounen, Sasuke pretty much committed to Sakura in 699 and showed no interest in any other person (you can tell by The Last and her novel), there was no cheating or pimping involved, there are many unconventional ways of conceiving babies, especially in Naruto.

Mates ur calling that I am making soap opera, when is already clear the manga has became official soap opera with all this mama drama
Yep the last was nh not sasuke, this manga is about sadarra were getting more and more info so in few chpts it will be show whats with sadarra, karin, sakura, sasuke

 

[Endles Waltz]

Mates ur calling that I am making soap opera, when is already clear the manga has became official soap opera with all this mama drama
Yep the last was nh not sasuke, this manga is about sadarra were getting more and more info so in few chpts it will be show whats with sadarra, karin, sakura, sasuke

No, people like yourself are making it out to be a soap opera, in the end it is a very simple shounen, Sasuke married Sakura and Kishi won't retcon that into a love triangle, he is just playing with gullible people with creative deranged minds. :lol

But I agree that we will find out the whole truth in a few chapters, let's wait and see.

 

[Amaterasu]

It's a lie.

Karin is a relative