Debate: Orochimaru [NSUNSR] vs Deidara [Zexion]

[TRE MERCER]

people are underrating deidara go zexion baby!

pause!​

 

[Rιver]

Is this a troll post? If not, this judgment doesn't count. It's totally incomplete. You didn't actually say why Zexion won the debate or explain how he brought the better argument. Completely unfair to the debaters (especially NSUNSR) that this sloppy judgment should hold the same merit as Icelerate's, who went in depth explaining his reasoning on why he thought NSUNSR won. From reading this I have no way of knowing if you even read the debate or not.

Lol .

 

[Zexion~]

Is this a troll post? If not, this judgment doesn't count. It's totally incomplete. You didn't actually say why Zexion won the debate or explain how he brought the better argument. Completely unfair to the debaters (especially NSUNSR) that this sloppy judgment should hold the same merit as Icelerate's, who went in depth explaining his reasoning on why he thought NSUNSR won. From reading this I have no way of knowing if you even read the debate or not.

While I agree it was small, saying Ice's is the perfect example of a judgement is wrong. Its not the judges responsibility to explain their opinions and idea's on the debaters arguments down to the very last detail that is something the debaters can ask for.

The perfect argument is

-Summary of the main important arguments
-Verdicts on who won/why they won in said arguments
-Overall verdict with extra reasoning and comments on debating style/vocabulary and other shit

Ice is overdoing it.

Agreed, saying that judgement was half-assed would be a compliment.

Bashing you're own twin.....how low.

 

[EZQ]

Are river and apex brothers?

 

[Zexion~]

Are river and apex brothers?

Yes indeed

 

[Beans2]

While I agree it was small, saying Ice's is the perfect example of a judgement is wrong. Its not the judges responsibility to explain their opinions and idea's on the debaters arguments down to the very last detail that is something the debaters can ask for.

The perfect argument is

-Summary of the main important arguments
-Verdicts on who won/why they won in said arguments
-Overall verdict with extra reasoning and comments on debating style/vocabulary and other shit

Ice is overdoing it.


Bashing you're own twin.....how low.

My point isn't that Ice's judgment is a perfect judgment,, I was just comparing his to River's and explained how Ice's was better because it explained his reasoning.

 

[Zexion~]

My point isn't that Ice's judgment is a perfect judgment,, I was just comparing his to River's and explained how Ice's was better because it explained his reasoning.

Technically a judge merely is there to let people know the verdict :lol everything else is extra.

He stated which way he thought the arguments went and how many I won and how many NSUNR won :lol

Only arguing this because no one else will ever judge it.

 

[KidGamer65]

I hope this dude isn't defending River's judgement.

 

[Zexion~]

I hope this dude isn't defending River's judgement.

I am sort of, its terrible but in the end a judge is supposed to deliver a verdict.

 

[KidGamer65]

I am sort of, its terrible but in the end a judge is supposed to deliver a verdict.

............

A verdict with zero reasoning behind it has an equal amount of weight behind it. Zero.

 

[Zexion~]

............

A verdict with zero reasoning behind it has an equal amount of weight behind it. Zero.

Not really :lol as usually the judge being a judge is weight enough.

 

[KidGamer65]

Not really :lol as usually the judge being a judge is weight enough.

Either you are only pulling this BS because he voted for you, or you are actually crazy enough to think that a judge can waltz in and say "X" wins the debate w/o providing any kind of logical reasoning as to why he thinks "X" won the debate. Explanations are exactly why poor judgements can be called out in the first place.

No explanation=No weight behind judgement. Being a declared a judge doesn't change that. It's really that simple. No reason to take anyone's opinion seriously if they can't produce a reason as for why they believe such.

 

[Zexion~]

Either you are only pulling this BS because he voted for you, or you are actually crazy enough to think that a judge can waltz in and say "X" wins the debate w/o providing any kind of logical reasoning as to why he thinks "X" won the debate. Explanations are exactly why poor judgements can be called out in the first place.

No explanation=No weight behind judgement. Being a declared a judge doesn't change that. It's really that simple. No reason to take anyone's opinion seriously if they can't produce a reason as for why they believe such.

No.

He produced a reason, :lol he said I won the majority of the arguments.

I mean, not many reasoning is provided for the good ol' Guilty/Not Guilty, But those are some pretty heavy judgings :lol


All i'm saying is that judges going by the norm, usually just provide verdicts. Opinions are extra.

 

[Nattana]

Okay, I will be the last judge.

NSUNSR won in the majority of the arguments ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

Ans since I'm a judge, in the end I'm supposed to deliver a verdict ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

NSUNSR wins. Orochimaru >>> Deidara ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

 

[KidGamer65]

Okay, I will be the last judge.

NSUNSR won in the majority of the arguments ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

Ans since I'm a judge, in the end I'm supposed to deliver a verdict ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

NSUNSR wins. Orochimaru >>> Deidara ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

Lmfao.

This is essentially the shit logic you are using Zex. :lol Stop it.

 

[Apêx1]

Are river and apex brothers?

I most definitely do not have a brother with an extra chromosome.

 

[EZQ]

I most definitely do not have a brother with an extra chromosome.

OT: I could be the judge but i'm not good at it and i already gave my toughts on this fight on this same thread, so my veredict would be biased. Sorry.

Why doesn't anyone else just do it. C'mon for the sake of the tourney

 

[Nate Standfield]

I'll judge if need be, I have more experience then my kawaii pony picture shows.

 

[Zexion~]

Lmfao.

This is essentially the shit logic you are using Zex. :lol Stop it.

He clearly had previous bias .-.

I'll judge if need be, I have more experience then my kawaii pony picture shows.

No because you're tight at me XD

 

[Nate Standfield]

I'm only tight on Latino men. Let me prove myself.